Diana Henry's Baked Chicken with Mustard and Herbs

Thank you all so much for your incredibly warm and lovely messages! It's so nice to be back and know that all of you are out there still reading.

Today I'm going to tell you about how I deal with the daily grind of WTF AM I MAKING FOR DINNER TONIGHT that makes even the most eager cook a little, shall we say, itchy. I don't know how many of you here are also following me on Instagram, where I mentioned this new way of meal planning back in January, so forgive me if this is a little repetitive, but I really do find it such a helpful way of working through the constant and unrelenting chore of having dinner on the table every evening that perhaps it can be useful to a few of you too.

Here's what I do: rather than sit down and write down a whole menu for each day of the week when meal planning (which was time consuming and eventually felt very…uninteresting and difficult), I decided to assign specifically themed meals to specific days of the week in a much looser fashion. Like this: On Mondays, we eat pasta. On Tuesdays, it's beans. Wednesdays are for chicken. Thursdays are soups or stews. Fridays is for fish. (Weekends are a free-for-all.) What this allows me is much more flexibility and also more rigidity at the same time, but in a way that feels both freeing and safe. Do you know what I mean?

Since Mondays are for pasta, it means that the week starts out very gently. All I need to do is make a pot of tomato sauce, which I could do in my sleep, and some green vegetable (sometimes, yes, it's just a sliced cucumber because I am only human, other times it's steamed broccoli or boiled chard). Dinner is very easy and almost always drama-free, because the boys both eat noodles and everyone's happy. It allows me to start the week off feeling somewhat capable and in control.

Tuesday is bean day and I usually end up making some kind of simple bean situation in the Instant Pot. This recipe (using Rancho Gordo cranberry beans, for example!) is wonderful and Bruno will eat at least three helpings of it. WHUT. I want to marry that recipe. The boys eat it plain or with a bit of bread and Hugo will have some avocado with it. We top it with cilantro and hot sauce and pickled onions and avocado. Sometimes, though, life is too crazy even for the Instant Pot and then I make a red or yellow lentil soup, which takes about 20 minutes and while Hugo will bellyache about it, both kids will usually eat it. (Obviously, it helps if I slice a hot dog into the soup, but I don't always do that because I don't want them to get used to hot dogs on the regular because I am MEAN and also sort of stupid seeing as we live in Germany and they already are used to eating them all the time everywhere gaaaaah.)

Wednesday is Chicken Day. Sometimes I make this Korean chicken, sometimes I make breaded cutlets (but let's be honest, rarely, because that set-up is way too time-consuming and annoying at this point in my life – I mean, keep in mind that unless there's a second adult here, I can't set foot in the kitchen without Bruno behind me dismantling literally everything in sight or physically hanging off of me or Hugo asking if he is finally allowed to watch something NO YOU CANNOT AND IF YOU ASK ME ONE MORE TIME CHILD I SWEAR TO…), but recently I discovered Diana Henry's baked chicken and it is so delicious and so easy and so…satisfying and impressive and perfect that it makes me happy every time I make it.

You make a soft little mixture of Dijon mustard, butter and herbs (she calls for tarragon, but I end up usually just using a bit of dried sage or nothing at all), then squash this all over a bunch of chicken thighs. Then you sprinkle breadcrumbs on top and stick it in the oven until browned and crisp. That's it. The crispy top pleases the children, the herbs and mustard make it sophisticated enough to not give you an existential crisis and it's on the table (from start to finish!) in 40 minutes. (The active time of 5 minutes is fast enough that I can trick the kids into leaving me alone while I do it.) SO GOOD.

It's one of only two recipes actually printed out and pasted to my refrigerator, that's how much I love it. (The other one is for this, but with yogurt/milk instead of buttermilk.)

The original recipe specifies chicken thighs (skinless, but bone-in) and it is definitely the way to go. HOWEVER, because of course, I have also tried this with skinless, boneless chicken breasts and while it's not nearly as juicy and toothsome and rich, it's totally fine. Just reduce the cooking time to 20 minutes and then use the broiler for 3 minutes at the end to brown and crisp the breadcrumbs. (The photos in this post are of the chicken breasts.)

