DSC_3869

"Who will free apples from the tyranny of cinnamon?" was something I was, no joke, thinking about the other day. "I mean, I like cinnamon," I continued telling myself, as Hugo took a 17th screeching turn around the coffee table (his new thing: racing around it like it's Daytona and he's, um, one of the guys in a fast car), "but why is it in every single apple recipe I come across? Free yourselves, apples!!" I howled silently. And then, because my companion was a crazy-eyed 16-month-old coffee-table-racing machine screaming "hallo! hallo! hallo! hallo!" as he zoomed forward, I howled it out loud too. Good thing toddlers are so easily amused!

And lest you think I have completely lost my marbles, I would just like to take this moment to say that not a few hours later, I finally happened upon a recipe for apple cake with nary a fleck of cinnamon in sight. It was like someone had heard me or something! Or Dorie Greenspan, to be more specific.

The reason I'd been thinking about apples and their everpresent cinnamon fog is because we are drowning in apples at the moment. I have this irritating habit of buying a few at every market we go to,  but Max and Hugo aren't the biggest apple eaters (they're more in the pear/clementine/grape camp), so unless I eat an apple at every meal, I get buried under them pretty quickly.

DSC_3860

And, like I said, while I have no beef with cinnamon per se, it just gets a little tedious to see it in every apple cake under the sun. So along came a fabulous French friend of Dorie's named Marie-Hélène to liberate me both of my moldering apples and my cinnamon resentment.

Marie-Hélène's apple cake is one of those genius recipes that is hardly a recipe, really, but is the kind of thing you need in your arsenal for the rest of your life. The batter is awesomely easy – you only need a whisk and a bowl and a stove for melting butter. The original recipe asks for 3 tablespoons of rum, which would make for a fabulously grownup cake, boozy and moist. But since I was making this for a playdate with a friend and her son, I decided to go with only one tablespoon of alcohol (bourbon, since I was out of rum) and two tablespoons of whole milk. The batter is silky and there's relatively little of it, especially with regards to the mountain of chopped apples that gets folded in. In fact, when you pile it into the cake pan, you'll see it is that holy grail of cakes: more apple than cake. Exactly what I wanted.

DSC_3883

We ate it once it had cooled sufficiently and it was fragrant and delicate and the apples (I'd used a mix of Boskoop and Elstar, I think) were supple and lovely. It was perfect playdate material, though of course I was also already imagining it as a dinner-party dessert, since it was so light and appley. (Though the next time I make it, I will be reducing the sugar by a few tablespoonfuls.) By the next day, the cake had morphed into something almost akin to a clafoutis – the cake bits were more pancakey than cakey and the fleeting flavor of the bourbon was entirely gone. It was just as delicious and very well suited for breakfast.

An apple cake for every time of day! Holy grail indeed. And no cinnamon in sight.

Marie-Hélène's Apple Cake
Makes one 8-inch cake
Adapted from Around My French Table

3/4 cup all-purpose flour
3/4 teaspoon baking powder
Pinch of salt
4 large apples (if you can, choose 4 different kinds)
2 large eggs
3/4 cup sugar
1 tablespoon dark rum or bourbon
2 tablespoons whole milk
1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
8 tablespoons (1 stick/4 ounces) unsalted butter, melted and cooled

1. Center a rack in the oven and preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Line the bottom and sides of an 8-inch cake pan with parchment paper.

2. Whisk the flour, baking powder, and salt together in small bowl. Peel the apples, cut them in half and remove the cores. Cut the apples into 1- to 2-inch chunks.

3. In a medium bowl, beat the eggs with a whisk until they’re foamy. Pour in the sugar and whisk for a minute or so to blend. Whisk in the rum, milk and vanilla. Whisk in half the flour and when it is incorporated, add half the melted butter, followed by the rest of the flour and the remaining butter, mixing gently after each addition so that you have a smooth batter. Switch to a rubber spatula and fold in the apples, turning the fruit so that it's coated with batter. Scrape the mix into the pan and even the top.

4. Slide the pan into the oven and bake for 50 to 60 minutes, or until the top of the cake is golden brown and a knife inserted deep into the center comes out clean; the cake may pull away from the sides of the pan. Transfer to a cooling rack and let rest for 5 to 10 minutes.

5. Carefully pull the parchment paper – and the cake – out of the pan and let cool on the rack until it is just slightly warm or at room temperature, then transfer to a cake plate. The cake can be served warm or at room temperature, with or without a little softly whipped, barely sweetened heavy cream or a spoonful of ice cream. The cake will keep for about 2 days at room temperature. However long you keep the cake, it's best not to cover it — it's too moist. Leave the cake on its plate and just press a piece of plastic wrap or wax paper against the cut surfaces.

Posted in

78 responses to “Marie-Hélène’s Apple Cake”

  1. Mamen Avatar

    I am an apple cake lover and You just made my day with this recipe 🙂
    Have a nice day!

