DSC_1482

One of the most underrated cookbooks of the past couple of years is, in my opinion, Aleksandra Crapanzano's The London Cookbook. a wide-ranging collection of recipes from London's best restaurants, pubs, cafés and holes-in-the-wall. I got a copy from my editor (the writer and I share a publisher) and over the past several months have slowly fallen in love with it. (It was published in the fall of 2016, when I had my hands full with my own book launch!)

The premise isn't, at first glance, my kind of thing at all. I'm really pretty uninterested in restaurant recipes. Restaurants have completely different goals, budgets and team numbers than a home cook. While I can appreciate that some home cooks would like to know how a three-star restaurant makes a 15-step duck confit, my sense is that most of us couldn't care less. If we can afford to go to that kind of restaurant, we enjoy that kind of cooking there. If we can't afford it, it remains a thing like a fancy sports car or a luxury vacation – something to view from afar. Or is it just me?

But Aleksandra gets that attitude and while there are of course several multi-step recipes in the book that kind of make my eyes glaze over, there are a surprising number of truly doable, simple gems in every chapter. In the introduction, it turns out, Aleksandra specifically mentions the fact that she wanted to only include recipes that were "easily made at home." If a chef wasn't able to adapt a recipe realistically for a home cook, it wasn't included. If you know restaurant cookbooks, that's pretty remarkable. Even more remarkable is that Aleksandra, clearly a first-rate home cook and the kind of cookbook writer we should all strive to be, managed to hone the recipes to make them truly accurate (and isn't that what we're all looking for in recipes?!). What you end up with is a book full of gorgeous, vibrant, interesting recipes from all kinds of amazing places in London that are also totally doable and approachable for home cooks. It's a slam dunk.

DSC_1531

The very first recipe that I tried was this olive oil cake from a café in London called Towpath. (I've never been myself, but I've heard about it from all sorts of discerning food people over the past several years.) And it was…perfect. The recipe was precise and correct (even without metric measurements) and the cake was out-of-this-world delicious, especially considering how simple it is. Everyone from Joanie, my baking North Star, to my father, who'd usually rather eat a plate of kimchi than a piece of cake, was ravished by it. By a simple, orange-scented olive oil cake, you guys!

I think the reason it was such a home run, beyond the fact that it was such a pleasure to follow such a well-written recipe, was a combination of the cake's flavor and its texture. The flavor was sort of delicate and floral, but also satisfyingly creamy and comforting, like a really good yellow cake. The crumb was fine and moist, but not greasy or oily in the least. Sturdy, too, the kind of thing you could almost eat out of hand, but without being dry or tough. It was marvelous. (The only weird thing? No salt in the recipe. The recipe came to Towpath via a Tuscan olive estate, which explains the lack of salt – most Italian dessert recipes (most European ones, actually) eschew salt. Out of habit, I added a pinch. You can go either way.)

When I made this, in mid-February, we still had a few chocolate Santas lying around the house and one of them was a fancy dark chocolate one, so on a whim, I chopped it up and added it to the cake. I think it was a mistake, or rather, an unnecessary fiddling and one I wouldn't recommend. This cake deserves to be left alone, served up proudly in its stark simplicity. No chocolate or whipped cream needed.

The recipe's in my forever files; the book's on my kitchen counter.

Note: This post includes affiliate links and I may earn a commission if you purchase through these links, at no cost to you. I use affiliate links only for products I love and companies I trust. Thank you.

Olive Oil Cake
Adapted from The London Cookbook
Makes one 9-inch round cake

2 cups all-purpose flour
1 tablespoon baking powder
1 1/4 cups sugar
3 eggs
3/4 cup good extra-virgin olive oil
3/4 cup whole milk
1 to 2 teaspoons grated orange zest
Juice of 1 orange
Pinch of salt, optional

1. Preheat the oven to 350 F/180 C. Butter the sides of a 9-inch springform pan and line the bottom with parchment paper.

2. In a small bowl, stir the flour and baking powder together.

3. Place the sugar and eggs in the bowl of a stand mixer. Beat on medium speed until thick and pale yellow, about 3 to 5 minutes.

4. Add the olive oil, milk, orange zest and juice and beat for another minute or two. Turn off the machine and fold in the flour mixture by hand.

5. Scrape into the prepared baking pan. Bake for 45 minutes, until golden brown and a knife inserted into the center comes out clean. Cool on a rack completely before serving.

Posted in , ,

40 responses to “Towpath’s Olive Oil Cake”

  1. Natalie Avatar

    I love using olive oil in cakes! Looks so delicious ♥

    Like

  2. Hina Avatar
    Hina

    No salt?

    Like

  3. Luisa Avatar

    Yes! Thank you for reminding me. This is the one weird thing about the recipe. I added a pinch…Going to edit post now!

    Like

  4. Gerlinde Avatar

    I am going to have to try this, maybe today. My adult boys are coming and they always expect something sweet. When I was just married, many decades ago, we used to get together and cook from Julia Child’s book. It would take us all night but we had a great time. These days I am going for easy recipes and I am too tired to cook at night.

