DSC_2778

I am stuck. Completely and utterly stuck. I've had these cake photos sitting in this post form for two weeks now and every day I open it up to start writing and every day I close it again because I don't know what on earth to say.

How about this: This cake, it is good. So good! So moist. A little crunchy, too. Not too sweet. Perfect.

My friend Sylee made it for me a while ago, except, because she's Indian-American, she used white poppy seeds instead of black ones. We ate slices of it at her place after a lovely lunch of fava beans and crisped prosciutto on wholesome bread, along with a mug of milky tea. It was such a nice Friday afternoon.

The original recipe uses regular poppy seeds, all chalky and blue. I love the way they pop in the creamy-white batter. I like their slightly stony flavor and the way they taste embedded in the sour tang of the buttermilk batter, the faint whisp of vanilla floating behind them like a nimbus cloud. I like how the cake is almost juicy with moisture, how the top ripples and folds once it's baked. I like the way it makes the house smell.

And that's about it.

DSC_2762

If you could peek into my brain right now, I think you'd have a start. There's a crazy ticker tape parade of stuff going on in there at the moment: finishtaxes findacrib buydiapers whenisthisbabycoming owmypelvis shouldibeworried organicchangingpadversusregularchangingpad whocaresjustbuyaflipping changingpad sheets breastpump owmypelvis whenisthisbabycoming taxes crap taxes yikes whatarewegoingtocallhim bureaucraticpaperwork spineproblems willineedanepidural owmypelvisow and so on.

I've been so lucky so far – the baby is healthy and well, I am doing fine, there is absolutely nothing to worry about. And yet. As the gestation comes to an end, I find myself on the verge of anxious tears a lot. Some of it has to do with the annoying pelvic pain, some of it is because I miss my husband, who is working feverishly before he can take time off and come home before the baby arrives, some of it is because – utterly against my nature – I don't really have anything set yet. I know a baby doesn't need much, I know that we don't need to blow our paychecks at the baby store (trust me, we're not the type), but still, for my own peace of mind, I need to start dealing with the fact that we are still missing the most basic basics: enough clothes for the first few weeks, a changing pad, for cripes' sake, even just a few folded cotton cloths or towels.

Until I do that stuff, I'm afraid that ticker-tape parade of to-do lists and low-grade anxiety isn't going to go anywhere and I will lie awake at night as the rain hits the windows, feeling him bump and wiggle inside me, and worry. Which is silly, I know.

DSC_2770

But really, that shouldn't stop you from making this cake. It's such a good cake. Especially when sliced thickly and served with milky tea in the afternoon. It's comforting and plain, but not boring and the crunch of the poppy seeds is a treat. In fact, when it cools off this weekend, I might even try to distract myself by baking it again so I can eat slices of it for comfort in the afternoons to come, soothing myself like I'll find myself surely soothing this baby just as soon as he gets here, right into my arms.

And who knows, maybe one day the smell of this cake baking will be something that our boy associates with home.

Deborah Madison's Poppy Seed Cake
From Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone
Makes one 9-inch round cake

1 cup poppy seeds
1/2 cup milk, heated, but not boiling
2 cups all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon baking powder
1 teaspoon baking soda
3/8 teaspoon salt
3 eggs, separated
1/2 cup (4 ounces or 113 grams) unsalted butter
1 cup granulated sugar
2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
1 cup buttermilk

1. In a small mixing bowl, combine the poppy seeds and the hot milk. Set aside until needed. Heat the oven to 375ᵒF. Butter and flour a 9-inch spring form pan. Set aside.

2. In a medium-sized mixing bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt.

3. Place the egg whites in the bowl of an electric stand mixer, fitted with the whisk attachment. Whisk on medium-high until firm but moist peaks form. Transfer the egg whites to a small mixing bowl. Using the same bowl as for the egg whites, but now using the paddle attachment, beat the butter and sugar on medium-high speed until light and fluffy, about 3 minutes. Add the vanilla, then beat in the egg yolks, adding one at a time and beating well after each addition. Scrape down the sides of the bowl with a rubber spatula, as needed.

4. Drain the milk from the poppy seeds, discarding the milk. Add the buttermilk and the drained poppy seeds to the batter. Beat until well combined, then again scrape down the sides of the bowl with the rubber spatula. Add the flour mixture to the batter, in thirds. Again scrape the bowl with the rubber spatula, making sure it’s all well mixed. Fold in about a quarter of the beaten egg whites with the spatula, then fold in the rest, mixing gently until just combined.

