Finish

Oof. Readers, Hugo was up four times last night (10:15 pm, 12:50 am, 3:00 am, and then 5:30 am, at which point he started to do this adorable cooing, chattering thing that really is the sweetest thing on the planet except that it's 5:30 in the morning, child, and you have kept me up ALL NIGHT GO BACK TO SLEEP GAH), so, actually, I thought if anything, this day's overwhelming emotion would be one of mild exasperation and slight crankiness (on my part). Instead, as the day wound down and we did our little nighttime ritual, I was overcome with melancholia. It's all going so fast, you see. Too fast.

He'll be six months next week. Wasn't he just born? Wasn't it just yesterday that I saw his little face for the first time? Already, I can list little things that he no longer does, that he's grown out of: No more funny wheezing when he naps in the stroller. No more falling asleep in my arms when I carry him around. No more needing to be nursed to sleep at night. I'm already starting to forget what he felt like in my arms when he couldn't hold his head up on his own. When I realized the other day that Hugo was no longer a newborn, and hadn't been one for some time, my mouth went all dry. Slow down, baby, I heard myself thinking, echoing millions of people before me. Slow down, please. Stay my tiny love a little while longer.

Following Hugo's lead, I put him down tonight for the first time without nursing him. I sang a song, stroked his head once or twice and then said good night and left the room. I was steeling myself for his tears as I walked out, but none came. I stood in the hallway for a while, listening to him coo and then grow quiet. I should have felt so proud, I know, of my boy, not even six months old, now able to fall asleep on his own. But all I wanted to do was cry.

Silly, right? I know. And yet. The heart is a funny thing.

Spice

Hoo! It's probably apparent to everyone that someone else here needs an early bedtime tonight. But before I go, I just need to tell you quickly about these cookies. The thing is, I'm pretty picky when it comes to Christmas cookies. I really mostly just like to eat the ones that Joanie makes. Every year, to be a good sport, I try out new ones, but they're mostly just for show. You know? I'd never really consider adding them to the lineup.

Until now. Seriously.

I'm sure you've heard all about Yotam Ottolenghi and Sami Tamimi's new cookbook, Jerusalem. It's on practically every Best-Cookbook-of-2012 list, on every food blog in creation, heck, there was even a profile of them in the New Yorker last week. I don't have a copy of the book yet, so I can't say a thing about it, really, except that the recipe for Spice Cookies alone (that I found online) is so good it's worth the price of the book alone. As my father likes to say, you really only need one good recipe to make a cookbook worthwhile.

Ottolenghi and Tamimi say that their spice cookies, stuffed with brandy-soaked currants, grated chocolate, winter spices and iced with a sharp, lemony glaze, are meant to be kissing cousins of that old German classic, Pfeffernüsse, and an Italian spice cookie that they found in Nancy Baggett's International Cookie Cookbook. I say that these spice cookies are one of my favorite things I've baked all year. And get this: I'm going to be taking some to Joanie's later this week, when we get together for another round of baking. I can't wait to see what she thinks of them.

Dough

The recipe is a little funny. It calls for only half an egg and a whopping 1 1/2 teaspoons of cocoa powder and you "soak" currants in brandy for all of ten minutes, which doesn't really plump a thing. But none of this matters. Just follow the instructions. Whisk together all the dry ingredients, then beat the butter with sugar and citrus peels and vanilla until a heady, fresh scent drifts upwards from your beaters. The dry ingredients are mixed into the wet until a dark, moody dough forms. It looks like freshly tilled earth. It smells like Christmas.

You form the dough into largish balls. I made the mistake of questioning the size of the balls that the authors call for. Surely, no one would want to eat a 5-ounce spice cookie,  I thought. I'm going to make one sheet of cookies as they call for and another in the bite-sizes that I'd like. Silly woman. Don't make my mistake. Make the cookies big.

Balls

[Freddie totally photo-bombing the cookie dough.]

Crackle

When you bake the cookies, the dough balls collapse outwards and then puff up, little fissures forming on their tops. I'd err on the side of underbaking them ever-so-slightly – a few minutes too long in the oven and you'll end up with a too-dry cookie with too-browned bottoms. 15 minutes should be perfect.