    Like

  2. julia Avatar
    julia

    Sounds fantastic, i love apple cake! Dear Luisa, in german measures, how big is a 8-inch cake pan?? Thanks a lot!
    All the best, Julia

    Like

  3. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    Did you notice to the side of her recipe Dorie says the French woman she got the recipe from served it with cinnamon ice cream?

    Like

  4. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    I’ve made this cake and it is fabulous — everyone in my family loved it….

    Like

  5. Amy Avatar

    This is my favorite apple-anything. I blogged about it on my blog as well, back when I was still unaware of JUST how good Dorie Greenspan was. This cake definitely makes apples taste more appely, and I think cinnamon would just ruin it. It also has the perfect apple-to-batter ratio, don’t you think?
    Anyway hope you’re doing well Luisa x

    Like

  6. Jennifer Jo Avatar

    I’ve been making this cake for awhile now (got the recipe from David Lebovitz). I serve it with whipped cream, an addition I highly recommend.

    Like

  7. Tara Avatar
    Tara

    Seriously one of my favorite recipes. It was on heavy rotation when I discovered it back in fall 2010. Got me through many a cold evening after Stasi research in Berlin! Glad you found it, it’s a winner.

    Like

  8. Janel Avatar

    This recipe is so simple, what a perfect way to highlight the lovely apples without the risk of overpowering their flavor with spices. Bonus that it’s made with pantry staples!

    Like

  9. olga Avatar

    Spot on, Luisa. Agreed. Poor apples haven’t been allowed to shine on their own. I think this cake is a lovely thing to have with a cup of tea and the flavors are so clean and elegant. We love this cake here but don’t make it often enough. thank you for the reminder!

    Like

  10. Katie Avatar

    Ah! This sounds so perfect. More apple than cake! I will have to make it soon.

    Like

  11. jenny Avatar

    This is so my kind of cake. Officially on the weekend agenda.

    Like

  12. Jemima Avatar
    Jemima

    My Thanksgiving dessert!! Can’t wait.

    Like

  13. Christine Avatar
    Christine

    This looks perfect for both me (lazy, hungry, apple lover) and my husband who hates cinnamon. Thank you!

    Like

  14. Gemma Avatar

    ‘By the next day, the cake had morphed into something almost akin to a clafoutis…’ Just based on this it’s a must-try!

    Like

  15. Heather Avatar
    Heather

    Perfect! Thank you for sharing! I feel the same way, and about pumpkin baked goods as well … so.much.cinnamon.

    Like

  16. Catherine @ Chocolate & Vegetables Avatar

    Oooooh, lovely! I’m always looking for cinnamon-free apple ideas as my other half is inclined towards hating it at times! I’ll have to file this one away for future reference.

    Like

  17. bellini Avatar

    I have made Dorie’s cake and can attest to the fact that is is simply delicious. Easy to put together as well. An excellent combination.

    Like

  18. Giulia Avatar

    Have you ever made the Smitten Kitchen Sharlotka? No cinnamon and even less ingredients than this one. Soooooo good. I also make it with pears and plums.
    http://smittenkitchen.com/blog/2012/01/apple-sharlotka/

    Like

  19. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    You’re funny! And this cake looks amazing.

    Like

  20. Luisa Avatar

    No, I haven’t and it sounds lovely. BUT THERE IS CINNAMON IN THE RECIPE! 🙂

    Like

  21. alison Avatar
    alison

    Yay, I’m so glad you’re back!!! Can’t wait to try this – my husband loves apple pie, but I find making it rather tedious so I’m always on the lookout for other interesting apple desserts.

    Like

  22. Molly Avatar
    Molly

    Mmmmm. I want some now. I wonder if it would be good with crème anglaise.

    Like

  23. Kim A Avatar
    Kim A

    Am going to make it this weekend. Sounds so good,I can’t wait to make it. Thanks. Glad you’re back.

    Like

  24. Tonya Avatar

    This is actually one of my go-to desserts. People find it really impressive but it’s also ridiculously easy to make + if you have apples on hand you probably have everything needed to make it.
    I was actually planning on making this to bring to a dinner party on Sunday!

    Like

  25. Elle Avatar

    Ha. Me too. Anything pumpkin is mindlessly dosed with pumpkin pie spice. I much prefer fun twists like coconut curry or cardamom or even miso tahini. But no, it’s always cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg…lol

    Like

  26. Val Avatar
    Val

    I literally just had this same experience. I too am drowning in apples, and while I’m fine with the apple/cinnamon combo, I too am just tired of it. Then I came across Dorie’s recipe on David Lebovitz’s site, and I’m been waiting for a free afternoon to make it. Glad to hear it’s worth the effort.

    Like

  27. bubblegum casting Avatar

    Yummm!! Looks like a great recipe will have to try this over the weekend

    Like

  28. talley Avatar

    An apple a day keeps the race car driver at play (?!?).
    I adore this cake – so easy to make and eat. I have another recipe for you to try. It’s really freaking good and it doesn’t have any cinnamon in it! It also tends toward a pancakey pudding, as I quote Ali, “You see, Balzano apple cake is more like a cross between a clafouti and a pancake.” Sounds good right? Try it – you and your pile of apples will be happy!
    http://www.alexandracooks.com/2009/11/06/balzano-apple-cake-revisited/

    Like

  29. Kaffiknopf Avatar

    so nice to read you back 😉 hope you are fine. we are crowded with apples, too. And this is my favorite apple cake receipe, too. funny!! I got it from David Leibowitz and all late summer and fall I bake this and an sour cream apple pie “im wechsel”. our apples maybe last for a few more cakes … winter is around the corner. do you have a yummy “Bratapfel”receipe?

