Bread_3

I imagine many people's weekends were spent like mine – with a bowl of flour, instant yeast and water fermenting in a warm corner of the kitchen as they went about their business, courtesy of Jim Lahey and that kitchen imp, Mark Bittman.

Yes, you all know how I feel about the Minimalist. I usually downright ignore his column when Wednesdays roll around. But this time, I simply could not. I've spent too many Saturdays lingering around Sullivan Street Bakery, gnawing on a slice of the best pizza bianca to be found in New York or walking back home with a crinkly bag of filone to ignore Jim Lahey's spectacular recipe for bread that is the easiest I've ever tried, with among the best results.

Yes! A fantastic recipe! Something to rave about! Finally. What a relief. If you all aren't running home to buy instant yeast (not that stuff that comes in little packets, that's not instant) and throw together your loaf of supremely gratifying, holey, tasty bread, well, then I can't help you either. Do it! You'll be so happy you did. And then you can laminate this recipe and add it to the hall of fame.

It's so easy – you mix together some instant yeast, flour (I used a mix of bread flour and AP flour, half and half) salt and some water to form a "shaggy" dough. You cover this tightly and let it sit undisturbed for 12 to 18 hours. Then you sort of manhandle the dough around for a bit, let it rise a little longer while you preheat an oven and a cast-iron pot (I used a round one, but next time might try the smaller oval pot), and then dump your wobbly dough into the hot pot and let it bake in the oven (first covered, then uncovered) until you have a golden, hollow-when-thumped, crackling loaf of bread (it crackles! As it cools!).

You have to let it cool before slicing, but when you do, beware. A taste of those slices of bread – plain, spread with honey, whatever – will make the people around you become singularly fixated and before you know it the entire loaf will be gone. Gone! It's okay. You can make another loaf and barely even dirty your hands.

Go! Bake! NOW!

No-Knead Bread
Yields one 1 1/2 pound loaf

3 cups all-purpose or bread flour, more for dusting
¼ teaspoon instant yeast
1¼ teaspoons salt
Cornmeal or wheat bran as needed.

1. In a large bowl combine flour, yeast and salt. Add 1 5/8 cups water, and stir until blended; dough will be shaggy and sticky. Cover bowl with plastic wrap. Let dough rest at least 12 hours, preferably about 18, at warm room temperature, about 70 degrees.

2. Dough is ready when its surface is dotted with bubbles. Lightly flour a work surface and place dough on it; sprinkle it with a little more flour and fold it over on itself once or twice. Cover loosely with plastic wrap and let rest about 15 minutes.

3. Using just enough flour to keep dough from sticking to work surface or to your fingers, gently and quickly shape dough into a ball. Generously coat a cotton towel (not terry cloth) with flour, wheat bran or cornmeal; put dough seam side down on towel and dust with more flour, bran or cornmeal. Cover with another cotton towel and let rise for about 2 hours. When it is ready, dough will be more than double in size and will not readily spring back when poked with a finger.

4. At least a half-hour before dough is ready, heat oven to 450 degrees. Put a 6- to 8-quart heavy covered pot (cast iron, enamel, Pyrex or ceramic) in oven as it heats. When dough is ready, carefully remove pot from oven. Slide your hand under towel and turn dough over into pot, seam side up; it may look like a mess, but that is O.K. Shake pan once or twice if dough is unevenly distributed; it will straighten out as it bakes. Cover with lid and bake 30 minutes, then remove lid and bake another 15 to 30 minutes, until loaf is beautifully browned. Cool on a rack.

Posted in , ,

155 responses to “Jim Lahey’s No-Knead Bread”

  1. Steve and Pam Avatar
    Steve and Pam

    Spectacular. In more than three decades of cooking together, we’ve never attempted bread. What a delight to have found Lehey’s recipe in the Times.
    Will probably go with the 1 1/2 cups water next time, but it was delicious at 1 5/8.
    In fact, it was so good, the family cat ate the recipe!