While they're still warm, you make a lemon glaze and then spoon it over the cookies. I had to do this a few times (I suspect my cookies were still too hot) to get the thickness I wanted. If you're more patient than me, only once will probably do. Then you glue a few cubes of candied orange peel to the top of the cookies and you let them rest until they've cooled completely.

Group

When you break one open, you might think they look a little dry. Maybe even a little boring. But one bite, one richly flavored bite with the faint zing of citrus and a winey pop of currant against the spiced, chocolatey dough, will cure you of that thought in an instant. The texture of these cookies is a revelation – velvety is the one word that keeps coming to mind. The thin cap of icing provides the most delicate of snaps. If you took away my beloved Lebkuchen for eternity and left these gems in their place, I'd be grateful. That's how good they are. You know how else good they are? So good I've decided not to bake a single other thing for Christmas except for them, again and again.

And with that, folks, I'm off to bed. My preshus will be up in a few hours to ruin my sleep and I must be prepared.

Ottolenghi's Spice Cookies
From Jerusalem: A Cookbook
Makes 16 large cookies
Note: I grated the chocolate by blitzing it to rubble in the food processor.

Cookies:
¾ cup plus 2 tablespoons (125 grams) currants
2 tablespoons brandy
Scant 2 cups (240 grams) all-purpose flour
1 1/2 teaspoons best-quality cocoa powder
½ teaspoon baking powder
1/4 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon each ground cinnamon, allspice, ginger, and nutmeg
1/4 teaspoon salt
5 ounces (150 grams) good-quality dark chocolate, coarsely grated
1/2 cup (125 grams) unsalted butter, at room temperature
2/3 cup (125 grams) superfine sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1/2 teaspoon grated lemon zest
1/2 teaspoon grated orange zest
1/2 large free-range egg
1 tablespoon diced candied citrus peel

Glaze:
3 tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
1 cup (160 grams) confectioners’ sugar

1. Soak the currants in the brandy for 10 minutes. Whisk together the flour, cocoa powder, baking powder, baking soda, spices, salt, and dark chocolate.

2. Beat the butter, sugar, vanilla, and lemon and orange zest to combine but don't aerate much, about 1 minute. With the mixer or beater running, slowly add the egg and mix for about 1 minute. Add the dry ingredients, followed by the currants and brandy. Mix until everything comes together.

3. Gently knead the dough in the bowl with your hands until it is uniform. Divide the dough into 1¾-ounce (50 gram) chunks and roll each chunk into a perfectly round ball. Place the balls on 1 or 2 baking sheets lined with parchment paper, spacing them about ¾ inch (2 cm) apart, and let rest in the fridge for at least 1 hour.

4. Preheat the oven to 375°F (190°C). Bake the cookies for 15 minutes, until the top firms up but the center is still soft. Remove from the oven. Once the cookies are out of the oven, allow to cool for only 5 minutes, and then transfer to a wire rack.

5. While the cookies are still warm, whisk together the glaze ingredients until a thin and smooth icing forms. Pour a tablespoon of the glaze over each cookie, leaving it to drip and coat the cookie with a very thin, almost transparent film. You may want to repeat this step for a thicker glaze. Top each cookie with 3 pieces of candied peel placed at the center. Leave to set and then serve, or store in an airtight container for a day or two.

Posted in ,

61 responses to “Ottolenghi’s Spice Cookies”

  1. Katerina Avatar
    Katerina

    Dear Luisa,
    I could have written this post today, except for the part that I can’t in a million years write as beautifully as you. My baby is 4.5 months old (also waking up to nurse about every 2 hours all.night.long.) and just today I wanted to find a potion to keep his dear sweet self JUST SO for a little while longer. It is going too fast, and sleep deprivation aside, oh so very glorious. Best wishes!
    Katerina

    Like

  2. Katerina Avatar
    Katerina

    p.s. it looks like your timestamp is still on NY time, not Berlin time…

    Like

  3. Agnes Avatar
    Agnes

    If they can match Lebkuchen, I’ll have to try…

    Like

  4. Sliceofmidlife Avatar

    I’m one of those food bloggers who has gushed over Jerusalem. Do yourself a favor and get the book (or have someone get it for you for Christmas). For the record, his other books Plenty and Ottolenghi are also fabulous.
    By the way, I just finished your book. Lovely read.
    Get some sleep. Before you know it, Hugo will be a teenager.

