DSC_4316
I have no explanation why it's taken me so long to write about these little pumpkin packets. After all, I've been making them for the better part of the past three years. They jumped out at me from the pages of the first Moro cookbook, written by a husband-and-wife team both named Sam, for the sole reason that I hadn't ever seen pumpkin, or squash, really, and feta together and the moment I read those two ingredients on the same page, it sort of clicked in my mind. What a perfect combination – sweet and fudgy, soft and sheepy.

The fatayer look like they'd be a pain in the neck to make, what with a dough and roasted squash purée and then the assembly, along with some toasting of nuts. But strangely enough, they come together very quickly. I've made these on weeknights, in fact. They're easy as…oh, forget it.

They're very filling – you won't need much more than a little salad alongside one of them for dinner. That's if you make four big ones from the recipe. If you want to make smaller fatayer, it's no problem – you just turn them into eight smaller ones. That's probably more sensible, though I've never done it.

DSC_4295

Don't let the dough scare you off: it's silly easy. You just mix water, flour, yeast, salt and a little olive oil. Hardly any different than pizza dough, though the proportions are different. Don't be tempted, like I was, to substitute different flours for the regular, all-purpose kind. White flour gives the fatayer a bit of snap – the dough's rolled so thin that it crisps up beautifully in the oven and almost snaps when you bite into it. If you use whole wheat (or in this case, whole wheat spelt flour), the dough never quite gets to that crackly stage and it's a pity.

While the dough is rising, you roast the squash with garlic and salt and oil. Then you purée it and while you're at it, you might as well go ahead and toast the pine nuts now and crumble the feta and prep the oregano, too.

Then, the rest is no worse than an after-school crafting assignment. Divide the dough into fourths or eighths. Roll it out thin as can be. Fill it with dollops of squash purée, crumbled feta, a sprinkling of oregano and the toasted pine nuts. Fold each one up into a rough triangle and bake just until the dough is turning golden and crisp.

DSC_4328

You have to let the fatayer cool just a bit after they're finished baking, which will be difficult. Your house will already smell of toasted garlic and roasting squash and now the smell of baking bread will join it. But if you don't wait, take it from me, you risk burning your mouth.

But then, when they're ready, oh, are you in for a treat. The salty goat cheese, the hot, sweet squash, the punch of the oregano and the nice waxy feel of the pine nuts all work together very, very nicely. These are inspired little things. They're perfect for those nights when you're curled up on the couch for dinner – they don't really crumble and if they've cooled enough, you can even munch them out of hand. Perfect for these lengthening autumn evenings or for those of you stuck indoors by a menacing storm.

Stay safe, New York. xo

Sam & Sam Clark's Pumpkin Fatayer
From Moro: The Cookbook
Makes 4 large or 8 small fatayer

Dough
220 grams all-purpose flour, plus more for dusting
1/2 teaspoon instant yeast
100 milliliters warm water
1/2 teaspoon salt
2 tablespoons olive oil

Filling
800 grams kabocha, hokkaido or butternut squash, peeled (if necessary), seeded and cut into chunks
1/2 garlic clove, crushed to a paste
Salt
1 tablespoon olive oil
80 grams feta cheese, crumbled
a handful fresh oregano, chopped (I used a sprinkle of dried oregano)
1 tablespoon pine nuts, toasted
Salt and pepper

1. For the dough, place the flour in a mixing bowl and make a well in the middle. Sprinkle the yeast in the well, then pour in the water and mix slowly together, adding the salt and olive oil as you go. Knead the dough together on a floured surface for about 5 minutes, until the dough is smooth and no longer sticky. Set aside and cover with a cloth.

2. Heat the oven to 450 F (230 C). Toss the pumpkin with the garlic, olive oil and salt to taste and arrange on a baking sheet. Roast, stirring often, for 25 minutes or until soft. Remove and let cool slightly before puréeing.

3. Divide the dough into four or eight equal pieces. Roll each piece into a ball and then, using a rolling pin, roll out one ball very thinly. Eyeballing the pumpkin purée, put either a quarter or an eighth of it in the middle of the round. Top with some of the crumbled feta, oregano and pine nuts. Moisten the edge of the dough with a little water, then gently squeeze the adjoining edges together until you have a rough triangle shape. Pinch the edges together well.