    Like

  2. anna maria Avatar

    I’ve joined the no-knead bread club, and made my first loaf of it. I used the “wrong” yeast and let it rise for 21 hours, but it worked out fantastic. My post about it is here http://web.mac.com/stone0579/iWeb/piaandco/Blog/647B3203-3548-44C8-8A60-677163919976.html

    Like

  3. becky Avatar
    becky

    a small question: is the water just room temp or regular bread-making warm water? i’m a novice bread maker and the water temp is what sinks me usually (too hot or too cold).

    Like

  4. Mr Parallel Avatar
    Mr Parallel

    I’ve done three batches so far with increasingly decent results. However, my Creuset casserole has become dark and discolored as a result. My wife thinks I’m ruining the finish somehow. Anyone else have this experience. Can you give me something to tell her that will reassure her?

    Like

  5. Gigi Avatar
    Gigi

    So far, I have made a parmesan/pepper version (loaf was a little dense, needs some tweaking), a sesame seed version (with seeds kneaded into the dough) and a cinnamon-raisin version (added 1/4 cup each of brown and granulated sugars, 2 tablespoons of cinnamon and 2 big handfuls of raisins). The cinnamon-raisin is fantastic and the sesame is as good as anything I can buy at a local bread bakery.
    As Mr. Parallel mentioned, my Le Creuset is also becoming slightly discolored from baking. I assumed it might be from the cornmeal I used for the 2 hour rising that was burning a bit. I’m not too concerned – that pot has never seen so much action in all the years I’ve owned it so I’m finally getting my money’s worth out of it!
    In total, I’ve made about 8 loaves and I don’t imagine I’ll be buying bread from a bakery anytime soon. I plan to try a garlic/rosemary version and an olive version in the next few weeks.

    Like

  6. Ju Avatar
    Ju

    Sorry to burst anyone’s bubble but the Chinese have been using this method for centuries! In fact, you can steam the dough over rapidly boiling water for 10 minutes and then put the whole thing in a preheated oven just to brown it. It can be glazed with egg or melted butter for better flavour and appearance. The Chinese has learnt this art long ago and they call this dough “pau”. If you are interested, check out any site on Chinese cooking and you will find many variations of this method. Sometimes,they call the initial dough the “sponge” and sometimes “porridge” depending on what method is being used. The really soft breads can take as long as 3 days to prepare (nothing much really, just letting the dough rest and proof itself. The really good bakers keep a portion of the sponge for later batches of dough. The smell is awful but the results are spectacular.

    Like

  7. mrparallel Avatar
    mrparallel

    Like Gigi, I was using cornmeal in my Creuset and it was burning slightly, so maybe that was the culprit. But since then I’ve switched to using my clay baker, which works even better and results in a higher, better shaped loaf too.

    Like

  8. jeannie Avatar
    jeannie

    My husband just got me a Le Creuset dutch oven as a gift after he saw me reading (and reading and reading) about this recipe. Will I ruin the pretty Le Creuset pot if I use it? We’ve used it stovetop with great results but I would hate to wreck his thoughtful present! This could turn out to be a “Gift of the Magi”-like incident!
    Advice? Tips?
    Thanks!

    Like

  9. christine Avatar
    christine

    I didn’t want to buy a costly le creuset, so I found a large vintage pyrex mixing bowl ($5 thrift store) and used it with a pie plate glass cover. My bread is perfect; proof that it’s the recipe and not the pot that makes this bread great. I’ve been searching for variations…thanks Gigi for the cinnamon raisin one, I’ll try my hand at it next.

    Like

  10. David Avatar
    David

    Will a 5 quart cast iron dutch oven work or do I need to purchase a 6 quart?
    thanks

    Like

  11. Eve Avatar
    Eve

    Still making the bread, and I’m getting a higher loaf using a glass pyrex covered casserole. I think it’s 2 or 3 quarts at most, much smaller than my enamel 5 quart, so I would recommend smaller is better. And save yourself some $ – you don’t have to blow the wad on the pot (tho’ the crust is crispier from my le creuset imitation than the pyrex).
    Will try Gigi’s cinnamon raisin version tonight.

