Sherry Yard's Quintessential Chocolate Chip Cookies

I am having a very odd week. On Monday, just after I'd dropped Hugo off at daycare (thankgodthankgodthankgod), I slipped on some just-formed black ice on the sidewalk. There was no time to catch myself, no time to even register what was happening before I slammed my head against the cobblestones. It was all very upsetting, as you can imagine, what with bits of tooth suddenly loose in my mouth and blood on the sidewalk and a momentary loss of vision and all that pain, pain, pain.

A good Samaritan helped me and I was the first in the ER that morning, so I was seen and treated in record time and in the grand scheme of things, of course, I was very lucky: The tooth I broke was a molar, the blood came from a cut under my chin, I don't have a concussion and Hugo was safe and sound in his cozy little Kita (thankgodthankgodthankgod) while all this happened. But I've spent the remainder of this week in an ugly little fog. Part of it is the pain – my jaw muscles are all seized up due to the shock and I have bruises all over my body – and part of it is a strangely thick feeling of sadness that I can't really explain. I mean, it was really just a harmless little accident. So why has it left me feeling so ravaged?

What I'd like most right now is to crawl into bed and spend a few days being very, very quiet – but if someone came and offered me a few of these cookies, freshly baked – I wouldn't kick them out either.

Sliced cookies

I first made them a few months ago, after reading about Martha Rose Shulman's secret double life, and found them to be, in fact, quite perfect. They're chewy in the middle and just a tad crisp on the edges and because of the chopped chocolate, every bite you take is infused with chocolate and caramel flavors. They're pretty flawless. And as you probably know, once you find perfect chocolate chip cookies, it's sort of difficult to find much additional language about them. If they're great, they just are; if they're not, you have to keep looking. I herewith declare my search to be over.

But my favorite thing about these cookies is that once formed into logs, they can hang out in your freezer for quite some time, resting until you have friends over and need a last-minute snack or dessert or have smashed your head on the sidewalk and are feeling fragile and in need of cosseting (provided you can still chew).

And with that, folks, I'm off to be quiet and heal. Have a great weekend!

Sherry Yard's Quintessential Chocolate Chip Cookies
Makes 4 dozen cookies

185 grams (1 1/2 cups) all-purpose flour
2 grams (1/2 teaspoon) baking soda
115 grams (4 ounces/1 stick) unsalted butter
100 grams (1/2 cup) sugar
80 grams (1/2 cup packed) light brown sugar
2 grams (1/4 teaspoon) salt
1 large egg
5 grams (1 teaspoon) vanilla
225 grams (8 ounces) bittersweet chocolate, cut in 1-inch pieces (or use coins)

1. Sift together flour and baking soda and set aside. In the bowl of a standing electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream butter until lemony yellow, about 2 minutes. Scrape down sides of bowl and paddle. Add sugar, brown sugar and salt. Continue creaming mixture on medium speed until it is smooth and lump free, about 1 minute. Stop mixer and scrape down sides of bowl and paddle.

2. Add egg and vanilla and beat on low speed for 15 seconds, or until they are fully incorporated. Do not over-beat. Scrape down sides of bowl and paddle.

3. On low speed, add sifted flour mixture. Beat slowly until all of the flour is incorporated. Scrape down sides of bowl. Add chocolate chunks and mix in.

4. Heat oven to 350 degrees with the rack positioned in the lower third of the oven. Line a baking sheet with parchment. Spoon heaping teaspoons of dough 2 inches apart onto baking sheet. If not baking right away, remove small handfuls or spoonfuls of dough from mixer and plop them down on the middle of a sheet of parchment or wax paper, creating a log about 1 1/2 inches wide and 12 inches long. Fold parchment over, creating a sausage. Chill for at least 1 hour, preferably overnight. Using a serrated knife, slice chilled dough into 1/3-inch-thick rounds and place them 2 inches apart, in staggered rows, on parchment-lined sheets and proceed. (Dough will keep, tightly wrapped, in the refrigerator for 1 week, or in the freezer for up to 1 month. Thaw frozen dough at room temperature for 30 minutes before slicing.)