4. Place the fatayer on a parchment-lined baking sheet and bake for 10 to 15 minutes, until the dough is starting to turn golden brown. Let cool for a few minutes, then serve.

Posted in ,

31 responses to “Sam & Sam Clark’s Pumpkin Fatayer”

  1. Sharmila Avatar

    They look like giant samosas which make me want them already. Squash from CSA box – meet your sweet, triangular fate.

    Like

  2. Shmuel Avatar
    Shmuel

    They also look like hamantaschen, which are traditional Purim a Jewish holiday sweets.
    Feta, its saltiness, goes well with sweets. Most famous is watermelons with feta.

    Like

  3. Sylee Avatar

    Recently found pumpkin + feta in Skye Gyngell, but unpocketed. I think the dough is the missing element that makes me want to make this tonight rather than sometime!

    Like

  4. Saraspunza Avatar

    Okay, these are on the list for tonight. Wow, they look scrumptious. I think I will roast up the butternut squash though and keep it in chunks. I hope it works! I can see the salad on the side, with some pomegranate seeds sprinkled to and fro…

    Like

  5. Danielle Avatar
    Danielle

    Luisa, I love your recipes and stories and have been a regular reader for quite a while (although I have never posted). This recipe looks delicious and I can’t wait to try it! Do you think canned pumpkin, mixed with the garlic and herbs, would work as a substitute for fresh pumpkin?
    Thanks! 🙂

    Like

  6. Amanda Avatar

    I’ll make these as soon as I get an oven. Imagine life without an oven. Exactly.

    Like

  7. Anne Avatar
    Anne

    2 questions but first a comment. Looks yummy. I’ve never used instant yeast but notice that it’s used in pizza dough as well as this one..why? and 2, how long do you let the dough rise.

    Like

  8. june2 Avatar
    june2

    Amanda, get a toaster oven! They work just fine, and you can find perfectly decent ones under $50. For a bit more you can find one that will hold a whole roast chicken.

    Like

  9. Omar Avatar
    Omar

    I can report that uptown NYC has been spared any real damage as of 10:17 PM on Monday. I am in a bit of despair as the ingredient amounts given are by metric weight.. and would love to make these (I have some freshly roasted pumpkin in the fridge). I’m an American without a scale! Also intrigued by the Moro book.. my family is said to have come from the area.

    Like

  10. Molly Avatar

    Oooooo…. I adore pumpkin + feta. But oregano? Oregano!! I am so all over this.
    And by golly if I don’t have Moro East RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME as I type, sitting on my desk this past week, drool-splatters littering several of the pages.
    Those Sames. They know a thing or two.
    Now go give that little H a squeeze for me, will you?
    xo,
    M

    Like

  11. Molly Avatar

    I meant “Sams” 🙂

    Like

  12. Octavia Avatar
    Octavia

    I love all things pumkiny lol! This sounds delicious one of my favourite dishes is pumpkin mac and cheese, love to know your thoughts 🙂 http://www.amazine.com/story/934432

    Like

  13. katy Avatar

    Since I have a kabocha squash from last week’s CSA box sitting on my kitchen counter and I can never resist any food that consists of either pumpkin or feta, I think this may just be tonight’s dinner. I also woke up to more fog and rain (the true San Francisco treats), so I’ll take any excuse to turn on the oven.

    Like

  14. Marie Matter Avatar

    these look amazing! was thinking of what to make tomorrow for halloween, and these look just perfect!
    xx
    littlekitchie.blogspot.com

    Like

  15. Ann Avatar
    Ann

    Oh no Luisa, are you leaving your beginnings behind you? Milliliters and grams? What are us Americans to do?

    Like

  16. Viviane@Taste-Buds Avatar

    I grew up around Fatayer and eating them but I never had pumpkin ones! These sound delicious actually, and somehow toasted pine nuts are always a treat for me and they can make almost anything better!