    Like

  5. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    This seems very similar to Molly Wizenberg’s yogurt cake (w/ milk instead of yogurt) and that cake is such a perfect one – easy to whip up, tender crumb, everything you want in a weeknight snack. Love it.

    Like

  6. l Avatar
    l

    Thank you for this recipe and, in particular, for describing the cake’s texture and showing a photo of the crumb. Texture is so important in a cake but it isn’t always mentioned in recipe headnotes or shown in the accompanying pictures. You’ve convinced me to try this one.

    Like

  7. Victoria Avatar

    Hi, Luisa.
    Believe it or not I actually have this cookbook so on your recommendation I will try this cake. The only olive oil cake I ever made was a chocolate cake, and Walter and I each took one bite, and I threw it out. But you have never steered me wrong; after all, you gave me the secret embedded-on-another-post recipe for spaghetti with ricotta stirred in, which I make all the time; not to mention rice-stuffed tomatoes baked with potatoes! Do I need a very light flavored extra virgin olive oil to make it work.

    Like

  8. Kate Avatar
    Kate

    This looks tasty and I think that my kids and I would love it…If you make this again, pretty please weigh your ingredients and update your post! I’d love to try it but am reluctant, given the potential for discrepancies in methods of measuring flour. Also how big were the eggs that you used?

    Like

  9. Margaret Avatar
    Margaret

    Do you think it will bake ok in a regular 9” round cake pan?

    Like

  10. Luisa Avatar

    No, you can use almost any olive oil – I used a pretty strongly flavored one and it was great.

    Like

  11. Luisa Avatar

    The recipe worked perfectly as written with US measurements – as I wrote in the post, you don’t need to worry about converting to metric, it’s a pretty forgiving recipe. So don’t sweat it! I used large eggs.

    Like

  12. Luisa Avatar

    Yes, of course – but getting it out will be a little tricky. Just make sure you line the pan with parchment and have some overhang so that you can lift it out.

    Like

  13. Susan B. Avatar
    Susan B.

    I would love to make this – it’s right up my alley! One question: the recipe calls for the juice of one orange. Could you tell me how much you think this would be? I have navel oranges and they are rather large. Do you think 1/2 cup? Thanks!

    Like

  14. Luisa Avatar

    It’s a pretty forgiving recipe – I would just use the juice of the whole orange!

    Like

  15. Shannon Avatar
    Shannon

    Luisa, this is in the oven now! Question – do you have a favorite olive oil that you buy in Berlin or Italy? And do you ever buy NON extra-virgin olive oil?

    Like

  16. Luisa Avatar

    In Berlin, I almost always buy Greek olive oil at a Greek wine store in Charlottenburg called Cava. I buy it in a big 5 liter tin for about 45 euros. I like the olive oil (he has two or three different brands, some organic, some not), I like supporting small olive farmers in Greece, and I like the price. When my mother has a bumper crop of olives, we actually get our own olive oil but that doesn’t happen every year. So then we just buy this brand: https://www.google.de/search?q=olio+grezzo&client=firefox-b-ab&dcr=0&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjr7p-l5oLaAhVIr6QKHRc8CcAQ_AUICygC&biw=1380&bih=706#imgrc=HdFdX-wpGCy1iM:
    And I only buy extra-virgin…

    Like

  17. Marie Avatar
    Marie

    I always love reading your posts, but particularly tonight because my brother-lawn-law has a recipe in that book! His name is Bob Cairns, and he used to work for Andrew Edmunds. He’s a rare breed: an amazingly talented chef who loves to cook at home. Which is lucky for us, because we get to enjoy food to swoon over and then feast on every time we visit.
    Will try the Olive oil cake this weekend – thanks for bringing it to our attention!

    Like

  18. Hayley Avatar
    Hayley

    Oh lovely! This is very similar to David Lebovitz’ Olive Oil Muffin recipe, which he made to try to replicate Maialino NYC’s olive oil muffins. I have tried the Maialino muffins, which are out of this world delicious, and made David Lebovitz’ recipe, which comes pretty close!
    The cake recipe seems to have more sugar and less liquid(olive oil/milk). It also uses all orange juice, while the muffin recipe has some grand marnier in it. A side by side comparison sounds like a fun way to while away a weekend afternoon 🙂

    Like

  19. Judi Avatar

    A marvelous cake and, as you say, Luisa, pretty forgiving! I used 00 flour, because that’s all I had in the house (don’t ask), and Meyer lemons instead of oranges, because I’m addicted to them (I never had them growing up in Cologne). I did make one tweak to the method…a la Dorie Greenspan, rubbed the lemon zest into the sugar and let it sit for about a half hour before beating the sugar and eggs together. Lovely subtle floral flavor from the olive oil/citrus combo. A keeper…and even better on day 2. Thank you!