5. Transfer the batter into the prepared cake pan, smoothing the top with the rubber spatula. Bake until golden and firm, with the sides just beginning to pull away from the pan, about 40-50 minutes. Remove from the oven and place on a wire rack. Carefully run a sharp, thin knife along the sides of the cake, just against the pan, then gently remove the rim and allow the cake to cool to room temperature before slicing.

Posted in

51 responses to “Deborah Madison’s Poppyseed Cake”

  1. Janet Rudolph @ DyingforChocolate Avatar

    Yummy… this cake is laden with poppy seeds..can’t wait to make it

    Like

  2. Sara Avatar

    You mean I’ve had this recipe sitting on my shelf for 5 years? I love how dense it is with poppy seeds. Looks delicious. I can’t say don’t worry (I couldn’t take the same advice myself with my two boys) but just try to remember it is normal, even if we wish it wasn’t. Just keep baking, it’s a good way to channel that energy.

    Like

  3. Honeybee Avatar
    Honeybee

    That looks delicious. My mother is crazy about anything with poppy seeds, I’m going to make this for her.
    The anxiousness a couple of weeks before the “go-live” – sounds veeery familiar. I admit that I also somewhat “mourned” our life as a couple, just the two of us. Although I never dared admit it at the time… Now I’m expecting our second baby (due in october) and I’m already experiencing mild how-on-earth-will-I-manage-with-two panic attacks! Let’s take a deep breath. 😉

    Like

  4. Hayley Avatar
    Hayley

    I can feel your quiet anxiety. You have such a dignified way of expressing it..
    As for the recipe, should one use buttermilk or sour cream? There’s 1C buttermilk in the ingredient list and you mention its tang, while instruction step 4 has ‘sour cream’ with no mention of buttermilk.

    Like

  5. Kat Avatar

    Once he’s born, there’ll be even more to worry about… though the pelvis will feel better. =) Also, we changed our kid on a folded towel for the first few days; if you don’t have a changing pad, the kid won’t mind. Good luck! You can do it.
    The cake looks beautiful, and we actually do have poppyseeds sitting around. Maybe I’ll bake it for Mother’s Day.

    Like

  6. Anna Avatar

    Best of luck with everything! I am sure it will all get sorted out, but I hope you can let go of some of your worries, or just know that they will pass eventually and everything will be fine.

    Like

  7. tracy via the traveling cupcake Avatar

    This cake looks amazing…Im sure its perfect as is but I am envisioning it with a little lemon glaze on top (what is it about lemon and poppy seeds that just makes sense?)
    I had the same anxiety as you (and still do now that my due date is tomorrow). I found the best way to get rid of it was to just get it done (easier said than done, I realize). I made a master list of all the items that we were missing in order for me to feel like we were prepared, and bought them all in one afternoon. It was overwhelming and took me a while, but I felt so much better afterwards.
    And I feel you on the pelvis pain -ouch! Hope you are feeling better and slightly less overwhelmed soon 🙂

    Like

  8. Luisa Avatar

    Sara – that’s what I thought! I’ve had that cookbook for practically a decade, never even LOOKED at the desserts… 🙂
    Honeybee – you can do it! Deep breaths indeed!
    Hayley – so sorry, fixed it now. Just buttermilk!
    Kat – good idea!
    Tracy – a glaze would certainly not hurt. BUT if you are feeling lazy, it’s nice to know the cake is just lovely on its own. 😉 As for the rest: Due date tomorrow, WOW! Hooray and good luck, hope you don’t have to wait too much longer. I want to do just what you’ve done, just barrel through the list in one exhausting afternoon and then have it done. I know I’ll feel better then. 🙂

    Like

  9. Megan Avatar
    Megan

    Happy Mother’s Day.

    Like

  10. Leslie Avatar

    Well, I can certainly understand the anxious mood, but poppyseeds can only help with that – it is said to soothe the nerves.

    Like

  11. Molly Avatar
    Molly

    Order all necessities online and sit back with a slice of this cake. 🙂 It is overwhelming, isn’t it? It will continue to be, but in a more concrete way once Baby Boy arrives! But then you’ll have such a sweet little head to kiss. Best wishes.

    Like

  12. Jill Avatar
    Jill

    My mother used to make a poppyseed cake that I loved. Your recipe makes me want to dig hers out and make it after so many years.
    Try not to worry, but on the other hand, get used to it. It’s a parent’s job to worry and after a while it just becomes a part of who you are!

    Like

  13. Janae Avatar

    Aw, I remember how much those last weeks of pregnancy were uncomfortable, but you’re almost there! I hope you have a smooth end to your pregnancy and a quick and relatively painless delivery (btw – I had my baby in a German hospital, and it was quite the experience! The doctors and midwives gave such excellent care though). All the best to you, and happy mother’s day.