    Like

  12. Eve Avatar
    Eve

    Still making the bread, and I’m getting a higher loaf using a glass pyrex covered casserole. I think it’s 2 or 3 quarts at most, much smaller than my enamel 5 quart, so I would recommend smaller is better. And save yourself some $ – you don’t have to blow the wad on the pot (tho’ the crust is crispier from my le creuset imitation than the pyrex).
    Will try Gigi’s cinnamon raisin version tonight.

    Like

  13. Geralyn Abinader Avatar
    Geralyn Abinader

    We’ve been making this bread according to the directions, letting the dough rise for about 18 hours. Our crust is perfect, but the inside seems almost wet, too moist. Any suggestions?
    Thanks, Geralyn

    Like

  14. Michael Avatar
    Michael

    I have made about 6 loaves now, trying lots of containers with success: a 6qt stainless allclad, a 7qt stainless stockpot, a 5qt cast iron enamel dutch oven, and best of all a $9.95 enameled 8qt oval covered roasting pan. There is enough room in the roaster to do two loaves, or a bunch of rolls.
    I also found that pouring the dough out onto parchment (for the second rising and shaping) makes the cleanup nonexistent, and gently lowering the dough into the pot on the parchment sling takes much of the anxiety out of that process. The pot is also left pristine after the baking.
    As far as the recipe is concerned I have tried various combinations of bread, all purpose, and whole wheat flour.
    The bread flour seems to add a chewy moist quality like a great pizza crust, and all purpose makes a lighter, dryer crumb, and the whole wheat makes for moist crumb and more flavor. My favorite combo so far is 1.5cup all purpose, 1cup bread flour, and 1/2 cup whole wheat. Rise 12 hours, then 2 and oven at 450°f.
    If you don’t have one, get an oven thermometer. I found my oven was 75°f too hot at 450°! No wonder my first loaves were blackened on the bottom at 525°f.

    Like

  15. Alice Avatar
    Alice

    I have made this bread about 6 different times. The last time I used all-purpose flour and allowed the dough to rise for 12 hours, and then added rosemary and thyme into the dough by lightly mixing with a wooden spoon. I then allowed it to rise another 10 hours. Then shaped it and let it rise another 2 hours. This was the longest time I have allowed the dough to rise and I feel like it was alot easier to handle. I was at my boyfriend’s house and he doesn’t have a heavy pot, so I baked the bread in a deep cast-iron frying pan, with another cast iron frying pan on top. I brushed olive oil onto the top and bottom of the dough before baking it, and then after taking the top off brushed more olive oil on the top and put herbs and coarse sea salt on the top. I cannot even believe how good it came out. Definitely the best results so far… I would definitely advocate allowing a longer rising time.

    Like

  16. eric rochow Avatar

    I made this bread for my online video show: http://www.gardenfork.tv (cooking, gardening, and other stuff) and its quite amazing. thanks to all for posting variations. come watch the show.
    eric http://www.gardenfork.tv

    Like

  17. beth beckett Avatar
    beth beckett

    I have made the no-knead bread several times and love it! I use my covered c lay roasting pan, which works beautifully!
    I found another great Jim Lahey bread recipe worth trying if you have a stand mixer with a dough hook. It is
    http://www.foodandwine.com/recipes/jim-laheys-pane-casareccio. It gives directions for either pane casareccio or Focaccia from the same recipe. I make the Focaccia b/c it only takes minutes to mix & only 2-3 hrs to rise. I cut the recipe in half b/c it makes a lot, and I bake it on my pizza stone. It is heavenly dipped in garlic/herb olive oil. Try it!!!

    Like

  18. Deb Donovan Avatar
    Deb Donovan

    I love this recipe, but would like to try it with rolls. Does anyone have some tips on how to do this—size, what surface for the 2nd rise, what pan to use? Thanks.