5. Bake for 12 to 15 minutes, until lightly browned, rotating the baking sheet front to back halfway through. Remove from heat and slide parchment off baking sheet and onto a work surface. Allow cookies to cool for at least 5 minutes before serving, or for at least 20 minutes before storing in an airtight container. Repeat with remaining dough. Cookies will keep for up to 3 days at room temperature.

Posted in

72 responses to “Sherry Yard’s Quintessential Chocolate Chip Cookies”

  1. Jennifer Jo Avatar

    Oh Luisa, that’s awful! (Not the cookies, your fall.)
    I’ve been feeling sad and slightly ravaged all week and I didn’t even smash my head on the sidewalk—I just got snowed in with four kids and no library books. We humans are such fragile beings, every single one of us, at one time or another, in need of warm chocolate chip cookies and a quiet bed.

    Like

  2. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Hi Luisa,
    Sorry to hear about your accident. Ice is so freaky!
    You might like to load up on tumeric (fresh & dried) as it is very good for inflammation. Another thing that might help is sleeping with a mouth guard, in case you are a grinder or night-time jaw tenser. In the New World they sell them at the pharmacie & you put them in hot water, then into your mouth & they mould to your teeth. Sometimes an epsom salts bath can work very well for well-being. No idea how, but the magnesium has something to do with it. Get well soon and hope your are being well looked after. Bon week-end!

    Like

  3. Sini│my blue&white kitchen Avatar

    Oh what an awful start for the week you had, Luisa. That black ice is horrible… I still have a scar on my leg as I fell down the stairs a couple of months ago. All because of black ice. Thanks God I didn’t end up in the ER.
    I wish I could bake you a batch of these delicious-looking cookies and bring a bowl of them and a glass of cold milk to your bed.
    Hugs from Finland,
    Sini

    Like

  4. Gemma Avatar

    Ooft, things like that can really shake you up. I think there is something particularly horrible about falling over, I think it’s the total feeling of vulnerability, the loss of control. I fell over twice on a walk once and I was shaking for the rest of the day so do take care, rest up, enjoy your cookies and I hope you feel better soon.

    Like

  5. Mamen Avatar

    Hola!!!
    So sorry to hear about your accident. And yes, you were very lucky that Hugo was already at the daycare place. Mucha fuerza y ánimos!!
    And OMG!!! These cookies look delicious and have to try to bake them!!!!
    Have a nice day!

    Like

  6. Nora&Laura Avatar

    mm looks so delicious. i hope the cookies help that the sadness goes away fast and you feel better soon!!
    x
    laura&nora

    Like

  7. Katherine Sacks Avatar

    Oh Luisa, sending you lots of love and wishing you a speedy recovery!
    This was such a nice photo to see this morning. I made these cookies every single day for nearly 18 months while I worked at Spago and yes they are amazing! My go-to for sure. And you can use the roll-up log technique with almost any cookie dough. Sherry also has an amazing white chocolate-ginger version which I must have eaten several a day when I was 23. We would use a combination of dark and milk chocolate valrhona drops, and I would always sneak a few milk chocolate drops when I walked by the pantry. Goes to show I had no healthy eating thoughts back then!
    Hope you have a nice relaxing weekend and looking forward to seeing you next week at Soho House!

    Like

  8. Aline Avatar

    I think it’s two things. When you have a really bad fall, you feel scared of the world and betrayed by your own body for not protecting you. I think it’s a natural instinct as – the world out there seems bad and you just want to hide from it until it starts to look different again. Then also, when I had tooth issues I have been very depressed. Something about not being able to use your jaw and do the most basic, survival task of eating. I had an ordeal with a tooth implant and the implant didn’t take and then at the same time my dentist had a car accident and then I ended up running around with a wobbly implant for a good four month and I got so depressed. I actually started knitting and it was the only thing that calmed me. I hope you get better soon! I love following you on Instagram too and I’ve given your book to people who loved it and appreciated it as much as I did!

    Like

  9. Carly June Avatar

    So sorry about your fall! You’ve reminded me to tread extra carefully with all the ice on the ground. I hope you can relax this weekend and heal quickly!
    The cookies look amazing and as someone who has also had a difficult week, they might be just the ticket 🙂

    Like

  10. Zoomie Avatar

    I’m so sorry to read of your accident and pain. Hope the sad feeling lifts soon and you are back to your normal chirpy self.

