Homemade vanilla extract

New Year's resolutions! Do you make them? I do. I know, I know, yawn, but I can't help it. I do feel like there is something about turning the page from one year to the next that gives you the glorious sensation of having a clean slate in front of you to fill with all your wonderful scribblings. Like every year, I put down "exercise more" and "eat less sugar", but now I've started adding "be more patient", because oooh that little child of mine, and "get more organized" and "email less" and other exhortations that sort of kill me with their mundanity but are increasingly integral to my peace of mind. Once we get all those self-improvement things out the way, though, we get to the really fun stuff – like "make your own vanilla extract" and behold, it is only January 15th and I have already knocked this one off the list! ROAR!

Though to be fair and honest, there could be nothing less challenging about making your own vanilla extract. In fact, it is so easy, so ridiculously nothing that I'm almost sort of appalled that we've all been keeping Nielsen-Massey and McCormick in business all these years. (And that us expats have been wasting precious suitcase space on meticulously wrapped bottles of extract.) No more!

Okay, so here's what you do: First, get yourself some vanilla beans. Nowadays you can get amazing deals on vanilla on this here internet. For example:

Shipping to the US:

Vanilla Products

Vanilla Saffron

Beanilla

Shipping to Europe:

Madavanille or Madavanilla

Cap d'Ambre Vanille

Vanilla Mart

Next, get yourself a bottle of alcohol. Vodka's a pretty great choice, since it's available everywhere and doesn't have much of its own flavor. I suggest getting a 500 ml bottle. (You can certainly use bourbon or rum, but for a neutral vanilla extract, vodka is good. If you happen to live in Italy or another country where pure alcohol is cheap and plentiful, you can buy that instead. Then use only 250 ml of alcohol and 250 ml of water.)

Now for the hard work. Select eight plump vanilla beans. Open the bottle of alcohol. Split the beans lengthwise and carefully scrape out all the seeds. Put the seeds in the bottle of alcohol and then the split beans. Close the bottle. Shake. Store. DONE. See what I mean? Stupid easy.

The recipe is easily doubled or halved or quadrupled or whatever. You can make many little bottles as gifts or one big bottle that you share with no one. It's up to you! Now, the longer you let the extract sit, the more flavorful it gets – but it's pretty much ready to use after a week or so of sitting. The best thing about this stuff is that every time you use some of your glorious homemade vanilla extract, you can top up the bottle with a bit more alcohol. Vanilla beans are so intense that they can handle being used a few times over.

And with that, I'm off to work on my other resolutions. Like meal planning! On that list thanks to you helpful folks.

Posted in ,

52 responses to “How to Make Your Own Vanilla Extract”

  1. Sylee Avatar

    Glorious stuff, congratulations! I’ve always used Madavanilla, so it’s great to know about the other sources.

    Like

  2. Cristina Avatar

    Grazie mille Luisa! I have been looking for online resources to purchase vanilla beans and your vanilla extract recipe is so clear that I am going to give it a try. Since I am Italian, I am considering purchasing alcohol. Do you believe the extract comes out better with vodka or with alcohol?

    Like

  3. Luisa Avatar

    It truly does not matter! I actually made my extract partly with vodka (because I only had about 220 ml left in the bottle) and partly pure alcohol mixed with water. Use whatever is easier or cheapest. And enjoy!

    Like

  4. shelly Avatar

    I literally just said to my husband, a few days ago, “I’m going to make my own vanilla extract very soon”.
    And that bottle of alcohol, left over from the fondue, that’s been sitting on the shelf.. well, now I know what to do with it!
    Thanks and a very happy new year from Israel !
    ps- “Be more patient” has been a mantra of mine since my eldest, now almost 6 (!) was born. I totally totally empathize.

    Like

  5. Dawn Avatar

    I finally just retired my four year old bottle of homemade vanilla and need to make a fresh batch. The thought of ever buying vanilla in a store now is inconceivable!

    Like

  6. Heather Avatar
    Heather

    A suggestion. Whenever you use half a bean or just the seeds of a bean, put the remainder in your bottle to punch it up. I alternate between putting the leftovers in my extract or into a jar of sugar..mmmmmmm.