    Like

  19. osc Avatar

    I use 1 1/2 cups water instead of 1 5/8, use dry bread machine yeast (mixed dry with the flour), 1 1/4 teaspoons of salt, and a couple of rounded teaspoons of sugar. I rise for 18 hours plus the two hours at the end. I dispense with the whole towel nonsense and just let it rise the last two hours on a bed of flour. Then I gently pick it up and put it in a heated cast iron dutch oven (with a lid), and it has been perfect every time. One batch I put in black pepper and rosemary and lemon peel (at the beginning), and that was delicious. Next batch will be using 1/3 rye flour and a bit of caraway seed, and the batch after that will have shredded parmesan and sliced calamata olives. This recipe is very resilient and reliable.

    Like

  20. Anna Avatar
    Anna

    I finally made this bread, twice in three days, and it’s fantastic! I made one regular loaf, using 2 tsp salt and cutting the second rise to 30 minutes. Then I was inspired by Gigi’s comment above and made a cinnamon raisin loaf with 1/4 cup brown sugar, 2 tsp cinnamon, and 2 handfuls of raisins (I like it not too sweet). I used a pretty long first rise for both loaves, 20-24 hours. I baked them in a 2-quart enameled cast-iron saucepan so the loaves were high and nicely sandwich-sized.

    Like

  21. karen Avatar
    karen

    Greetings,
    This makes the best PIZZA dough ever!!! This is the kind of dough used to make pizza in Naples. It is thin and chewey and can be folded over without breaking.
    I use 1-1/2 cups of water, any old active dry yeast (all yeast is the same), and 2 Tbs salt.
    I use warm water, and I start with 1-1/2 cups of flour and mix until it is very well incorporated, even like a cake batter, all airy. Then slowly add the remaining flour, mixing thourghly after each addition. The final dough is not as sticky as the original recipe, but comes out just as good.
    Then let rise till the top looks like a pancake that is ready to be turned over, lots of small bubbles poking the top. 24 hours has worked for me.
    I place the dough on a piece of floured parchment paper, and fold it over once or twice adding flour to the top. After its 15 min rest, I cut a couple small pieces of dough off, fold it over to make a ball and pinch the edges closed, and let rest on floured parchment , covered, for 2 hours. (I bake a small loaf, and two individual pizzas from this one recipe)
    I bake the bread and the pizza on a pizza stone, though you could also use a cast-iron griddle, or the upturned bottom of your Le Crusette pots etc.
    And instead of covering the bread while baking, I put a pan of boiling water in the oven the first 20 min. of baking (for the bread) That makes the crust hard, then let the loaf cool in the oven on a rack, with the door propped open-this I think also helps make the crust crispy.
    For the pizza, punch the round down and into a larger round with your finger tips, then, still ontop of your floured parchment, stretch it out with your hands while turning the dough. It is too delicate of a dough to try and toss in the air! (Just like they make it in Naples.) If you do not have a pizza peel, you can use a sheet pan that has no upturned sides to it. (At a resturant supply store you can get a pizza peel for under 10 dollars.) Put the dough on a lightly floured peel, or pan, and top it with small amount of sauce….etc.
    Bake at 500* for about 9-10 min. on a pre-heated pizza stone-or griddle. (at a hardware store you can buy an untreated paving stone-any porus stone or ceramic or brick–and voila-a pizza stone-make sure it fits inside your oven)
    You will never order pizza out again!! Also, instead of letting the dough rise two hours, you can put the dough rounds in the refridgerator for later use, cover carefully with plastic, and some flour, so it does not stick. It will keep a couple of days. Enjoy!

    Like

  22. karen Avatar
    karen

    Correction, for pizza; use 2 tsp. salt, not 2 Tbs.
    And if you refrigerate the dough, be sure to bring it back to room temp. before trying to work with it.