    Like

  5. Amy Avatar

    Oh very cool & very exciting! The only thing I’ve asked so far from my parents for Christmas is the Jerusalem cookbook. I’m excited to try out these cookies from it.
    Oh! And I have to say, for Thanksgiving I made that butternut squash pie you’ve mentioned on here a few times. It was amazing! I’m afraid I can never go back to regular pumpkin pie again.

    Like

  6. NugicalMusings Avatar

    These look great! I bake a variety of cookies for cookie tin gifts each year, and these might just have to be added!
    nugicalmusings.blogspot.com

    Like

  7. Abby Avatar

    These sound delicious. I’m definitely going to make them for a cookie swap that’s coming up!
    Also, I love your father’s philosophy that a cookbook only needs one great recipe to make it worth buying. So often I covet dozens of cookbooks, only to tell myself that it’s crazy, I’ll never get through all those recipes, so why bother? But your father’s idea makes it feel worthwhile.

    Like

  8. Peggy Avatar
    Peggy

    Luisa, you have my eyes tearing up at work! My girls are 4 and 7, and it is going by entirely too quickly. Now I am longing to be done with work so I can give them hugs and get to making these cookies – they sound and look amazing!

    Like

  9. Juls @ Juls' Kitchen Avatar

    I can barely imagine what feels like to see your son growing so fast. On my side there are nieces, yesterday I was holding their tiny hands and rocking them to sleep, now they steal eggs from my hands when we’re making cookies together, and break them just crushing the shell over the flour… oh, Aunt Giulia, you said eggs! here’s the egg! she left me speechless!
    But back to these cookies: you convinced me to try them, just for me, in my new oven, in my new house, because if they taste like Christmas, I want Christmas in my house!

    Like

  10. Kasey Avatar

    It’s funny how I keep hearing from friends with babies that they grow up so fast and how you wish you could stop time. It feels so strange to me, being only weeks away from my due date, to think I’ll actually want time to slow down…Anyhow, I wanted to say how nice it’s been to see you posting so regularly here. I am one of those people who is in love with the Jerusalem cookbook, though I’ve yet to make these cookies! Get some good sleep 🙂

    Like

  11. Kay Avatar

    My son is 13 months old and I think I’ve said the same thing to myself almost every day since he was born. Everyone says it but it’s just too true…it goes so fast! So many bittersweet moments.

    Like

  12. Laurel Avatar
    Laurel

    I feel you on the sleep front. I’ve got an almost-1 and almost-3 yr old here and it’s lately been a struggle. 6 months is a rough age for sleep, but it will settle down (then comes new challenges!). Years are short and days are long. Can I suggest the book Healthy Sleep, Happy Child?
    Ottolenghi is worthy of a foodie crush, for sure. So many tedious steps sometimes (and tedious measurements!) but the result is always grand. Enjoy!

    Like

  13. Laurel Avatar
    Laurel

    Oh, Luisa, I can’t tell you what a gift it is that one of my very favorite bloggers had a baby boy the same time I did. Every word you write resonates powerfully. Tonight is the first night my guy didn’t need me to nurse him to sleep. As much as I’ve been wanting that, it makes me cry for that to happen, especially as I have just started back to work and he’s navigating day care (with limited success thus far).
    What a gift to Hugo that he can read these postings when he is older. I’m just scribbling “Mommy missed you when she was at work” to mark the day on his calendar.
    I am so loving these frequent postings and your reflections on mommyhood. Thank you! By the way, we have Freddie too–he is the best. As for the cookies, they are on my list. Yum, yum, yum.

    Like

  14. Kira Avatar
    Kira

    You are fantastic, I love your words!

    Like

  15. Kira Avatar
    Kira

    (and your parchment paper, cute!)