    Like

  14. Marissa Avatar

    Thanks for sharing, Louisa – the lovely cake and, more, the ticker tape. Feel the support you have (near a far) from so many!

    Like

  15. amelia Avatar

    owmypelvis hahahhahahaa — Not that I’m laughing at your pelvis pain.
    p.s. I love poppy seeds. This looks awesome.

    Like

  16. Katie Avatar

    That is a splendid looking cake, Luisa. I don’t open my copy of Deborah Madison’s book enough. Thanks for pulling this treasure out for us.
    All the best with the baby. I’m sure he’ll be beautiful.

    Like

  17. Amy Avatar

    Life’s a funny thing, isn’t it? In the midst of all that worry and anxiety is going to be what I can only imagine as the most beautiful thing that can ever happen to a person. And you get to have it! And that baby boy gets to have you, lucky him. Best wishes Luisa, and happy mother’s day.

    Like

  18. Flora Avatar
    Flora

    Will definitely be trying this recipe – it looks great 🙂
    The UK shops M&S and Mothercare both now deliver to Germany. They sell lots of super cute baby clothes (with much more fun patterns than those in the German shops). I agree with another poster – definitely order everything online. Traipsing round the shops whilst pregnant is not fun. Good luck!

    Like

  19. Eileen Avatar

    Ooh, I could definitely do with a slice of this cake right about now. And what a coincidence–I just so happen to have a big bag of poppyseeds in my spice cabinet right now!

    Like

  20. Katie Avatar

    I’ve never seen a cake like this before that’s so loaded with poppyseeds. It looks just incredible. I’m going to have to go out and buy more!

    Like

  21. Zoomie Avatar

    Take a deep breath, take a short walk (even if it’s raining), and know that all is well with your baby – and you. You’re a terrific writer and you’ll be a great mom. And just think how much fun it will be shopping for the baby stuff once your hus arrives to do it together.

    Like

  22. abs Avatar
    abs

    Louisa, Good luck, don’t worry, it will all work out (with or without the changepad) and you’ll all be just fine. Take it easy on yourself and eat lots of cake! All the best,
    abs.

    Like

  23. Rachael Avatar

    It’s true what they say about not needing a changing pad. You end up doing it on the bed and floor! I did think an organic mattress was a rewarding worthy splurge.
    I say eat eat eat! Try to dwell in these aching quiet days.

    Like

  24. CarrieSnow Avatar
    CarrieSnow

    This cake looks decadent. The only other time I’ve seen so many poppyseeds in one spot was in a certain pastry from the Hungarian Pastry Shop in Manhattan, up by St. John the Divine. We had friends that always brought them for dessert when we had dinner parties at our apartment. They were delicious and unusual– absolutely laden with seeds. I now feel homesick for New York.
    Hang in there with the anxiety. I think personally that once the baby comes so much of that stuff vanishes. As someone else pointed out, the concerns suddenly become concrete, and for me at least, there is something much more manageable about that.
    And bless your pelvis! Mine felt like it was going to split in two for my entire second pregnancy. It helps immensely to have the baby out– however I still had some soreness until a couple of months ago and my son is now almost nine months old. You will probably fare better!
    You are about to feel like the luckiest person on the planet. And really, you are. Happy Mother’s Day.

    Like

  25. Jocelyn Z Avatar

    The other day, a friend who is giving birth around the same time as me (and you!) told me that she got a bunch of burp cloths at her baby shower, and I panicked that I didn’t have any burp cloths for about a half an hour. Even though I knew I could use clean cloth diapers for that.
    I suspect I’m never going to stop worrying. Also, my pelvis hurts, too. And my house is a mess because I can’t bend over to clean things. I’d try to think of nice heartening things to say, but misery loves company, and your ticker tape parade made me feel better: I have one just like it. I hope you find my dirty floor comforting in the same way (or a similar way – I don’t actually wish a dirty floor on you).

    Like

  26. Anna Avatar
    Anna

    a shame that poppyseeds are forbidden to be sold in china. i miss baking with poppy

    Like

  27. Redd H from Salted Spoon Avatar

    I love the idea of eating this while drinking tea. Thanks for the awesome recipe.
    Sending happy baby birthing thoughts!

    Like

  28. Kara Avatar
    Kara

    Quick question – the first step mentions “hot milk” for soaking the poppy seeds. I assume we just heat the 1/2 cup milk from the recipe? Does it need to have anything else done to it? Thanks!