    Like

  23. Jared Avatar
    Jared

    Looking forward to trying this one. It is very similar, in a way, to my current favorite recipie, which I would like to put head to head with this one. It is in “The Bread Baker’s Apprentice: Mastering the Art of Extraordinary Bread”. This one is also very easy. Instead of warm mixing by hand you cold mix it in a mixer and put it in the fridge the night before. The dough is similarly very wet and hard to handle. You can make baguettes, boules, pizza or foccacia. The flavor is amazing.
    Recipe: Pain a l’Ancienne
    Categories
    Bread
    Ingredients
    27 oz unbleached bread flour (6 cups)
    2 1/4 tsp salt
    1 3/4 tsp instant yeast
    3 cups water, ice cold
    Instructions
    1) Combine the flour, salt, yeast and 19 ounces of water in the bowl of an electric mixer with the paddle attachment, and mix on low speed for 2 minutes.
    2) Switch to the dough hook and mix for an additional 5 to 6 minutes on medium speed.
    3) The dough should be sticky on the bottom of the bowl but it should release from the sides of the bowl. If not, sprinkle in a small amount of flour until this occurs (or dribble in water if the dough seems too stiff and clears the bottom and sides of the bowl).
    4) Lightly oil a large bowl and immediately transfer the dough into the bowl with a spatula or bowl scraper dipped in water.
    5) Mist the top of the dough with spray oil and cover the bowl with plastic wrap.
    6) Immediately place the bowl in the refrigerator and retard overnight.
    7) The next day, take the bowl out of the refrigerator and leave it out for 2 to 3 hours to return to room temperature.
    8) When the dough has doubled from its original prerefrigerated size, liberally sprinkle the counter with bread flour (about 1/2 cup).
    9) Gently transfer the dough to the floured counter with a plastic dough scraper that has been dipped in cold water, dipping your hands as well to keep the dough from sticking to you. Try to degas the dough as little as possible as you transfer it.
    10) If the dough is very wet, sprinkle more flour over the top as well as under it.
    11) Dry your hands thouroughly and them dip them in flour.
    12) Roll the dough gently in the sprinkled flour to coat it thoroughly, simultaneously stretching it into an oblong about 8 inches long and 6 inches wide.
    13) If it is too sticky to handle, continue sprinkling flour over it.
    14) Dip a metal pastry scraper into cool water to keep it from sticking to the dough, and cut the dough in half width-wise with the pastry scraper by pressing it down through the dough until it severs it, then dipping it again in the water and repeating this action until you have cut down the full length of the dough.
    15) Let the dough relax for 5 minutes.
    16) Prepare the oven for hearth baking: Put an empty baking pan on a rack at the lowest level, and set your baking stone (if you have one) on a rack immediately above the pan.
    17) Heat the oven to 500 degrees (550 if your oven goes this high).
    18) Cover the back of two 17 by 12-inch sheet pans with baking parchment and dust with semolina flour or cornmeal.
    19) Take one of the dough pieces, and repeat the cutting action, this time cutting the dough into thirds, lengthwise, creating three strips of dough.
    20) Flour your hands and carefully lift one of the dough strips and transfer it to a parchment-lined pan, gently pulling it to the length of the pan (or to the length of your baking stone). If it springs back, let it rest for 5 minutes, and then gently pull it out again.
    21) Repeat for the other two strips of dough, and then for the other half of the original dough ball.
    22) Take one pan to the preheated oven and carefully slide the dough, parchment and all, onto the baking stone (or bake directly on the sheet pan).
    23) Pour 1 cup hot water into the steam pan, and close the door.
    24) After 30 seconds, spray the oven walls with water (a squirt bottle is best for this) and close the door.
    25) Repeate twice more at 30-second intervals.
    26) After the final spray, reduce the oven setting to 475 degrees and continue baking.
    27) Meanwhile, dust the other pan of strips with flour, mist with spray oil, and cover with a towel or plastic wrap.
    28) The bread should begin to turn golden brown within 8 or 9 minutes.
    29) If the loaves are baking unevenly at this point, rotate them 180 degrees.
    30) Continue baking 10 to 15 minutes more, or until the bread is a rich golden brown and the internal temperature registers at least 205 degrees.
    31) Transfer the hot breads to a cooling rack. They should feel very light, almost airy, and will cool in about 20 minutes.
    32) While these are cooling, you can bake the remaining loaves, remembering to remove the old parchment from the oven and turn the oven up to 500 degrees (or higher) before baking the second round.
    Yield
    6 baguettes
    Source
    The Bread Baker’s Apprentice – Peter Reinhart