    Like

  11. Quiche Avatar
    Quiche

    Im so sorry to read what happened to you! How awful!! Rest is good. Wishing you a speedy recovery.

    Like

  12. Katie Avatar

    Oh Luisa, I’m so sorry to hear about your fall! We are fragile things, but I guess that’s something we easily forget in the hustle and bustle of everyday life. So, it’s jolting to be reminded of it in this way, when something just happens. Anyway, I hope that you’ll be able to take some time for yourself and feel better soon. These cookies seem like a good step in the recovery process!

    Like

  13. Amanda Avatar
    Amanda

    Oh, I’m sorry. I can relate a little too well after being slammed on the chin by my flailing 4-year-old and ending up with a swollen, cut tongue, bruised jaw and dizzy brain. Rest and heal. And as soon as I can chew again I’ll try these cookies.

    Like

  14. Molly Avatar

    Oh no! I fell on the stairs early this winter while carrying my daughter. Thank heavens she was in her car seat and was totally fine. We were on the way to the pediatrician so I was able to have her checked out. I ended up cracking a rib and herniating a disc. But blood and a cracked molar sounds so scary. My co-worker slipped on black ice last week and broke her collar bone. Man, these winters are killer.

    Like

  15. Tamsin Avatar
    Tamsin

    You poor thing! Falling is such a shock to the system, I’m still nervous walking on icy mornings after a fairly minor fall several years ago. I do hope you feel better soon, homemade cookies are the best medicine!

    Like

  16. Katie Avatar

    Oh no! The ice was so treacherous this week in Berlin…I also fell a few times, but not as badly as you did. I’m so sorry to hear that! Gute Besserung!

    Like

  17. Abby Avatar

    Ugh, how awful. I agree with Aline that part of it is feeling betrayed by your body. Just last night I stubbed my toes in a pretty major way. It was a stupid accident, but they’re still aching today, a reminder that I’m not as invincible as I like to think. Curling up in bed with cookies and a book sounds like just the thing. Feel better!

    Like

  18. Clara Avatar

    Aline expressed what I was thinking so clearly. You’ve had a very serious, completely sudden double whammy. One moment whole, upright and confident, the next moment, completely shaken. I’m so glad you’re ok. Pull the covers close and continue to be gentle on yourself. So sorry.

    Like

  19. Heather Avatar
    Heather

    Oh, so glad to hear you’re (mostly) intact. I hope you feel all is right with the world very soon!

    Like

  20. Honeybee Avatar
    Honeybee

    Poor you!! I find falls very upsetting, too! Almost like the universe is against you or something. It makes me want to cry, and not just because of the pain. I hope you’re feeling better, soon!

    Like

  21. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    Luisa, SO sorry to hear about your fall and the pain and sadness you feel now. I hope you feel better in the coming days and have help caring for Hugo — is your Mom around? Even after all that you found time to post the lovely cookie recipe which I will use as I was planning on making chocolate chip cookies for nephews in college with a friend who’s son is at boarding school. So your good will should travel around to Texas, Tennessee, and Arizona!! This morning I was reading about how much God loves us “See what kind of love the Father has given to us, that we should be called children of God; and so we are.” 1 John 3:1. So comforting!
    Hope you recover soon and feel better!!
    xo
    Katie

    Like

  22. Angie Avatar
    Angie

    That is aweful.. When I lived there during that horrible winter.. I fell so many times my ego I think was bruised more. Gute besserung!

    Like

  23. Denise | Chez Danisse Avatar

    Oh no. Being reminded of our vulnerability as human beings is no fun. Rest easy.

    Like

  24. Katie @ cakes, tea and dreams Avatar

    Oh my word, how frightening. I am so glad you’re OK, and that Hugo was safe.
    These cookies look amazing, and I hope you have the chance to enjoy some of them and heal. Gentle hugs to you. xo

    Like

  25. Helen Avatar

    You poor, poor thing! I would definitely prescribe cookies and curling up with a good book. Have you read ‘The Baker’s Daughter’ by Sarah McCoy? It’s a mutli-narrative story set in WWII Germany and present-day America, and I absolutely loved it. I hope you heal quickly and look after yourself – don’t let it give you a case of the ‘mean reds’.