    Like

  16. Zoe Avatar
    Zoe

    Hugo sounds so adorable…it made me think of my youngest’s
    cooing sounds…sigh. And I was looking for a great cookie recipe to take to a party next week — sounds like I’ve found it! Hope you get some rest and enjoy your little one — yes, it does go by too fast.

    Like

  17. Hannah Avatar

    Mine are 4 and almost 2 and sometimes I want to cry when I think how fast it is going – sometimes I do cry actually. But there is so much magic along the way. I wasn’t totally sold on trying these – like you, I already have my favorites – although citrus and spice are perhaps my ideal winter combo. But then there was this, “It looks like freshly tilled earth. It smells like Christmas.” And now I am figuring out how to measure half an egg 🙂 Thanks as always Luisa.

    Like

  18. jodye @ chocolate and chou fleur Avatar

    I’m very nearly obsessed with lemon glazed spice cookies. I can’t even count the number of times I made them last fall and winter, and it looks like the baking will begin again, now that you’ve reminded me! The candied citrus peel sounds like a lovely addition. I may have to throw in some candied ginger too!

    Like

  19. Vicki Avatar
    Vicki

    I have a lot of cookbooks so only allow myself 2 or 3 new ones each
    year. So far I’ve gotten two 2012 cookbooks — yours and Jerusalem.
    I’m thinking your new book is really classified as memoir, but it lives with my favorite cookbooks 🙂

    Like

  20. Suzy Avatar

    These were sooooo gooooooood!

    Like

  21. Sasha Avatar

    Holy. I. have. to. bake. these. now. now. now.
    Thank you for this recipe. After I bake these cookies I’ll have to buy Jerusalem. Long live cookie season!

    Like

  22. Amanda Avatar

    Funny Louisa, these even look ho-hum. But you’ve sold them, and I trust you. So here we go.

    Like

  23. Amanda Avatar

    ps. Is this really calling for half a large egg? Just making sure that wasn’t your late mama-night talking. I’m about ti double it to keep from doing that. (See how much I trust you!?)

    Like

  24. Victoria Avatar

    Hi, Luisa,
    First off, your mother’s meatballs are officially now MY meatballs. I think once you’ve made something fifteen times and haven’t even thought about making the meatballs you have eaten your whole life, you can claim the new ones as your own. Done!
    These cookies look great and worth trying. I am actually headed to Florida for a few days of vacation, but as soon as I’m back to NY, I will make them.
    Happy holidays dear girl. Won’t this be a fun season?

    Like

  25. kt Avatar
    kt

    This is why people have more than one child! My youngest is 15 months, and I can’t imagine coping with more than 2 children, but part of me craves another newborn.
    The cookies sound amazing. And that cookbook is on my Christmas wish list!

    Like

  26. Em Avatar

    I don’t think it is at all silly that you wanted to cry when Hugo went to sleep on his on. Not at all! I sobbed when my daughter stopped nursing (at 13 months).
    Also, these cookies sound amazing. Seriously, though, how do you measure half an egg? I’ve never done that before.

    Like

  27. Caitlin Avatar

    I have one question – did you use baking chocolate or sweetened chocolate? They look fabulous – I’m going to try them tomorrow!

    Like

  28. Eloise Avatar
    Eloise

    THANK YOU! I just made these after scouring the internet last night for some good christmas cookie recipes, and this morning before doing my shopping checked in with you, and you truly saved me.
    These are incredible and turned out perfectly. I truly was nervous what with the 1/2 egg. I also omitted brandy and currents (boyfriend won’t eat them..grr..) and substituted water.
    My only complaint – they make only 14 cookies! I will need to make more asap!
    Also, is it possible to add the glaze later (i.e tomorrow..)? I forgot to buy powdered sugar, of course.