    Like

  24. treeverte Avatar
    treeverte

    How to fix Le Creuset melted knob syndrome without having to order one for $7.95…Go to your hardware store and buy a nut and bolt and washer (the round thingy with a hole,looks like flat doughnut) and replace plastic knob with this! Insert bolt thru washer thru holeon top of lid-flip lid and add washer around bolt,screw on nut…voila cheap perfection!
    I made my bread perfectly by using the
    time to preheat my oven to 500, instead of the two hours suggested.
    Used the recipe but added two tablespoons of wheatgerm and ground flaxseeed,two teaspoons salt,two teaspoons sugar…added one teaspoon olive oil!
    Treeverte

    Like

  25. Gary Denton Avatar

    I am not really sure this is a new method, just seems to be a rediscovered old method.

    Like

  26. Sijbrich Avatar

    Hey, I think I saw the guy that authored this recipe was on the Martha Stewart Show a few months ago, making this bread. I’m definitely going to try it. Thanks for sharing.

    Like

  27. Davey Avatar
    Davey

    I see the NYT has now put the article in the pay-for archives, so the video is no longer available (apparently even if you do pay for access to the article). Wish I’d downloaded the video.
    I now make this bread regularly except I now use 3.5 cups whole wheat (King Arthur red winter) and 1/2 cup of white. About 2 cups water and 1/2tsp of regular ol’ dry yeast, 1.5 tsp salt. When ready to bake I sprinkle the top with sunflower seeds and rolled oats.
    I’ve never had any luck making wholegrain breads with the Kitchenaide, or later, a bread machine. Store bought was always better. With this method I’m making the best bread I’ve ever encountered — light, aromatic, beautiful crust. No bakery even comes close. And the recipe is so forgiving: I just add enough water to make a kind of sloppy dough. Exactness doesn’t seem to matter much. And I use ordinary dry yeast.
    I bake it in the ceramic liner of an old crockpot, topped with a solid aluminum dutch oven cover. In all my years of cooking, this is probably my most amazing experience.

    Like

  28. betty wolsky Avatar
    betty wolsky

    I would like to try this with sour dough. Anyone have experience with this?

    Like

  29. Tyler Avatar
    Tyler

    I went bonkers when I first saw the video on the NYT site. I wanted so badly to try it, but I didn’t have the right kind of pot. So I used my Calphalon annodized aluminum dutch oven. It was a disaster! The bread burned and stuck to the bottom!
    So I collected myself and went out and got a Lodge cast iron dutch oven. I tried again and it was perfect!! Success! The only things I did differently were the following: I used active dry yeast because I don’t know where to find instant. It worked fine, but if anyone knows where I can get a hold of some “instant yeast”, please send me an email. The other difference was that for the final rest, I allowed it to sit in a large bowl rather than on a towel. I found with my first attempt that the dough stuck to the towel, despite the thick layer of flour between them.

    Like

  30. Annie B Avatar
    Annie B

    I’ve been baking this bread since the article first came out, with astounding success. The cast iron dutch oven is the real key to it, I believe. Over the weekend, I added 2 tablespoons of artisan olive oil to the original recipe, let it rise according to the instructions, then divided it into 3 pizza crusts. Unbelievably divine! You must try it for an incredible pizza experience. I also used Montana flour, which has more protein in it. Try to find a flour made from winter wheat, if possible.

    Like

  31. Annie B Avatar
    Annie B

    One more thing: I have only used active dry yeast and not instant yeast.