    Like

  30. Elizabeth Avatar

    This looks one of those oh so French and elegant cakes. I must admit though I’m partial to a bit of cinnamon in my apple cake though.

    Like

  31. Luisa Avatar

    I’ve had that clipped for ages!! All old-school and pasted in a notebook! SO glad to hear it’s good.

    Like

  32. Monica Avatar
    Monica

    Made this last night and it turned out fabulous! Thanks for the recipe! I used all milk and no rum 😀 (BTW – I think you forgot to add the milk instructions to add the milk in Step 3?)

    Like

  33. Keith Avatar
    Keith

    Yes, I was thinking as I was going along about when the milk would be used and then forgot about it until Monica memtioned it here. Verdict: I don’t think the cake needs it at all – it was perfect without.

    Like

  34. SusanE Avatar
    SusanE

    I just popped it in the oven but forgot to put in the milk….because it was not in the recipe!

    Like

  35. mauigirlcooks Avatar

    I cannot wait to try this recipe; it sounds so moist and delicious! I agree with you about the cinnamon. Cinnamon is one of my favorite spices, but it has a time and a place. I prefer my oatmeal cookies not to have cinnamon, but just nutmeg, as in the Cook’s Illustrated recipe.

    Like

  36. Luisa Avatar

    Indeed. Thanks for catching that!

    Like

  37. Heather Avatar
    Heather

    Exactly!

    Like

  38. Charlotte Avatar

    I’ve made this a few times and we love it – I love cakes that are more fruit than cake. And I get help with the apple cutting (although my helper tends to eat more than he cuts!).

    Like

  39. Karina Avatar

    Yum! I love apple and cinnamon recipes (well I love cinnamon so much, and since I don’t think there are many non-apple cinnamon recipes, I make apple cinnamon a lot), well I never really thought about non-cinnamon apple recipes. But now…maybe a lemony-apple cake would taste good as well? Hmmmm

    Like

  40. Suzy Avatar

    Too true about the cinnamon. I’ve made this cake before, it’s nice to have an easy recipe to hand. I only don’t agree that one should eat different types of apples because they don’t all go soft at the same time and it annoyed me that some apples were uncooked and others perfectly done.

    Like

  41. Lindsay Avatar
    Lindsay

    Looks lovely! I typically don’t mind cinnamon, but my husband is an apple pie devotee, and sometimes I find myself tired of the same old apple pie, every time I make it for him. I’ve tried a number of variations, but our current fave replaces 80% of the cinnamon blend with garam masala, and let me tell you… SO TASTY! I can imagine that change would work in just about any apple application! 😀

    Like

  42. Denise | Chez Danisse Avatar

    I like the abundance of apples in this recipe. The texture looks wonderful. Thank you for the introduction to two new-to-me apple types.

    Like

  43. Kim A Avatar
    Kim A

    Made this tonight. Too impatient to wait for it to cool properly and ate a piece with vanilla ice cream. It was ok. Then just before bedtime went to transfer it from the parchment paper to a plate and a chunk broke off, so I took a bite, and it was so unbelievably delicious. The true flavor is not there until it is completely room temperature. So, so, so good! ThNk you for a wonderful recipe!

    Like

  44. Amy Avatar
    Amy

    It’s a little damp and dreary in NYC this morning and I just made this for Sunday breakfast. So perfect and delish!!! Thanks for sharing. 🙂

    Like

  45. Molly Avatar

    oh holy heck, i think i NEED this in my life! in part because we have, em, 130 pounds (POUNDS!) of apples, in the garage-cum-cold cellar. An apple-picking jaunt a few weeks back, you see. Surely there’s enough there for cake?
    For what it’s worth, my favorite pairing for apple is either the fruit itself, straight-up, or cardamom. Cardamom! Freshly-bashed is wonderful, but whatever. Oh, and nutmeg! (Instead, not And. No apples need And. They’re simple fruits. Straight Or territory.)
    Printing…

    Like

  46. Donne Avatar
    Donne

    Luisa, I wonder if you would be able to estimate the amount of apple in this recipe by volume or weight? I have some apples from a recent glut in the freezer, but as they’re already chopped, I don’t know how much would be equivalent to “4 large apples”. Thanks so much!

    Like

  47. Luisa Avatar

    I’d guesstimate that it’s about 2 or 2 1/2 cups worth? Maybe even 3 cups. But I’m really eyeballing it. The good thing is that I don’t think you have to be totally precise, a few apple pieces more or less isn’t going to hurt anyone.

    Like

Leave a reply to Giulia Cancel reply