    Like

  7. Susan Avatar
    Susan

    I’ve always put the whole beans in. I split the side of the beans to expose the interior, and into the vodka they go. It takes a couple weeks for the full flavor to develop, but it does last forever if you keep topping it off with more vodka. I’m just about to add new beans to my bottle, since it’s gotten a bit paler and less vanilla-y after four or five years (yes, really!). Simple and amaaazingly good!

    Like

  8. Becky Avatar
    Becky

    I too make my own vanilla and wonder why it took me so long to do something so simple! Some sources say split the beans some say there is no need. One article I read said heat your vodka first to impart the vanilla flavor quicker. Also you can place your beans inside the vodka bottle to use later in other recipes. In another words it will keep your vanilla beans from drying out. I have done it all ways and think they all work well. Right now I have split and non-split beans in my vodka, but it does need to cure for a month at least before using otherwise the flavor is mostly alcohol.I tasted mine as it went along to see when it was ready to use. Interesting way to experiment.. Another great source is indrivanilla.com. They have great prices and ideas on making vanilla. I let my bottle get half empty and then topped it off with more beans and vodka for this next year of baking.

    Like

  9. elizatwist Avatar

    I’m a big fan of resolutions. I make them throughout the year so I’m not particularly frenzied about them at the flip of the calendar. But I’ve got my first jar of vanilla extract going now. And I just filled out my meal plan for this week in my little book – it’s taken me a while to get back on track after a few weeks of being seriously under the weather. Anyway…good luck with fresh starts. It is amazing what simple intention setting will do for getting things accomplished!

    Like

  10. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    I’ve always wanted to make my own vanilla — will definitely try it now! Thanks for the information about topping off the bottle with more alcohol — I’ve never heard that, and love the gift idea….

    Like

  11. Patricia Avatar

    I’ve already placed an order for vanilla pods!!

    Like

  12. Kim A Avatar
    Kim A

    The Barefoot Contessa Ina Garten snips one end off the vanilla bean, puts abot 20 to 25 in a jar and then fills it with vodka or your choice of alcohol . Then when a recipe calls for vanilla extract, she pulls out a bean and squeezes the extract and seeds into her recipe. Then you can either put the bean back in the jar or in sugar to make vanilla sugar.

    Like

  13. Megan Avatar
    Megan

    I have a question: how does the vanilla-y-ness compare to store-bought vanilla extract? If a recipe asked for 5ml of vanilla extract, would you use 5ml of your homemade one or would you use more? Or less?

    Like

  14. Luisa Avatar

    I’d use the same amount.

    Like

  15. Luisa Avatar

    Ooh, good for you

    Like

  16. Luisa Avatar

    thanks for the tip!

    Like

  17. Luisa Avatar

    Good to know!

    Like

  18. Luisa Avatar

    Yay! And thanks 😉

    Like

  19. Nuts about food Avatar

    As an expat living in Italy, I also started making my own vanilla extract a couple of years ago (I mean, really, when I think of all that extra space in my suitcase that I could have used for great maple syrup, pecans etc.). I use rum because I had an open bottle when I started and still haven’t finished it and love how it tastes (I don’t use water in mine). The best thing is that whenever I use a vanilla bean for baking, I just stuff it into the jar afterwards and let it soak with the rest.

    Like

  20. Luisa Avatar

    Lovely! Of course you wouldn’t add water to rum – you’d only do that if you were using pure alcohol, which is 95%… 🙂

    Like

  21. Daniel Avatar
    Daniel

    It’s funny. This was one of the first things I did when I came to Germany eight years ago, since vanilla extract is near impossible to get here. I shook it every other day for two weeks and waited a month before I used it.
    I finished the bottle a few weeks ago, since I kept “saving it” and using commercial vanilla instead.
    I’ll have to add this to my to-do list, as I’m down to my last 200mL of regular vanilla, and am already freaking out.

    Like

  22. Liz Avatar

    I definitely like the idea if turning a new leaf at the new year. Making my own vanilla will be a great new thing to try. Thanks!