    Like

  32. Davey Avatar
    Davey

    Annie B, I tried it for pizza (deep dish in a cast iron skillet) with OK but not special results. Didn’t try to preheat the pan. What kind of pan did you use, and did you preheat it? Did you use some kind of cover like for the bread? Did you prebake the crust before adding the toppings? Thin or deepdish style?
    Do tell us more about your methods and results — sounds like something I’d like to try again.

    Like

  33. Mariah Avatar
    Mariah

    This no knead ran in our newspaper and I have baked it three days in a row. Each came out good. I baked it in a round baking dish with a cover from the 2nd hand store for 50 cents. It came out of the oven was 200 ° looking fab and tasting wonderful but a bit wet and rubbery, that is a little bit beyond chewy. Lots of holes too.The second one I took the cover off at 20 minutes baked it another 30 and it came out great at 205 °. The 3rd , a bit of sour dough a long rise, forming & resting a few hours & 20 minutes with the cover and about 35 without. It stayed in till 207 °. I am shooing for 210 ° but it was getting too dark. It is only about 3 minutes from 205 to 207.The bread came out Perfect. the crust was brown but not burnt. Inside open, holey, and much dryer than the first time the flavor excellent. Drier but not dry.
    I love all the ideas and will try others. It seeems the secret is a hot oven, hot pan & lid is a must and and a very wet dough. This probably will work with no more than one third of other flours or grains. Rye should like the long slow rise especially if your house is cooler than 70 °. Mine is.
    I too use a bench knife or scraper & place it on wax paper for the second rise. Pick up and dump. Little clean up which makes the bread making go faster, good when you are tired.
    Instant or rapid rise, or bread machine yeast is pretty much the same. It goes in with the flour. Tepid water is fine. I use only SAF red label. One of our stores in Portland sells bulk and they have the 1 lb vacumn packed bags for $2.36 cents. I went to the wholesale grocers like cache & carry or smart & final. They are a penny cheaper. They now sell to anyone off the street but if you use a check it must be a business one. Yes to credit cards.
    All yeast is not the same. The instant is smaller and grown in a different medium & usually has ascorbic acid in it. It reacts instantly.
    I bought a top to a long baker cloche at the 2nd hand store for $1.00 and i will bake my semolina loaves on the stone under it. I know it will work fine. I’m tired good night.

    Like

  34. treeverte Avatar
    treeverte

    aha…buttermilk oatmeal no knead bread.
    3 cups all purpose flour
    1 cup regular oatmeal
    1 tablespoon ground flaxseed
    1 1/2 tsp salt
    regular ol yeast 1 1/2 tsp
    Liquids-
    2 cups warm water with the addition
    1 tablespoon olive oil
    1 tablespoon honey
    4 tablespoons Sacco Buttermilk powder
    18 hours
    1-2 hour rise after
    Make quite a wet dough
    450 degree oven 35 minutes,25 minutes brown.
    Hated the quick rise dough..too fast!
    I mix the dough up in an ol crockpot container and let it rise slowly in the fridge.
    I have made a zillion loaves now and this is heavenly perfection…tasty, healthy and the bread has character.

    Like

  35. Linda D Avatar
    Linda D

    The NYT video is now on You Tube. I didn’t pick up that there was a second rise of 2 hours. Seems that after the 18-24 hr. rise, the dough was thrown directly into the oven on the video. Yes, no? Anyone just throw it in without that second rise? How did it turn out?