    Like

  26. Merle Avatar
    Merle

    Sweet Luisa!
    Feel better soonest.
    xo
    Merle

    Like

  27. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    So sorry about you fall! How scary.
    These cookies do look amazing. I plan to bake them this weekend. Thanks for the recipe and take good care of yourself. (Also, I notice as I scanned your comments, you have quite a few readers named Katie …)

    Like

  28. Paula Avatar
    Paula

    Oy, Luisa, so sorry to hear. I’m glad you’re on the mend and that the injuries sustained, all things considered, were not as grave as they could have been. But I have experienced two similar instances of falling and hurting myself (in the snow/ice, too, during my east coast days) and, in the aftermath, have a lingering sadness.
    I think that the rug, in literal and figurative ways, is pulled from under us in these accidents and lays bare our tremendous vulnerability and potential helplessness. We wonder about future scenarios (I could break my hip in my older years…is that the beginning of the end?; the prospect of disability makes us frightened, too). By falling, we are stripped of our steadfast life and assumptions about our relatively care-free lives. I also think that the grief is also, maybe, just a little mournful for the immediate””pre–accident” levity.
    Just hang in there. Cookies (and some vanilla ice cream!) will do the trick. Also: take advantage of your more pensive mode/sadness and read something thoughtful. Then, just hit the magazine stand for some lightheartedness and “angst” relief–nothing like InStyle or Vogue to curb existentialism and sadness.
    In other words: ride the melancholy…then smack it down with magazines and a little retail therapy. Hugs.

    Like

  29. elizatwist Avatar

    Luisa,
    I am so sorry for your accident. I’ve got some tips, take them or leave them… Find yourself the sort of bodyworker who employs a very very gentle hand. I don’t know what is available in Berlin, but here, we have all sorts of variations on cranial sacral therapy. Just having somebody lay hands on your body can help your entire system recalibrate after such a trauma. I’ve heard that arnica taken internally is best and I have a lovely st. john’s wart salve to apply topically to bruises, but that’s a local product (made by a German lady, though). Sometimes our emotions find a strange way to express themselves, but I always tell myself better out than in. Take care!

    Like

  30. shelikespie Avatar

    I’m so sorry, your fall sounds awful! It sounds like you’re shaken not only by the fall but by the near-miss that you almost had Hugo with you, and maybe some of the sadness is connected to that? Anyway, it’s ok to feel sad. Wishing you rest and fast healing!

    Like

  31. Sarah G. Avatar
    Sarah G.

    Sending positive thoughts your way, especially that no one and nothing interferes with your much needed quiet time. Heal well. xoxo

    Like

  32. Katie C. Avatar
    Katie C.

    I heard about the freakish and terrible “Glatteis” from my friend in Berlin – where I am currently visiting! I wish you gute Besserung, rest is definitely best. And as I am yet another Katie, and haven’t commented yet here but am an avid follower, I will just introduce myself briefly as a fellow cross-cultural mosaic, American-born but with over 20 years of living in Germany under my belt, and some close ties to Italy as well; now living in San Francisco, which is beautiful, of course, but a bit far from the mother land. Alles Gute, herzliche Grüsse

    Like

  33. Kate in New York Avatar

    There is something enraging, chest-tightening, and baffling on an almost existential level that a sudden painful fall brings. I had a similar shock recently thanks to an unmarked steel construction plate on a snowy street here in New York. I’ve been doubting my career path etc. etc. recently and it somehow felt related. I had to shake off the feeling that there was any grander meaning beyond gravity and the art of frictionless walking, for which I have demonstrated such a talent. I hope you feel back to normal soon. Thanks for sending out this recipe into the universe. With the cold we are having I just want to bake! And thanks for your dispatches from Berlin on Instagram; I’m visiting there this March and it is just whetting my appetite…

    Like

  34. Cassandra Avatar
    Cassandra

    I’m sorry! Just thought I’d let you know, though, in case it makes you feel better: my weekend will be significantly cozier and more delicious because I made a pot of erbsensuppe from your book. Just finished my first bowl and it is so delicious! So even though you are in pain and out of sorts, you are still managing to improve the lives of others. 🙂
    Now on to those cookies! Aside from soup, these seem the best thing to make to warm up in Boston’s second vortex.