The recipe comes from Diana's chicken cookbook and is definitely, positively, absolutely worth the price of the book. For some godforsaken reason, I only own this book on my Kindle, which drives me fucking bananas, because if I want to cook anything else from it, I have to keep re-entering my password and peering at the phone and then my children see me on the phone and then they WANT the phone and my fingers are dirty and stop screaming and oh my god no you can't have a snack and you can't have the phone and please go play and ten more minutes and I hate everything and I really don't understand why cookbooks even come in E-book form, it's so dumb.

Mustard butter

Thursdays are soup/stew days, which means that sometimes we eat some sort of bean stew twice a week, but there are worse things, yes? Usually it's some sort of puréed vegetable soup and bread. Thank goodness for German bread, which is about 80% of what Bruno eats in total, period. And sometimes, depending on just how much of a surrender week it is, it's the day the boys get pastina in broth (as in bouillon cube or Better Than Bouillon) and I fantasize about being capable of drinking three glasses of wine at dinner (I can't even do one glass, just so you know, which seems really unfair).

Fridays are fish (and frozen peas). Either I stick a bunch of frozen fillets in tomato sauce and serve over rice from the rice cooker, or boiled potatoes if I'm feeling charitable, or it's fish sticks. And then my husband roots around in the pantry looking for the instant mashed potatoes because you can't possibly have one without the other and I decide that instead of dinner, I'm having a bath and listening to a podcast and no, please don't follow me, in fact, forget I even exist, someone else is in charge now good night and good luck.

Please, PLEASE, you well-meaning, lovely, wonderful people, do not tell me how quickly this phase will be over and that I'll miss it one day. PLEASE. I am fully aware of that. As in every day. It sometimes keeps me up at night! It also does not usually make me feel better in the moment. You know? Sometimes you just have to live it and be frustrated and tired and happy when the kids are finally asleep and that's okay too.

Note: This post includes affiliate links and I may earn a commission if you purchase through them, at no cost to you. I use affiliate links only for products I love and companies I trust. Thank you.

Diana Henry's Baked Chicken with Dijon Mustard and Herbs
Serves 4
Adapted from A Bird in the Hand

1/4 cup Dijon mustard
A couple of pinches of chopped fresh herbs (like tarragon, thyme, oregano, basil, what have you)
1 3/4 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
4 skinless, bone-in chicken thighs
Salt and pepper
2-3 tbsp bread crumbs (from stale, not fresh, bread)

1. Preheat the oven to 425F. Mash the Dijon mustard with the tarragon and butter until combined. Put the chicken into a roasting pan (or a baking dish) and brush or use your fingers to spread the mustard mixture onto the chicken. Season, then press on the bread crumbs.

2. Roast in the hot oven for 35 minutes. The chicken should be cooked through. Check this by piercing the flesh near the bone, with the tip of a sharp knife, in one of the larger pieces. The juices should run clear with no trace of pink. If not, cook for a few minutes more then test again. The top should be a lovely golden color.

3. Serve immediately with the cooking juices that have gathered around the chicken.

Posted in , ,

81 responses to “Diana Henry’s Baked Chicken with Dijon Mustard and Herbs”

  1. Luisa Avatar

    Yes, funny, right? It only occurred to me afterwards that he must have done the same thing! Will have to ask.

    Like

  2. Luisa Avatar

    THE MELODRAMA OMGAAAH

    Like

  3. Luisa Avatar

    Thank you, this is a good reminder!

    Like

  4. Luisa Avatar

    Ha! Sounds like a legitimate diagnosis to me!

    Like

  5. Luisa Avatar

    thank you xo

    Like

  6. Luisa Avatar

    Such a bummer!! Sigh. xx

    Like

  7. Luisa Avatar

    One day corn tortillas will be available in grocery stores in Germany and on that day, I will celebrate.

    Like

  8. Luisa Avatar

    No apologies. Two is HARD. Will be honest, THREE IS HARD TOO. Four is ok, but not always. But way better than three. Solidarity…

    Like

  9. Luisa Avatar

    My book-reading time in bed ALONE before lights out is, right now, the best part of my day.