    Like

  29. Sylee Avatar

    The first thing I thought when I read this post is: Luisa needs more cake! And did I tell you that in India, expectant and new mothers are traditionally fed poppyseeds? So consider that a promise, my dear, both for now and for after — xx

    Like

  30. Charlotte Avatar

    It sounds like you have the worrying down pat. I’m with others – order the stuff on-line and get used to the ticker tape parade I’m afraid. Mine looks something like – bookdentistappt boostershots returnlibrarybooksalreadywouldyou omghesalmostfinishedkindergarden whoshouldwehaveforplaydatenextweek aretheswimmingthingsclean whydidisignhimupforfieldhockeywithabigstick whatwasithinking didipaymyvisabillthismonth willsummerclothesfit etc
    This cake looks delicious and something we all could eat in big slabs with tea – wonderful. Good luck with the prep and the sore pelvis.

    Like

  31. Monica Avatar

    I feel for you. I remember a very nagging fear as the end of my first pregnancy approached and I finally decided it was b/c the baby was going to come out whether I said it could or not. I was not in control of the process, and I was really nervous I wouldn’t be able to handle the actual birth (too much pain, something bad happening, etc). Do you think that is part of your anxiety? It all turned out well, of course and I did it three more times, all easier and easier. two epidural, two without. If you need it, feel no shame. And if not being ready with clothes is really on your mind, buy some clothes and swaddling blankets and a few packs of diapers. Checking that off your list may really help. Also, constant pain is a big deal, emotionally. So, don’t dismiss that. Try to hang in there.

    Like

  32. TONYK Avatar
    TONYK

    YOU DO NOT SAY HOW HOT TO HEAT THE MILK — HELP — I REALLY WANT TO MAKE THIS — THANKS FOR THE RECIPE AND GOOD LUCK WITH YOUR COMING BIRTH —
    TONYK

    Like

  33. Mim Avatar

    This cake sounds perfect right about now! I am currently in Germany, and in an ovenless flat, so I will have to wait until I am back in Australia to bake it. Australia, where it’s much harder to find buttermilk. Oh dear.
    I was in Berlin a few weeks back. We had some lovely food adventures!

    Like

  34. Zsofi Avatar

    First of all, the cake looks gorgeous. Mmmm. I love poppy seeds in cakes!
    As to the baby worries–every new mom has them. And there is SO much hype about “how to prepare for baby” that we are made to feel like we need it all totally in hand. I had twins a year and a half ago and I was NOT ready when they came–and everything still was perfect. Hard, but perfect. You will have what you need at the time you need it. You really will. I hope you get some peace in the weeks ahead.

    Like

  35. Luisa Avatar

    Thank you, all, for the encouragement and good thoughts! We spent the weekend zooming around town dealing with baby lists and this morning I’m feeling much more capable. 🙂
    CarrieSnow – I’m so sorry to hear your pelvis still is sore! Hope that goes away soon.
    JocelynZ – ha! It does make me feel better. (Although I also did just think: “burp cloths? cloth diapers? I have neither!!!”).
    Kara – I’m sorry, I fixed it now. All you have to do is heat the milk, but it doesn’t have to boil.
    Sylee – perfect!! I did not know that, but I love it. 🙂
    Monica – yes, absolutely that is part of it! Getting some things lopped off the list this weekend helped so much. The rest, well, I just have to be patient and let go. Eek! 🙂
    Tony – fixed now, just heat it, doesn’t have to boil, though.
    Mim – you can always replace the buttermilk with 1 cup plain milk to which you add 1 teaspoon white vinegar. Let it sit for a few minutes and then stir before adding it to the batter.

    Like

  36. Kika Avatar
    Kika

    enough clothes for the first few weeks and a few folded cotton cloths or towels…
    poor you, if you need some babyclothes or anything really, come over, I’m in Berlin, have two children and I can give you things for the first weeks!

    Like

  37. Andrea Avatar
    Andrea

    I am 31 weeks pregnant now and feel about the same as you. Something I read in a book comforted me: Do you remember your first months of your life? No? Well, be happy, your baby won’t either. 😉 I know this sounds a bit irresponsible, but there is some truth to it. In the same way I just try not to expect perfectness from myself, as the baby propably won’t either. We’ll both be new at this business.
    I am always happy to read your blog and hope to continue to hear from you once in a while after day X. (If your time allows, of course.) I like your style and your recipes! Alles Gute!

    Like

  38. Jamie @ green beans & grapefruit Avatar

    This cake looks like the perfect for breakfast or as an afternoon snack!