    Like

  35. Catherine Avatar

    Oh, you poor thing! I’m so sorry that happened to you. Sending love from here. xo

    Like

  36. Brittaney Avatar
    Brittaney

    Feel better soon, Luisa!

    Like

  37. TETI Avatar
    TETI

    Oh dear. What a shocking tale. Get better soon!

    Like

  38. Christine Avatar
    Christine

    It’s normal to feel depressed after an accident – even a relatively minor one. Glad you’re on the mend and I’m glad for cookies. Feel better! xoxox

    Like

  39. Karen Avatar

    I know you were told you didn’t have a concussion, but my understanding is that they are hard to diagnose, and from my own experience (unfortunately!), I know that even mild ones can make one feel sad and weepy. Take it very, very easy for a while. And thanks for the great cookie recipe.

    Like

  40. Molly Avatar

    Oh, Luisa, you poor, poor dear!!! I would march a tin of hazlenut-chocolate biscuits over to your doorstep in an instant, if I could. Oh, golly. Thank goodness, indeed, for small mercies and safe Hugos. It does rattle a person so, doesn’t it, those unexpected, out-of-the blue incidents? I think it is our assumptions that take a beating, our givens about all we know about our day. So terribly disconcerting. Just so plain terrible.
    Ditto what wise Karen has said: take it very, very easy, slow baby steps. May your poor jaw and molar mend well, as well as your battered spirit. I’m bolstered by the knowledge you have the best possible medicine on hand, all the same, in that cherry-cheeked, wide-grinned toddler of yours.
    Peace and rest, my friend,
    xo,
    Molly

    Like

  41. Lizy Tish Avatar

    Oh how awful… threw you for a loop I’m sure. Wishing you a speedy recovery. And I really hope someone makes you some of those cookies to help you feel better!

    Like

  42. Comeconella Avatar

    oh luisa. how awful! i do hope you are on the mend and feeling better. i fell on the pavement last year and looked like the textbook case of a battered wife. somehow that entitled my husband to feel sorrier for himself than me. and despite a few bruises and scrapes the encounter has stayed with me. i keep feeling that i may trip and fall again.
    sending you some virtual cookies!

    Like

  43. amelia Avatar

    awww, Luisa. That is so annoying / sad / totally sucks. When I’m carrying Teddy (just around the house), I constantly imagine how horrible it would be to fall, completely forgetting how horrible it is to fall in general! Take care and rest up!! xox

    Like

  44. Trisha Avatar
    Trisha

    I wouldn’t be so sure you don’t have a concussion. Depression can be the result of a concussion, which I learned playing hockey. Be sure and give yourself plenty of rest (mental rest included) and time to heal.

    Like

  45. eileen Avatar
    eileen

    rest up and be nice to yourself. we feel so vulnerable and winter makes it easy to feel depressed.

    Like

  46. Evy Avatar
    Evy

    Hope you feel better really soon! Thank you for posting even though you are still healing from this unexpected fall.

    Like

  47. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Take care, rest up, and consider getting a pair of rubber cleat strap ons for your shoes. You can get them on Amazon! I never had them for years, but once I got them I can’t picture being without them. I took a nice fall on some ice that had me out of shape for a month – that did it.
    Thank you for posting.

    Like

  48. Sarah R. Avatar
    Sarah R.

    I just want to say I hope you feel better soon. I can commiserate as I’ve fallen down our stairs at home not once, but twice this past week, and in the process injured my back and knee. It made me so angry at myself, but I’m trying to do what I need to do in order to heal. To our health and no more falls!

    Like

  49. dervla Avatar

    oh my gosh, just saw this now! I hope you’re feeling much much better! Ugh, what a scary thing to have happen. If i were there, i’d make you cookies (or whatever you wanted)

    Like

  50. Kaffiknopf Avatar

    OH YOU POOR THING I´m so sorry! I hope you will feel better asap * And these cookies look “oberlecker”, hihi. I think they are the perfect project for my baking loving girl. Also, there is still so much christmas chocolate I wanna get rid of. Cookies it is. Way to long that ago that I made cookies. Great, now I wish they would be ready before breakfast. 🙂
    Please take good care with all the fresh snow in the city now.

    Like

Leave a reply to Merle Cancel reply