    Like

  10. Jessica Avatar
    Jessica

    Loved this. My kids are a little older than yours (6 and 8), and I am very familiar with and do not miss the dinner times that you are talking about. For whatever reason, I too continued to push through and try to cook a family dinner most weeknights, even though I often met resistance or outright rage, and it was just very hard to accomplish logistically. I’m not here to tell you it gets perfect. I still fight with my kids and they still sometimes throw an irrational fit about dinner. And I often question my sanity and wonder why this evening feat is mine to manage, and why nobody seems to notice or thank me for all this damn work I’m doing! But this week the nicest thing happened. My 8 year old came into the kitchen while I was making our Monday night pasta (control! they all eat noodles!) and asked me if I would give her all my recipes in case one day she decides to become a cook!
    Anyway, you are doing a great job! Good luck getting through the tough parts. And try to hold on to the nice, sweet, lovely moments while you sweat through the rest.

    Like

  11. Debbie Tanner Avatar

    I made this the other night but because I’m so much lazier than you are, I used an herb butter my husband had made for some steaks awhile back and it was languishing in the back of the refrigerator. I melted it and mixed it with some mustard and then some panko bread crumbs and put it on some boneless skinless chicken thighs. I baked it at 375 degrees and it was AMAZING. Thanks for the inspiration!

    Like

  12. Erin Streiff Avatar
    Erin Streiff

    Thank you for this. You are the best.

    Like

  13. Jenna Avatar
    Jenna

    This looks delicious and immediately goes on my to-make list!
    I have strong feelings about living in a world that insists women do the unappreciated grunt work of raising children and housekeeping and then also insists that they act happy about it too. Nope! Do whatever it takes to get through the struggle with your sanity intact so that you can enjoy the easier phases whenever they come!

    Like

  14. Rosemarie Avatar
    Rosemarie

    So happy to see you are back!!! I just reread “My Berlin Kitchen” and it made so happy and also so hungry for pizza with anchovies and escarole! Lol reading this while my overtired 15 month old attempts to squash his afternoon nap for the 3rd day in a row. Daylight Savings, I looooathe youy

    Like

  15. Monica Avatar
    Monica

    Years ago when Angela’s Ashes was a best-seller, a bunch of my friends read it in their book club. They all had toddlers who were really picky eaters, and found the book very comforting: here was a big Irish family with very little money, whose children seemed to subsist on tea with lots of sugar, bread, butter, and the occasional potato. Yet they survived to adulthood.
    Wishing you occasional moments of peace and joy, along with the frustration. Very nice to have you back here.

    Like

  16. Charlotte Avatar
    Charlotte

    Oh this made me laugh because that was so our house (without the second baby) – sometimes I wonder that my husband is still alive. I just this week told both him and the boy (13) that they were each responsible for dinner one night a week. Tonight was my first night (because I am teaching the boy to cook so not really a break but still) and I so enjoyed not having to come up with a dinner idea and washing all the pots was still way faster than cooking….now to start on a litany of things I won’t eat so I can level the playing field or am I being too mean.
    Luisa – the hot dog thing…gaah indeed. If it makes you feel any better my kiddo lived on hot dogs and peanut butter for about 4 years until we convinced him to eat cheese.

    Like

  17. Dani Avatar

    I love this! Thank you for sharing x

    Like

  18. Ashley Avatar
    Ashley

    Our kids are similar ages and I get it. It made me feel good to know that I’m not alone. It’s easy for me to think that everyone else is zen and has it figured out, so I appreciated this. 🙂
    Around here Tuesdays are Chipotle Bowls/Taco Rice, Wednesdays are beans, and Thursdays are salmon. Friday my husband makes scrambled eggs and potatoes. Sundays are yogurt parfaits (we have a bigger waffle and egg brunch and aren’t that hungry so…). It works. I love to cook so it gives me a framework but also allows me to try out new recipes. And I have to ask…tell me about your fish in tomato sauce. My husband doesn’t enjoy fish so I’m always trying to figure out a way to make it more palatable.