    Like

  20. Francesca Avatar
    Francesca

    Dear Luisa,
    I just put the cake in the oven and I can’t wait to see (taste) how it turns out. I then took a glance at the baking time and I had to smile because you wrote: “Back for 45 minutes”. Just a little German intrusion and I am relieved to know that it happens to you too. After 15 years in Germany, as a mothertongue Italian with English knowledge I sometimes think that I am starting to sound like Salvatore in “The Name of the Rose”! 😉
    Un caro saluto!

    Like

  21. Luisa Avatar

    Oh, how neat! Which one is his recipe?!

    Like

  22. Karolina Avatar

    Great recipe, nice pictures, I like baking the more my own production.

    Like

  23. Reem Faruqi Avatar

    Hi! Sorry, not sure if my comment went through on my phone! My daughters and I made this cake; appearance and texture are lovely. Just my cake tastes strongly like olive oil! I think if I had used vegetable oil, it wouldn’t have been so overpowering. Any advice? it was extra virgin olive oil. Maybe my daughters and I are not olive oil cake people? Thank you!

    Like

  24. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    I made this cake today and I love it-so simple-so delicious! As always, the recipes you post never fail.

    Like

  25. Amy Avatar
    Amy

    This is a perfect recipe. I followed the recipe to the letter, minus the optional salt, and used a super mild olive oil. It was beautiful, and a runaway hit with the family. It tasted even better on Day 2. Thank you!

    Like

  26. magalischuffelhauer@hotmail.com Avatar
    magalischuffelhauer@hotmail.com

    Hello from Magali, Natascha’s sister from France.
    I loved your post and made the cake today….but my result wasn’t as perfect after cooking…and it is not the first time this happens to me with lemon cakes….they often( not allways) have this not perfectly cooked look inside…I wonder why??? Is there any chemical reaction between bakinkpowder and lemonjuice (I had no orange) that may be the cause of this cooking problem?
    usually for the oven, do you use “Umluft” or classical heat?
    Thanks for the eventual hints and maybe we will be able to meet one day in Berlin.
    In the mean time I enjoy your books a LOT!!!!!!

    Like

  27. Wink Avatar
    Wink

    Kate’s comment (which echoes my own request) isn’t about metric measurements, but rather about converting volume to weight. 2 cups of flour in arid Colorado will have a decidedly different water content than 2 cups of flour in humid North Carolina. This can make a big difference in baking (without even getting into altitude adjustments). Measuring by weight eliminates much of the discrepancy.

    Like

  28. Luisa Avatar

    Hi Magali! Do you have this issue with lemon cakes from US baking books only or all lemon cake recipes? I ask because European baking powder is different from American baking powder, which could be part of, if not the whole, problem. As for the oven, I always use the classic “Ober- und Unterhitze.”

    Like

  29. Christine Avatar
    Christine

    I made this cake last night and it is perfect! The recipe was quick and easy to follow, the cake is tender with just the right density, and it tastes delicious! It was also very good for breakfast this morning 🙂
    Thanks for posting!

    Like

  30. sarra Avatar

    J’adore l’ambiance de ton blog!

    Like

  31. simran Avatar

    such a wonderful and easy recipe with the goodness of olive oil

    Like

  32. Nanda Avatar
    Nanda

    I was just noticing the same slight differences but mostly similarities to the Maialino Olive Oil Cake on food52. Maybe I will bake both and see how they differ. I don’t have Grand Marnier and was going to substitute more orange juice anyway. We shall see!

    Like

  33. Elizabeth Avatar
    Elizabeth

    Made this with Cup4Cup gluten free flour and WOW–perfect, although I did use the zest of the entire orange because, orange zest. This is definitely a make-again recipe. I gave The London Cookbook to my daughter as a remembrance of her study abroad trip last year. It’s a wonderfully written book.

    Like

  34. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    So delicious! I’ve been meaning to make this for more than a month and finally did today, with a very old orange. Mine isn’t as tall/high as your picture. Any ideas why that might be? Just curious — it doesn’t look quite as impressive. But still so good!

    Like

  35. Luisa Avatar

    Did you make sure to really beat your eggs for 3 to 5 minutes? The longer you beat the eggs, the fluffier the batter gets and by extension the taller the cake. It’s also possible that your baking powder isn’t fresh anymore…

    Like

  36. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Both are definitely possibilities, thanks. It’s still great though — even my 5-year-old who hates everything loves it!

    Like

  37. Unlocker Software Avatar

    Unlocker is a software or utility application whose main function is to remove data or files.

    Like

  38. Kathryn Avatar

    I would love to make this cake, I am a great fan of olive oil in baking recipes, but I have a serious (and totally unfair) citrus allergy. Do you have a suggestion of what I could substitute in for the missing flavor and liquid content?

    Like

  39. Tanya Avatar

    I made this cake yesterday….turned out awesome….thank you soooo much for the recipe

    Like

  40. Sara J Evans Avatar
    Sara J Evans

    I just made this with an amazing local olive oil that is infused with real tangerine from Pasolivo! I can’t wait to try it!

    Like

Leave a reply to Hina Cancel reply