    Like

  29. Luisa Avatar

    Amy – yay, I’m so glad you liked it!
    Abby – right? I totally agree.
    Peggy – hugs to you, mama!
    Kasey – oh, I know, it’s weird. Especially at your stage, when you just want the baby there already.
    Laurel – I had a look at that book, but in general have realized that I am not cut out for parenting books: they turn me into a total stress-case!
    Laurel (two Laurels in a row!) – I’m so glad you know how I feel. It’s nice to know that another little boy was transitioning “away” from his mother last night, too! 🙂
    Kira – thank you!
    Hannah, Amanda, Em – you measure half an egg by cracking the egg into a bowl, beating it and then only pouring half of the beaten egg into the cookie batter.
    Victoria – yes, they are yours!!! Enjoy the gorgeous Florida weather, how lovely. And have I already told you that we listen to the Natalie Merchant CD you sent every day?! And every time, I think of you! Thank you xo
    kt – yes! I get it now, I do. More babies, more more please.
    Caitlin – sweetened! but dark, not milk. If you’ve got chocolate with anywhere from 55 to 75% cacao, that’s what I’d use.
    Eloise – I’m so thrilled that you made them already and loved them so much. Wonderful! I think the glaze won’t stick the day-old cookies as well as if they were still warm. But it’s worth a try! (Also, next time you make them, I think you should slip the currants in anyway. Want to bet he’ll like them? I don’t actually like currants that much, but in this recipe, I thought they were marvelous.)

    Like

  30. Omar Avatar
    Omar

    Your posts about Hugo or Berlin or time always make me misty! And let me tell you, I’m not a misty type. Love the blog and cook from it often. Just ordered Jerusalem thanks to you!

    Like

  31. Vicki Avatar
    Vicki

    Been looking for this recipe for years. Tried it, LOVED them! Thank you for sharing and recommending the cookbook as well. Hope you got some sleep…

    Like

  32. laura k Avatar

    That parchment paper is the best. I’m guessing that’s a German thing. Just another reason to go to Germany.

    Like

  33. Caroline in San Francisco Avatar
    Caroline in San Francisco

    “The heart is a funny thing”. Just lovely and so true.
    I am not a spice cookie person, but your words sold me on this recipe (and possibly the cookbook)! Thank you.

    Like

  34. kaktusfink Avatar
    kaktusfink

    I made those today and used a whole (rather small) egg – they turned out perfect.
    Danke für die Erinnerung an dieses Rezept, ich habe das Buch und finde es wunderbar, war aber noch nicht auf die Idee gekommen, darin nach Weihnachtsplätzchen zu suchen. Jetzt tut mir fast der Lebkuchenteig leid, der seit Oktober darauf wartet, gebacken zu werden …

    Like

  35. Silvia Avatar
    Silvia

    You have been dedicated to explorations of your multiple cultures and worlds throughout your life, culinary and otherwise. I wonder why your Jewish heritage has not awakened any curiosity in you. It’s part of your legacy and that of your son, whom you are no doubt interested in exposing to his multicultural world-Jewishness, too, is part of his background. And a centuries long German culture, as well, the 20th century not withstanding.

    Like

  36. Luisa Avatar

    Omar – aww! Thank you!
    Vicki – so glad!
    Laura – isn’t it awesome? It’s been discontinued, sadly!
    Caroline – thank YOU!
    Kaktusfink – ich wäre auch nie auf die Idee gekommen! Viel Spass beim Lebkuchen backen – seit Oktober, das wird ja lecker!

    Like

  37. Susan Avatar
    Susan

    My Grandson Safi arrived at about the same time as Hugo, so I am remembering the feeling of baby time going by TOO FAST too, now. Slow down, please, I think.
    REALLY hard to be a nana with a 19 hr drive between us.
    I also recently acquired TWO cookbooks, yours and Jerusalem. I LOVE both. I bought a pomegranate yesterday, as a result.
    A comment was made about the ‘magic along the way’, as they grow, and I know that to be true too. Enjoy every minute.

    Like

  38. Ciao Chow Linda Avatar

    I can relate to the feeling of time going by so quickly. My little ones are 35 and 32 and it seems like only yesterday that I was holding them in my arms. Enjoy, enjoy. These cookies really resonated too – I grew up eating something almost identical by my Italian mom. She called them “brownies” which they weren’t, and I wrote about them in the early days of my blog. They’re here if you want to take a look:http://ciaochowlinda.blogspot.com/2008/12/italian-christmas-brownies.html
    Anything Ottolenghi makes is outrageously delicious. That cookbook is on my wish list.