    Like

  39. Tamsin Hickson Avatar

    This cake is irresistible, especially with so many good wishes following it in the comments column. My first was born more than twenty years ago but I can so clearly remember those worries. I dreamt a few weeks before the birth that he arrived, a blue stuffed toy, and I put him in a drawer and FORGOT about him, and woke up crying. It is all worth it!

    Like

  40. tricia Avatar
    tricia

    I remember having the same thoughts and worries near the end of my pregnancy. (I now have a three month old.) Non-organic changing pad with organic cover. That was my compromise anyways.

    Like

  41. Molly Avatar

    Dear Luisa,
    You and your pelvis will be rock stars, with regards to this whole little baby business. I know this, absolutely and for sure. You do not know this, yet. But you will. Trust me. There is no doubt, not even a crumb. Not even a smackerel of poppy seed. None, zero, zip. A rock star. Trust me.
    Molly
    p.s.: a folded bath towel makes a very fine changing pad, no joke. but there is no substitute for a poppy seed cake.

    Like

  42. Brittany Mallett Avatar

    Im not usually one to comment, but this time a couldnt help myself. Because I was just where you are… I remember the changing pad anxiety, the anticipation, the pelvis pain, and never ending decisions that had to be made. Our daughter is 2 months old now, and those last weeks of pregnancy are still vivid in my memory. If it helps, we didnt use the change pad for the first 2 weeks, at least. I just changed her wherever I was with a little towel under her butt. So if you dont get one in time, psh, no biggie. Also, they’re so clean at first that you could really get by with just a couple outfits… we got by with 3 until my mom ran out to get her some more.
    As long as you have your boobs, some diapers, and the odd blanket, you’ll be fine. I want to write something comforting enough to calm the excited anxiety of a soon-to-be new mom, but having just been there, I dont think there IS anything… just know that oddly enough, once the baby arrives it all seems so, so, so much simpler.
    Thanks for the recipe! My Oma makes one just like this – can’t wait to try 🙂

    Like

  43. Kim Avatar
    Kim

    I made this cake at the weekend and have to say it’s DELICIOUS!!! Make it now, you won’t regret it!

    Like

  44. Kishori Avatar

    hello – do you think this would freeze and reheat well?

    Like

  45. Ben Avatar

    Yummie!
    This cake definitely has to be delicious! I have a similiar recipe on my blog and it’s one of the best cakes I ever made!
    If you are interested in the german recipe, you can find it here…
    http://www.bensopenkitchen.blogspot.com/2012/04/becherkuchen-mit-mohn-oder-schoko.html
    You can do it also with chocolate instead of the poppyseeds…
    And about the baby worries. I’m having 2 little children (1 1/2 and 3 1/2) with my beautiful wife. We had the same worries. But you’ll see, once the baby has arrived nothing will be as planned before… And that’s a good thing! So don’t plan and worry too much…

    Like

  46. kate Avatar
    kate

    I can’t wait to try this, it looks beautiful.
    And if it makes you feel any better, my baby rarely wore more than her diaper for the first few weeks. It’s nice to have lots of skin-to-skin time with your new baby. Who needs clothes?!
    Good luck 🙂

    Like

  47. zuza zak Avatar

    us poles love poppy seeds in cake!! check out my mum’s poppy seed, chocolate and lemon baba
    http://cheesy-mash.blogspot.com/2012/03/polish-baba-easter-cake.html
    zx

    Like

  48. Wally Avatar
    Wally

    The poppy seeds should be ground (in a spice grinder or coffee grinder) this releases the flavour.

    Like

  49. Luisa Avatar

    Kika – thank you, we got a million adorable little hand-me-downs from friends. Our kid will be warm and toasty! 🙂
    Andrea – not irresponsible at all! Sounds like wise advice to me. 🙂
    Tamsin – Ha! I’m having all kinds of nutty dreams right now, too. Wacky!
    Molly – “a smackerel of poppy seed” might be the most lyrical thing I’ve ever heard. Downright Shakespearean! Thank you, lady.
    Brittany – thank you! Feeling calmer already.
    Kishori – sure thing.
    Kate – that sounds so dreamy… I cannot WAIT!
    Wally – no, actually, I wouldn’t grind the seeds here. You want that lovely crunch and if the seeds are fresh enough, the flavor is delicious and subtle.

    Like

  50. CarrieSnow Avatar
    CarrieSnow

    Just wanted to duck back in to say that I made this cake and could not be happier that I did. It’s heaven…love the crunch, the subtle sweet, and the velvet touch that I think is due to a combination of the whipping of the egg whites and the sheer presence of butter. This is one addictive cake!

    Like

Leave a reply to Kara Cancel reply