DSC_8762

I may have been raised by a Roman in an extended family of Italo-Saxon gourmands, but I will have you know that I periodically, in high school, did indulge in an after school snack comprised of two slices of German Schwarzbrot sandwiching an oozy crimson layer of ketchup. Yes! It's true. I used to eat ketchup sandwiches. But, get this, that's not even the worst of it! Just to mix things up a bit – adventures of a latch-key kid, oh my – I sometimes boiled up a handful of pasta and sauced it with, you guessed it, that sauce of all sauces, ketchup.

Will horrors never cease? You probably think I should have my food professional license revoked.

But you need to know this to understand why, when I read this Minimalist column two weeks ago, my ears pricked up and my eyes widened. Who cares about authenticity? Noodles in a soy broth made with ketchup sounded like my kind of dinner – a throwback to my days on Bambergerstraße after school, gussied up just a wee bit with rice vinegar and toasted sesame oil.

DSC_8767

Posted in , ,

57 responses to “Mark Bittman’s Egg Noodles with Soy Broth”

  1. maggie (p&c) Avatar

    Where would be without the culinary experimentation of the latchkey kids…Probably plenty of people realized they liked tinkering with food in those afternoons alone…
    This looks comforting, and nice for a windy day.

    Like

  2. maggie (p&c) Avatar

    whoops, entered link wrong before. sorry! come visit us at pithy and cleaver, we’re making latch-key kid food, too!

    Like

  3. Adrienne Avatar

    I’m glad to see you gave this one a shot – I must admit I glanced at it and passed right by. Perhaps I’ll give it a try.
    BTW, made the chana punjabi last week and you’re right, it’s spectacular.

    Like

  4. Brittney Sinquefield Avatar

    Have to say I am new to the blog scene but I have really enjoyed all of your posts. Your writitng style is homey and I feel like I am peeking in on a friend. You share so much of yourself! I love it. Please come and visit me over at http://www.bfelicitas.blogspot.com.
    Thanks again for all your wonderful recipes.

    Like

  5. Ronni Avatar
    Ronni

    I noticed this a few weeks ago and made it, too, and we loved it! It’s not authentic, but who cares: it’s quick, easy and very tasty. Also it makes a ton of broth so I saved half of it and used it throughout the week with frozen wontons from Trader Joe’s to make a 5 minute wonton soup. Delicious. There are definitely worse things one could eat.

    Like

  6. stephen Avatar

    one of my favorites! I lived in Hawaii when I was a young surfer and if I wasn’t eating rice then cold noodles for breakfast did the trick. Love em hot, cold, spicy, juicy-buckwheat, rice or flour.

    Like

  7. jenny Avatar
    jenny

    when this recipe first came out in the nytimes I made it with soba (what I had on hand) and added some spinach sauteed with garlic and a hard-boiled egg. I was instantly hooked; the broth is weird and wonderful. definitely going in my permanent repertoire, too.

    Like

  8. meleyna Avatar

    No need to hide your ketchup shame. But being actually Asian, I am embarrassed at how much I like this un-authentic recipe.

    Like

  9. Rose-Anne Avatar

    Hey, I’ve been fantasizing about making some sort of weird, groovy sauce to put on noodles! Great minds think alike 😉

    Like

  10. Chilli Avatar

    I wasn’t a latchkey kid. But to my mother’s despair I was in love with Maggi noodles (Indian equivalent of Ramen when I was growing up) as a post-school snack. These were religiously consumed, of course, covered in ridiculous amounts of ketchup. This recipe appeals to the kid in me like you would not believe!! I missed it on Bitman’s column but am so glad you posted it!
    I recently discovered english brown sauce which I lov-v-v-ed. Am going to try this recipe using that instead of ketchup…

    Like

  11. Erik Avatar
    Erik

    my pièce de résistance: gummy worm soup with Hershey’s Syrup substituting for chicken stock

    Like

  12. Tea Avatar

    My brother and I–in our latchkey days–came up with something called Bachelor Beans: a can of refried beans, a can of corn, grated cheese, all warmed up with cubes of tomato thrown in and eaten with chips. I still make it for camping trips.
    I wonder if you could add greens and a poached egg to this? My lazy comfort suppers are usually soba done that way (here and here) but I like this Chinese-style version.
    And I love the image of you making little kitchen messes on your own. So sweet!