    Like

  23. Leah Avatar

    Believe it or not, I messed this one up! I don’t think I put in enough vanilla beans, so the bourbon just sat there, more booze than vanilla, for the better part of a year. Still, it was fun! I just ended up using it up in cocktails rather than baking with it. And my, with a vanilla sugar rim and some chocolate mint, those summertime cocktails were delicious.

    Like

  24. karsten Avatar
    karsten

    being from berlin i have no clue what to do with vanilla extract once i ve made it. how does it taste, like vanilla flavoured alcohol?

    Like

  25. Leslie Avatar

    Hi Karsten, we Amis use a spoonful of vanilla extract instead of a packet of Vanillazucker when baking. Now that I live in Berlin I also use Vanillazucker in American recipes and the two are interchangeable as far as the recipe coming out the right consistency, but other American Berliners like Sylee (first commenter above) have told me that the extract gives a much stronger and clearer vanilla flavor. Maybe I don’t notice the difference because I’m not much of a baker, ha ha.

    Like

  26. Leslie Avatar

    By the way, I have been to Vanilla Saffron’s bricks-and-mortar shop in San Francisco, which is actually an ice cream shop focusing on different kinds of vanilla ice cream. They have their vanilla and saffron products on display too and seem to be a serious, no-frills specialist in these two flavorings.

    Like

  27. Kate in New York Avatar

    Thanks for this recipe! I’ve been wanting to try making vanilla extract. Especially since, lush that I am, I have had the same bottle of good vodka in my freezer for three years now. Have you tried making any other extracts this way, like lemon or almond?
    Also, cheers to the resolutions that recognize what you need for peace of mind. Sometimes as they get more important they’re harder to recognize!

    Like

  28. Luisa Avatar

    You wouldn’t want to drink it – as Leslie said, Americans use it in baking recipes or other sweet things like pudding, for example. It adds vanilla flavor. It’s a must in chocolate chip cookies! 🙂

    Like

  29. Luisa Avatar

    I haven’t tried this with anything else, but to make limoncello, the first step is to steep lemon peel in alcohol, so it certainly works!

    Like

  30. Debbie Tanner Avatar

    We live in South Florida and grow our own beans! We just harvested some and we use a mix of half vodka and half brandy because I like the flavor better.

    Like

  31. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    What kind of vanilla beans do you recommend. I noticed at the food store I shop at there is a huge price difference — from around $28. for 8 for the ones from Madagascar all the way down to the cheaper ones bought in the bulk section.

    Like

  32. Susan Ralston Avatar
    Susan Ralston

    I am so excited to make my own vanilla extract. And if it tastes as good as it sounds I will be making it for my three precious daughter in laws. The problem I have is I do not drink alcohol and I don’t know which kind to buy for this. I know there is a wide range of producers and prices. Do I purchase the expensive kind or a particular brand?
    P.S. Being the best momma and wife is a good resolution. If you accomplish anything else consider it a bonus. Thank you so much for your blog. I am always excited when you post something new.

    Like

  33. Luisa Avatar

    I hear you – I barely crack a glass of wine a week. 😉 I had a bottle of cheap vodka hanging around from my husband’s birthday party about four years ago. I don’t see any point in using an expensive alcohol for this recipe – the point is the vanilla beans and their essence, which will be pulled out from them from any quality of alcohol. Go with what’s cheap! And thank you for your wise words! 🙂

    Like

  34. Luisa Avatar

    It doesn’t really matter. If you’ve got the cash for the fancy ones and feel like splurging on them, go for it – but cheap beans are still vanilla beans, so either way you’re going to have a pretty great extract. If it’s any help, the beans I used were definitely the cheap ones.

    Like

  35. Carmit Avatar

    I hopped on the vanilla bandwagon a few years ago and haven’t looked back. I also keep a bean in my sugar jar and every time I use a bit I feel a bit smug :). Aldi/Lidl sell beans for about 50 cents a piece around Christmas time, so that’s always a good time to stock up.
    A few years ago I made a few bottles to give away as gifts and having just bought about 4L of vodka, ran out and had to pop back into the grocery store to get another bottle. I did get a dirty look from the cashier.

    Like

  36. Andy Avatar

    Awesome sharing. I can’t wait to give this a try and do away with buying vanilla extract. Hope this home made vanilla extract taste better if not as good as those selling in my shop!