    Like

  17. Alyssa Avatar
    Alyssa

    any idea how many cups of squash puree is 800 grams? thanks!

    Like

  18. Luisa Avatar

    Danielle – sure, I think it could work. Freshly roasted squash tastes better, in my opinion, but it wouldn’t be the worst shortcut.
    Amanda – yikes! My condolences.
    Anne – just as long as you’re preparing the rest; it’s about 45 minutes.
    Omar – if you’re uptown, get thee to Zabar’s as soon as they’re open again and buy yourself a little digital scale upstairs. I bought mine there 10 years ago and it’s still going strong. Mine’s a Salter.
    Molly – H is squeezed!! 🙂
    Ann – buy yourself a scale? It’s a good little investment in your kitchen. I also advise metric cooks to have cup and spoon measures, for what it’s worth. (Also, while I think you meant it humorously, really? This is one of the only metric recipes I’ve ever posted on this site…hardly leaving my beginnings behind me.)
    Alyssa – I don’t know, but it looked approximately like 1.5 to 2 cups. 800 grams is a little less than 2 pounds, if that helps…

    Like

  19. Jennie Avatar
    Jennie

    Just wondering if you could make these and then freeze them to be cooked later. Would that work with the dough?

    Like

  20. Luisa Avatar

    Jennie – definitely!

    Like

  21. Rachael Avatar
    Rachael

    Do you cook the Fatayer in the 450 oven you roasted the squash in? Or at a lower temp?

    Like

  22. Luisa Avatar

    Rachael – nope, same oven.

    Like

  23. Suzy Avatar

    So, my sister is working in their kitchen at the moment. SO MUCH TO TELL YOU!

    Like

  24. Hannah Avatar

    These look to DIE for. My tummys rumbling already. Great way to use up of the left over pumpkin from Halloween!
    I also have a few pretty cool ways to reuse your halloween leftovers!
    http://www.amazine.com/story/936592

    Like

  25. clémence Avatar

    Looks delicious!

    Like

  26. Amanda Avatar
    Amanda

    Would just like to say, I made these last night for Halloween dinner and they were delicious! Lots of steps but not too bad, and in the end you get some savory little pockets of goodness. I know this is an authentic recipe from southern Spain, so I’m hesitant to say this, but now I want to experiment with other flavor combinations and fillings. Also they make great leftover lunches- I just threw 2 in a tupperware and ate them at my desk today. Delicious!

    Like

  27. Ugg boots uk Avatar

    The Mavericks defense problem inside and outside Barcelona flowering, to widen the gap in the third quarter. This section, the last 4 minutes and 17 seconds, http://www.uggbootssaleby.co.uk/ Navarro again third succeeded, Michael shooting, outstanding the entire state Jiawa Yi scored four points, Barcelona played 15-5 wave of attacks, and the first three quarters to 74 -56 lead with 18 points.

    Like

  28. Tama K Avatar
    Tama K

    I recently fell in love with a similar Turkish dish called gozleme. The dough is even thinner and the rolled out dough is much larger- put cooked squash, thyme, feta, cooked onions on one half and fold over in half. I also had a version with super thin dough (not quite phyllo) folded in quarters. Same filling.

    Like

  29. Tama K Avatar
    Tama K

    I forgot to mention other combos had mint or parsley with it. Turks have several styles of young cheeses like feta. I was in heaven!

    Like

  30. lolita Avatar

    It looks so cute!And sounds yummy!I wanna have a try!

    Like

  31. Jessica Avatar
    Jessica

    Just made the parts up to put together for tomorrow night’s dinner. (They are all seperate in the fridge.) I don’t have feta, so I’m subbing mozzarella, thus losing that nice saltiness/savoriness. So, I caramelized some onions in smoky ham fat and brown sugar. We’ll see how it goes! Reminds me (with or without the onions) of a favorite recipe I tried from Smitten Kitchen last year, the butternut squash and onion galette. It’s a favorite, but the galette dough is a little tedious with the butter. I’m so excited to try these, as they went together pretty quickly! Thank you.

    Like

Leave a reply to Danielle Cancel reply