    Like

  13. Heather Avatar

    Sounds good and simple! I might have to whip this up after a long week of culinary school :)- I will be in need of something simple!

    Like

  14. Amy C Avatar
    Amy C

    I love this recipe…I tried it the day I saw it in the NYtimes. I subbed half of the water for a veggie broth I had sitting around. It tasted vaguely like beef ramen noodles, in a good way – just a homey, tasty noodle broth.

    Like

  15. Mama JJ Avatar

    Back when I was not-a-latch-key-kid of ten or so, I would just slather the pasty white hotdog buns (after we ran out of the hotdogs) with ketchup and mustard and call it delicious. Shudder!
    I want to try this recipe. I like the idea of adding some green veggies to bulk it up—I bet chard would be lovely.

    Like

  16. Ellen Avatar
    Ellen

    On the ketchup front…in Japan, spaghetti is made like yakisoba–stir fried, only with ketchup as the sauce. (First you cook onions, maybe a little meat or veggies. Then you add your cooked spaghetti. Then you squirt in ketchup.) This is why Japanese spaghetti (at people’s homes anyway) is often so sweet…

    Like

  17. KT Avatar

    my occasional noodle craving just kicked in. must… eat… noodles…

    Like

  18. Angela Avatar
    Angela

    I was thinking about this on the rainy ride home today and thought it might be just the thing for dinner … you’ve convinced me. My son will not believe it when he sees me willingly add ketchup to a dish. Thanks.

    Like

  19. Tiffany Avatar

    I made this the other day too! Love the simplicity and so much better than instant noodles. I used a spinach fettuccine which worked just fine.

    Like

  20. unconfidentialcook.com Avatar

    I saw this and wondered about the ketchup…now I’ll give it a try. Thanks!

    Like

  21. EB Avatar

    As a latchkey kid I was all about funky noodle soups. I called them ‘fridge soup’… they always had a soy sauce base but never ketchup. I bet this would take me back to sitting on the couch watching Jem and slurping noodles.

    Like

  22. nicolette Avatar

    oh my gosh, the irony! JUST last night i was discussing pasta with ketchup in my swedish class. its like, a national dish there! the husband used to be too embarrassed to make it in front of me, but lately, he has no shame. anyhow, in my restaurant exercises last night, lots of the students put this dish in their written dialogues. everyone giggled, as we are all married to, or dating swedes.

    Like

  23. Liz Avatar
    Liz

    Mark posted a follow-up suggesting putting the sauce on quinoa and having a savory breakfast. I can attest that this is also delicious!!

    Like

  24. Laura Avatar

    I make for dinner at least once a week…I love it! I don’t tend to use ketchup too often though. Should give it a try though. I used to eat an obscene amount of the stuff in college. Even as a topping for a Graham cracker once.

    Like

  25. Marti Avatar

    Ha!
    This same article gave me the courage to post a non-authentic standard of my own:
    http://blankpalate.blogspot.com/2009/04/mutt-of-meal.html

    Like

  26. Sara Avatar

    This sounds like a simple, comforting meal, authentic or not.

    Like

  27. Mouse from A Mouse Bouche Avatar

    YUM. I just tasted pasta with ketchup for the first time and also thought if I admitted that no one would ever listen to me rhapsodize about cooking ever again. (It was kind of delicious). I wonder if scrambling a little egg into the broth would add something nice. I used to do that with ramen back in college. SO comforting.

    Like

  28. Cucinista Avatar

    I read this and wanted to try it too, but you more than did it justice. I have really been enjoying reading your posts, looking at your photos, and salivating over your recipes. Thanks for your efforts!

    Like

  29. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    Thank you for sharing this, we’re having it for dinner shortly with some fresh soba noodles. Yum, I’m excited.

    Like

  30. Claudia Haas Avatar

    This sounds wonderful – I am a brothololic (chicken broth, noodles and parmesan).This would be a lovely change!

    Like

  31. Rachel Avatar

    I really love your blog. your profile photo on the left is adorable.

    Like

  32. Melody Elliott Avatar

    We have this type of “soup” most Sundays with a poached egg on top. I add some miso, spinach, spring onions, etc. I buy the noodles in the asian produce section..fresh.
    Yours looks delish!

    Like

  33. Anne Avatar

    Thanks for being so brave and exposing a culinary skeleton in your closet. Though the fact you made your ketchup sandwiches with German bread and not the Wonder variety somewhat redeems your foodie status!
    You are becoming my go-to for easy meals. The roasted shrimp and broccoli is now a family fave and I think this will soon be added to our list.

