Mexican green goddess dressing

This aging thing is nuts. Why, just this past weekend, I had to take a six-hour train ride to southern Germany, sleep at a Holiday Inn Express (the sheets! so silky! the room! so quiet!) and then come back the next day, and all I could think about this adventure was: 12 WAKING HOURS ALL BY MYSELF I CAN READ EVERY BOOK UNDER THE SUN ALL BY MYSELF AND THEN I GET TO SLEEP ALONE AND BE WOKEN BY MY OWN SELF AND THEN READ SOME MORE IN BED BECAUSE NO ONE IS DEMANDING BREAKFAST OR A PLASTIC ELEPHANT OR THAT MAMA GET TO HIS SIDE RIGHT THIS MINUTE OH MY GAH WHAT BLISS IS THIS.

I can guarantee you that ten years ago (or even five? three? anytime before June 2012?), I would not have been this easily pleased. (My reading list, in case you're wondering, was the latest two New Yorker issues in full, the latest Vogue, The Book of Negroes and 35% of The Fault in Our Stars. No, I don't think I looked outside the window once?)

Also, with age, I have learned that the things I used to detest no longer repulse me! Let's make another list, shall we?

Things I used to hate:
cilantro
scallions
creamy salad dressings

Things I now love:
cilantro
scallions
creamy salad dressings

Well, not all creamy salad dressings, to be totally honest. In fact, let's just say only this creamy salad dressing. After arriving in southern Germany on Sunday and before going to sleep in the soft and silky Holiday Inn Express bed, I had an encounter with a creamy salad dressing that I would only describe as  unfortunate. (In case you're wondering what I was doing in Baden-Baden, click here and look for the show from May 12th.)

ANYWAY. This creamy salad dressing, to get to the point already, is from Gwyneth Paltrow's second cookbook, It's All Good. And while opinions differ on the book, the chapter on salads and salad dressings is pretty great. This dressing, in fact, called Mexican Green Goddess Dressing, is worth the price of the book and not to sound like a broken record or anything, but my philosophy is that if you get just one great recipe out of a cookbook, that cookbook's a keeper.

Gwyneth's Mexican green goddess is made up of sheep's milk yogurt, olive oil, cilantro, scallions, lime juice, salt, a touch of honey and a jalapeño (it's tough to find jalapeños in Berlin, though, so I used a drizzle of this terrifyingly spicy hot sauce instead – thank you, Liana!). You blend everything up in a blender or with an immersion blender that has a turbo setting and then you use it on a salad consisting of chopped romaine, avocado, tomatoes, canned black beans, corn (fresh if you've got it, and canned if you don't), more scallions and more cilantro. And you know what, it truly does taste of Mexico – all of those wild, bright flavors blended up and threaded together. It's fantastic.

Mexican chopped salad

You are by no means constrained to only use this dressing on this particular salad, though. I used it on cold boiled broccoli the next day to fantastic effect, for example, and on a bowl of sliced cucumbers and tomatoes a few days after that and could imagine it on a bowl of simple arugula, too, or steamed fennel or any vegetable really, that needs a bit of a creamy, spicy, zingy zhuzh.

I still haven't come around to dill, though. Maybe check in with me when I'm 40.

Gwyneth Paltrow's Mexican Green Goddess Dressing
Adapted from It's All Good
Makes 1 1/2 cups

2/3 cup sheep's milk yogurt
¼ cup cilantro
2 scallions, roughly chopped
¼ cup lime juice (2-3 limes)
½ jalapeno, roughly chopped, or a drizzle of hot sauce
½ cup extra virgin olive oil
½ teaspoon coarse sea salt
1 tablespoon honey or agave nectar

Combine all the ingredients in a blender. Blend until completely smooth. The dressing can be kept in a jar in the fridge for up to a week.

Posted in , ,

32 responses to “Gwyneth Paltrow’s Mexican Green Goddess Dressing”

  1. Marie Avatar

    I have a jar of this in my fridge right now! I agree it is lovely! I like to drizzle a bit on a veggie sandwich for a little extra flavor – so good!!

    Like

  2. Ileana Avatar

    Haha, I am just starting to be on okay terms with dill. Anyway, I’m also reading The Fault in Our Stars and enjoying it so much! Hope you find yourself with another 12-hour window soon to hang out with your books. 🙂

    Like

  3. Sally Avatar
    Sally

    As I’ve gotten older I find I can tolerate most of the things I used to hate, with the exception of cilantro. I still hate that. Oh, and okra. I dislike that more every time I taste it.
    Peace and quiet is a lovely thing. Believe it or not, there will come a day when you’ll be able to sit down and read (and remember) more than a paragraph while your child is in the house! That was a wonderful day.

    Like

  4. Giulia Avatar

    Yours is the second mention of The Fault In Our Stars I have read today, finally prompting me to go to Amazon and find out just what could make this book so special (first mention was Frank Bruni’s NY times column, by the way). I just watched about half of your show when I should have been working, by the way, and can guarantee that my 78-year-old parents-in-law down in tiny little Trier were probably watching it too, wondering, “who is this woman?”
    The times have certainly changed, but nowadays it’s as though appearing on television really means reaching an entirely new (but actually much, much older) market/generation!

    Like

  5. Heather Avatar
    Heather

    I so agree. Melissa Clark’s Green Goddess Chicken recently blew my mind. It uses yogurt instead of goat cheese. I would use it on pretty much anything now.