    Like

  19. Luisa Avatar

    The recipe’s hidden in this post: https://www.thewednesdaychef.com/the_wednesday_chef/2013/04/cooking-for-the-whole30.html
    Skip the chile if your kids don’t want spicy. 🙂

    Like

  20. Robin Watson Avatar
    Robin Watson

    This is brilliant! So delicious. So easy. I made it with bone-in dark-meat pieces from a cut-up chicken and it worked just fine. Love it!

    Like

  21. LK Avatar
    LK

    My kids are 5.5 and almost 3 and sometimes I feel like I’m the only one who feels this way about dinner, so thank you for writing this.
    I have some chicken in the freezer that I’ve been ignoring, so I think I might try this. The adults will like it, but at most, one kid will eat it.

    Like

  22. Katie Avatar

    Omg this looks so tasty and simple. I am definitely going to try this recipe for a mid week dinner! Love your meal planning guide – especially having pasta on Mondays. Pasta is nice and easy and makes everyone happy 🙂

    Like

  23. Rachel Altan Avatar

    I love this post so much. I’ve got a spreadsheet that helps me out with meal planning now but sometimes I still overshoot and have too much cooking to do with little people dancing around me. Last week I took dinner out of the oven and my mitt was wet and my hand started to burn and there was a two-year-old in my way so I hurled the whole sheet pan over his head onto the stovetop and chicken thighs went flying everywhere bouncing off the backsplash. There were tears; not his.

    Like

  24. Sandra Avatar
    Sandra

    Love your writing. No, you will not miss this stage believe me. I couldn’t get through it fast enough

    Like

  25. Marie Avatar
    Marie

    “Hugo asking if he is finally allowed to watch something NO YOU CANNOT AND IF YOU ASK ME ONE MORE TIME CHILD I SWEAR TO…” this made me laugh so hard. This is my 8 year old every time he gets screen time. I feel seen! 🙂

    Like

  26. Tara Avatar
    Tara

    LUISA!! This post SPEAKS to my soul so dang much right now. I’m recently divorced and have my kids 50% of the time and while I love them desperately and miss them so much when I’m not with them, oh my god are they driving me fucking crazy. I read this post finally, for the chicken, but as usual, got so much more. Xoxo (mine are 3 and 7 btw).

    Like

  27. Sonali Avatar
    Sonali

    Luisa I am late to this but I keep coming back to this post both as a recipe reference and because it so perfectly mirrors how I feel about getting dinner on the table for a 5 and 2-year-old. My 5-year-old rejected a salad I made last night with all of his favorite stuff (chicken! green beans! apples! almonds!) and I felt like chucking the plate at him. And it was fucking delicious! Gah.

    Like

  28. John Avatar

    Its amazing! And im sure so tasty.

    Like

  29. Nicole Avatar

    Hilarious, just how I feel (twins, just over three years old). Do people tell you when it will be over and what comes next? No, thought so. Because the next thing is even more exhausting and charmingly endearing at the same time.
    I really need to get the book out again (paper copy at my bedside buried under children books) and I think it will be brilliant with the fennel-tomato-chickpea dish, so, here is another big sigh from me. Here is one tip since you can read German: Die Eltern Trickkiste. All the things you already sort of know but forget while your mind gets frazzled everyday in short one page or less articles.
    N xx

    Like

  30. Laura in NYC Avatar
    Laura in NYC

    this looks delicious, luisa!
    here’s another possibility for your chicken nights: i like to throw a bunch of boneless chicken thighs, potatoes cut into chunks, cherry tomatoes, and sliced onions into a big roasting dish. drizzle on a few tablespoons of wine (i most often use mirin, because it lasts forever in the fridge), a sippy cupful of water (you know how it is), and plenty of salt. cover with foil, bake at 400F(200C?) for 30 minutes and then another 30 minutes, uncovered.
    my two-year-old has the appetite of a bird, but she loves this chicken (though she prefers raw cherry tomatoes to the ones that have been cooked with the chicken). i make enough to last for two nights and just reheat the leftovers, covered, at 350F for 25-30 minutes on a night when i just can’t.

    Like

Leave a reply to Rosemarie Cancel reply