    Like

  34. Kasey Avatar

    When I first read this read in the New York Times, I was debating whether on not this would taste like anything other than soy sauce. It reminds me of my college days–ramen and more ramen 🙂

    Like

  35. Cam Avatar

    Agreed: this is delicious. I just made it with soba noodles (you’re right; it’s great) and posted at http://www.whattoeatblog.com. I’ll be coming back to this one for sure. Cheap, easy, and really delicious.

    Like

  36. molly Avatar

    i LOVE the simplicity of this dish. it sounds quite delish too. will try it maybe tonight.

    Like

  37. laura Avatar

    I made this a few weeks ago & it was surprisingly delicious: http://www.clovesandcream.com/2009/03/fusion-somen-noodles-with-prawns.html
    I never would have pegged ketchup as the star ingredient.

    Like

  38. Sues Avatar

    This looks like exactly what I would LOVE for dinner right now! And I’m on a super sriacha kick!

    Like

  39. Mixing Bowl Mama Avatar

    I think my family would love this meal…and I love the simplicity of the recipe. Thank you for sharing and I think I’m going to give it a try next week post-holiday eating….

    Like

  40. Janie Avatar
    Janie

    How does a butter sandwich sound? I used to leave the dinner table with two pieces of white bread spread with butter (tub butter I think, not even the real stuff) and slapped together to eat while I played with friends.
    I’ve also seen noodles with BBQ sauce that looks really good.

    Like

  41. Mama JJ Avatar

    Oh my. I am a GOON! I made the sauce and added it to the noodles, thinking it seemed waaaay too thick and strong. I checked later and sure enough, you’re supposed to add water to the sauce—HA! (That’s what I get for speed-reading recipes while simultaneously multi-tasking and pondering ethereal thoughts.)
    My kids didn’t like it (we have leftover sauce concentrate and they WILL be trying it again), but I watered my serving down and added some sauteed spinach with garlic and onion and it was delicious.

    Like

  42. Rebecca Avatar

    oh, thank you–looks like a healthier alternative to those Ramen cravings I admit I occasionally have…the gingerbread looks awesome, too–I love Edna Lewis.

    Like

  43. Lacey Avatar

    Hey, new reader 🙂
    MAN that looks good. and simple. and delicious. And noodle-ey. I’m a pasta fanatic of all sorts, I will totally be making this.
    Awesome blog.

    Like

  44. Mel @ bouchonfor2.com Avatar

    I recall viewing that article and thinking to myself… it sounds like something I made after coming home from a party in high school… in a good way. Comfort food way. Never did use ketchup though 🙂

    Like

  45. Shelley Avatar

    I made this today for lunch. It was really good. I did leave out 1 cup of the water and added a smidge of chicken stock base, but other than that, I was quite pleased. YUMMYLICIOUS!

    Like

  46. Bex Avatar
    Bex

    I just tried this! I don’t have all the ingredients, so instead used ketchup, soy sauce, sesame oil and worcester sauce, and added king prawns, leeks (no scallions in the house) and jalapenos (for a fiery kick) to the noodles.
    Very nice! 🙂

    Like

  47. Sonja Avatar

    I sometimes make a “Japanese inspired quick fix” based on a similar sauce, using soy, mirin, puréed tomatoes, sugar, dark sesame oil and shichimi (Japanese chili mixture). If I feel like it, I add some vegetables and/or seafood and let them simmer in the sauce. Really yummy with soba or udon noodles!

    Like

  48. Luisa Avatar

    I’m loving all these new combinations you guys are coming up with – good job!

    Like

  49. eliz Avatar

    I made (and blogged about) this, too, and I couldn’t resist the urge to throw all sorts of things in and on, like green onions, bean sprouts, leftover chicken and some shrimp. Not authentic, but not bad at all.
    http://tinyurl.com/cj56pz

    Like

  50. Emily Avatar

    I really love your blog and hope that someday I can cook like you, so the fact that you have used ketchup on pasta, something I used to eat as a child (and still do) made me shriek with joy! I also blogged about Bittman’s ketchup/soy sauce recipe and my secret love of ketchup. Keep up the amazing work!
    http://tinyurl.com/d2b8g3

    Like

Leave a reply to Mouse from A Mouse Bouche Cancel reply