    Like

  37. Kate Avatar

    This sounds magnificent! I moved to England a few months back from the States, and have found vanilla to be one of those sadly expensive things.
    I was lucky enough to receive your book for Christmas – I’ve been wishing for it for ages, and someone finally took the hint and gave it to me. It was definitely worth the wait, not least because you are an incredibly easy person to empathize with (which is partially your style, and partially the shared experiences). I moved to England because of my then-fiancé, and when I read your book (flying over the Atlantic and wondering whether I’d really have the nerve to get on the one back to England, as I was unemployed and increasingly becoming aware that I was in England for my fiancé, not entirely for me) I took deep solace in the knowledge that someone else had gone through all the stupid things I was experiencing, and that maybe it would all be okay. When I got back, I managed to get everything in place to have a life here, and pretty much have a job and everything, but in a bit of a twist of fate, I got dumped. Now I really don’t know what to do – there aren’t really any maps, and no one can tell me what would really be best – but I guess I’ll have to figure that out. Maybe someday I’ll get an ending as wonderful as yours. I will, in the meantime, take your advice and eat a little Greek salad, and I will not skimp on the salt.

    Like

  38. Vikki Avatar
    Vikki

    I can only get a 750 ml of vodka here — can you please tell me how many vanilla beans I need to use for that amount? thanks!

    Like

  39. deb mattin Avatar

    Timely post as I am soaking off a bottle label in preparation for making extract. I have some beans left0over from my Christmas DIY kahlua and am anxious to try homemade extract. I love the idea of feeding the extract – adding more vodka and beans and just keep it going. starting mine tomorrow!

    Like

  40. Luisa Avatar

    Oh honey. I’m sending you the biggest hug. I’m so sorry. My only advice: be gentle with yourself and listen to your gut. It knows where to take you. xoxo

    Like

  41. Nuts about food Avatar

    Duh, of course, sorry! ;o)

    Like

  42. Megan Avatar
    Megan

    Thanks!

    Like

  43. MB Manion Morell Avatar

    What a fantastic post… thanks for the idea, Luisa! I just finished your book a few weeks ago, and absolutely loved it! As someone who has lived and traveled all over the world since I was 10, and gravitates to experiencing life through food, I could relate so much to your writing! In part inspired by your book, my New Year’s resolution was to begin a blog, which I titled Bourbon and Brown Sugar http://bourbonandbrownsugar.wordpress.com/ – First resolution I can remember ever keeping, as I’m having SO much fun with it. Seems that concocting vanilla extract with bourbon might be an interesting adventure to try in the spirit of blogging fun… cheers…

    Like

  44. Joshua Hampton Avatar

    I never thought making your own vanilla extract is so easy. Thanks for this.

    Like

  45. MB Manion Morell Avatar

    Luisa, First – I wanted to let you know how much I enjoyed “My Berlin Kitchen.” As a person who has lived and traveled all over the world since I was 10, I could SO relate to your experiences… and it made me realize how many of my own memories over the years are food-related. Thanks in part to your fantastic book, which I finished just before the holidays, my New Year’s Resolution was to begin a blog. As it is titled “Bourbon and Brown Sugar” I think I’ll have to try the bourbon-vanilla combo in the spirit of adventures in blogging. I’ll be ordering some vanilla beans during my snow day here on the east coast of the US. Thank you so much for the wonderful idea!

    Like

  46. Erika Avatar

    Sounds great, Didn’t know you couldn’t purchase vanilla beans online, you can purchase just about anything online these days lol. Any alcohol will do? or is Vodka the best bet.

    Like

  47. karsten from berlin Avatar
    karsten from berlin

    ok, went to poland to get decent vodka and got the vannilla beans. before I mix the two, what exactly can I do with the combination?

    Like

  48. Luisa Avatar

    You use vanilla extract in any baked good to give it a bit of vanilla flavor – just like Vanillezucker, but it has more fragrance and depth (and no sugar). For example, it’s an essential ingredient in chocolate chip cookies! Enjoy.

    Like

Leave a reply to Nuts about food Cancel reply