    Like

  6. Mary G Avatar
    Mary G

    I am pretty sure I will never be OK with dill, And am still fairly frightened of creamy dressings, but I am willing to give this creamy dressing a try 🙂
    I do have the millet muffin recipe if you still need it. YUM

    Like

  7. Kat Avatar
    Kat

    I used to hate dill, too, and maybe I still do (it’s likely) BUT I’ve found one dill recipe that I love – it’s from Yotam Ottolenghi’s Plenty, and it’s the cabbage and kohlrabi salad with dill and dried cherries. I leave out the sprouts because I think they’re too earthy. But the rest is perfection!

    Like

  8. heather Avatar
    heather

    Can’t wait to try this. I saw the your IG pic and can’t stop thinking about it. We love her Carrot Ginger Dressing in our house. Willa uses it as “dip” I use it for a delicious salad dressing. Mmmmm.

    Like

  9. Luisa Avatar

    That’s next on my list! Looks amazing. And if it will get Hugo to eat carrots again, I will worship at the altar of Gwyneth forevermore.

    Like

  10. Luisa Avatar

    Aha! Interesting. Will check it out….from a distance…for now… 🙂

    Like

  11. Luisa Avatar

    You’re so right!

    Like

  12. Meena Avatar

    I love how you’ve put the dressing in a vintage looking bottle! I bought the book myself despite the mixed reviews, and I’m pretty pleased with it. I love the salad section, and the seafood section has some nice easy stuff too. One of my favourites is the ginger tea from the beverages section!

    Like

  13. katie Avatar
    katie

    I’m guessing the sheep’s milk yogurt is used to meet a specific health benefit or dietary restriction of Gwenyth’s and that any type of dairy–goat or cow–could be subbed in for it. Or do you notice a specific unique taste with the sheep milk? Just curious.

    Like

  14. katy Avatar

    I love your cookbook philosophy and I am of the same mind. Granted, this is why I’m now swimming in a sea of cookbooks (and books) and am realizing that I must downsize and soon, but still: I will always believe that a life with books is better than one without.

    Like

  15. Amy Avatar

    Haha! Dill is an enemy of mine too, which I always feel guilty about. I’m hoping to try it one of these days and all of a sudden love it, but until then why must everything including salmon be ruined by it?
    And also like you I used to hate creamy salad dressing — that is, until I tried Heinz’s bottled Cesear salad dressing (never seen it in the US but I find it here in France). I don’t know if that’s a double strike because it’s creamy AND it’s pre-made from a bottle, but damn it’s good. This one looks great too, love the flavors of Mexico.

    Like

  16. Luisa Avatar

    Cow’s milk is definitely a no-no in the book. You can certainly use cow’s milk yogurt here, though, if that’s what you have. However, sheep’s milk yogurt is much richer and milder than regular yogurt and that does influence the final result. I have a feeling you might be able to use less lime juice if you used regular yogurt, but you might need to up the olive oil a bit for a similar mouthfeel? Just guessing…

    Like

  17. Catherine Avatar
    Catherine

    Have you made anything from David Lebovitz’s new book?

    Like

  18. Gerlinde Avatar

    I love dill and I watched you on the German TV show. You have no accent what so ever when speaking German, how wonderful.

    Like

  19. Luisa Avatar

    Not yet! Looks amazing.

    Like

  20. Sherry Avatar

    Oh my God, this looks amazing and it hits all of my spring food cravings. I guess I know what I’m eating for lunch next week …

    Like

  21. Thea Avatar
    Thea

    Here in Berlin I use to buy Jalapenos at “Perfetto”, Karstadt, Wilmersdorfer Strasse. Don’t try it on Mondays. Best is Thursday, Friday – because of deliverance…
    And as I use to get the ARD-Buffet newsletter, I had knowledge about your TV appearance. I enjoyed it. 😉

    Like

  22. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    I’m very impressed that you’re reading “book of negroes”!

    Like

  23. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    Well, thanks to you I just finished reading Laurie Colwin’s delightful Home Cooking and want to read it all over again.

    Like

  24. Jaime Avatar

    I absolutely love cilantro and dill but I know so many people who have them on their top 10 lists of foods they hate! Boggles my mind, I think they taste so fresh!
    This dressing looks divine, will be trying this week, thanks! 🙂

    Like

  25. Isadora Avatar
    Isadora

    I made the dressing last night and it was fabulous! Thanks for posting it. I’m now inspired to make different types of salad this week to use it up.

    Like

  26. Suzy Avatar

    This was SO good! You really have a knack for finding the right recipes to make… Good thing you have a blog. Ha!

    Like

  27. Patricia Avatar
    Patricia

    Where did you find black beans in Germany??
    All I can find is kidney beans.

    Like

  28. Luisa Avatar

    At Bio Company! And other organic grocery stores… Good luck!

    Like

  29. Luisa Avatar

    So glad you liked it! xox

    Like

  30. Paula Avatar
    Paula

    So yummy!! I’d been eyeballing both the salad and the dressing for days and finally prepared it tonight for dinner. What a winner, thank you!! (Used 2% cow milk yogurt and sriracha sauce). Next is that delicious carrot ginger dressing.

    Like

  31. Kirsten Avatar
    Kirsten

    This was great. I didn’t find the half jalapeño to be spicy at all, so I added a little hot sauce at the end. I used some of the dressing to marinate some chicken that we grilled and added to the salad as you described it. Really, really excellent. Thank you!

    Like

  32. John Avatar
    John

    This looks awesome, but I have a question about one of the measurements. For the 1/4 cup of cilantro, do you chop it up first and then measure it, or do you roll it into a bunch and fit that into the measuring cup?

    Like

Leave a reply to Mary Cancel reply