    Like

  39. Grace Claus Avatar

    what darling parchment paper!

    Like

  40. robyn Avatar
    robyn

    Luisa – do you think these would freeze nicely (after baking) – even with the orange peel on top?

    Like

  41. Mathilda Murray Avatar
    Mathilda Murray

    Hey Luisa!
    That looks all good.. . I am excited about your book, since I also live here in Berlin… Hope you like this app below by chance, since there is a lot of other traditional recipes featured!
    Best,
    Mathilda
    https://www.facebook.com/smartcaruk/app_538476539514757?ref=ts

    Like

  42. Molly Avatar

    See, now, I have passed by these cookies countless times — too muddled, don’t like currants, not enough spice, too dry, blah blah blah — but now, NOW, to hear you rave, I want to make them yesterday.
    And Luisa, the book is the bomb. The eggplant. The hummus. Old familiars, made brand new again. A treasure trove.
    And dear Luisa, you sweet thing, this growing up business is bittersweet and wonderful and heartbreaking, isn’t it? It only gets better and worse with each year. But oh, the privilege of being along for the ride, no?
    Happy springerle munching to you, my dear,
    xo,
    Molly

    Like

  43. Mai Lowe Avatar
    Mai Lowe

    I have a 7 week old (turned 7 wks only about an hour ago!) and I could not agree more with the sentiment that time goes by all too quickly. And I know exactly what you mean with the cooing and chattering noises – my son just started making those! and they melt my heart and I have to hide my huge smile at night while i’m trying to stay focused on getting him back to bed!
    These cookies sound delicious and actually look quite easy to make. I can’t wait to try them.
    I can’t reiterate enough how much I love your more frequent postings and your sharing of how mommyhood is going for you. Thank you so much!!

    Like

  44. Becki Avatar
    Becki

    I made these cookies today, how could I not, after what you wrote about them?! Mine turned out just like your pictures, which always makes me happy and the texture is like VELVET! That’s the best way to describe them. Next time, a double batch.
    This cookbook is on my wishlist, and hope some one picks it!
    Oh, a question for you. How did you grate the chocolate? It makes kind of a mess using the box grater (lighter than air, the pieces fly all over). Do you have a better way?

    Like

  45. Luisa Avatar

    Robyn – honestly, I’d just freeze them in the dough ball stage. I think you’ll have more delicious cookies if you bake them freshly.
    Molly – I clearly need to own it! And yes, it’s a total privilege. Am loving (almost) every minute. 🙂
    Mai – 7 weeks! Aww! I’m all nostalgic already!! So glad you’re having fun reading. 🙂
    Becki – YES! I’m thrilled to hear it. As for the chocolate, I broke it into rough pieces and then blitzed them in the food processor. Way easier than grating! In fact, I’m going to go update the post now.

    Like

  46. jenn Avatar

    maybe this is a silly question-but do you use dried currants or fresh? thanks!

    Like

  47. Taylor @ Sports Clothing Avatar

    Hmmm looks really yummy and I’ll surely try this at home and let you know how it came.

    Like

  48. Luisa Avatar

    Jenn – dried!

    Like

  49. Bess M. Avatar
    Bess M.

    These are so delectable and very forgiving as I totally messed them up. I didn’t have currants, so used golden raisins, and when baking these with my 3 children, misread the recipe and added 1.5 TABLESPOONS instead of teaspoons of cocoa. No matter; these were fragrant, velvety (as another commenter above noted), and so, so good. I will make them the proper way just to compare, but the mistakes were keepers, too. Well, actually, they only kept overnight as they were such a hit here. Thanks for passing along the recipe.

    Like

  50. Ally Avatar
    Ally

    After that absolutely insanely wonderful panforte by Tartine you posted a few years ago, I have to trust your recommendation on these cookies too. I was looking for a chewy ginger cookie, but these seem close.

    Like

Leave a reply to Grace Claus Cancel reply