    Like

  36. Pauline Avatar
    Pauline

    hi made my first loaf but it hardly rose during the 2 hours before baking … taste Ok but somethings not quite right …

    Like

  37. Gerry ( Bloke) Avatar
    Gerry ( Bloke)

    I read the NYT NKB recipe in the Sydney Morning Herald and I have made bread ever since – I make two loaves at the same time –
    2 cups of wholemeal & 4 cups of plain flour – 3 teaspoons of salt 1/2 teaspoon of dried yeast & 4 cups of warm water and a tablespoon of olive oil – stir – I let it stand for 18 hours to rise and then put it on a bench – put in 3/4 cup 1 cup of flour – a 2 minute knead and then 30 minutes in the oven – 15 minutes to broan – gives a woonderful crumb and spot on everytime –
    Gerry ( auzziewog@hotmail.com )

    Like

  38. Gerry ( Bloke) Avatar
    Gerry ( Bloke)

    Oh I forgot – there is a 2 hours second rising be4 it goes into a hot oven (450 F or 25 C )

    Like

  39. pat Avatar
    pat

    What is salilio bread and does anyone have a recipe? I buy it on market but have not found a recipe to make it.

    Like

  40. Monique Avatar
    Monique

    Since I picked up some good tips and variations here for the no-knead bread recipe, I thought I would share my suggestions for a quick clean up. I turn out the dough on a Silpat silicone baking mat which I sprinkle minimally with flour and bran and leave it there for the second rise. The dough slides off easily into the pot and after a quick rinse with water, the Silpat is clean. Also, I cover the dough for the first rise with Glad Press ‘n Seal (go out immediately and buy a roll if you don’t own some already) and then I wrap the same piece of Press ‘n Seal around my hand (other wraps don’t grip as well) and use it to scrape out the dough – no dough scraper to clean. The recipe is a thing of beauty in its simplicity and now the clean up is too.
    Monique

    Like

  41. Grandma Avatar
    Grandma

    Nancy–measure the base of your cast iron pot. If it is 8 to 10 inches in diameter, it should be fine.
    Dawn–Sure, you can leave the dough longer, just don’t let it dry out. Cover it with a plastic bag that you’ve cut open to make a sheet.
    Love,
    Grandma

    Like

  42. Sue Avatar
    Sue

    The chicken and egg question – who comes first- Dunaway or Lahey? I have her book- it’s worth the price.
    We love the bread. I was using a pyrex roaster, but found a great enameled over cast iron pan atTarget.
    Ridiculously nice price-under$40.00

    Like

  43. Eva Sartori Avatar
    Eva Sartori

    Has anyone tried making a sourdough version? How much sourdough did you use?

    Like

  44. J.B. Bulharowski Avatar
    J.B. Bulharowski

    This recipe has been sitting around in my recipe database for a long time. Finally, I tried it and WOW the results were superb. My husband said this was my best effort ever. I have made my own starter (al la Nancy Silverton) and I have S. Dunnaway’s No Knead to Knead Cookbook, so I’ve been around the block with bread baking. Bottom line, why bother with complicated starters, recipes, etc when this product “Satisfies.” Nice blog Ms. Weiss, there were some good suggestions I will implement, like the use of Silpat to rest the dough for the last 2-hour ferment. Thanks for the fun!

    Like

  45. Lois Avatar
    Lois

    I’ve seen nothing on the various websites for no knead bread about using some of the batter for the next batch, like a sourdough starter.
    It works exactly the same as making no-knead bread the first time but tastes even better and you’ll never need to use commercial yeast (except for the first batch.)
    Just take out 1/2 cup out of the fermented batch (after the 18 hours before adding more flour), and keep it in the refrigerator. Every 5-7 days, take it out and add a cup of flour and enough water to make it wet again, about half a cup, mix it in and let it ferment for a couple of hours. Put it back in the fridge for the next bread baking. If you wind up with too much, discard some of it before putting it back into the fridge for the next batch.
    Use 1/2-1 cup of the “starter” to replace the same amount of flour in the no-knead recipe and let it ferment for 18 hours as in the regular recipe.
    IMO, using a starter makes the flavor and texture even better. It tastes like no-knead bread should taste and it doesn’t taste like sourdough.

    Like

  46. Maria G. From Potomac Avatar
    Maria G. From Potomac

    Great bread, by far the best I have ever made. Anyone has ever tried make the same recipe with wheat?

    Like

  47. Barbara Avatar
    Barbara

    I used King Arthur all purpose flour and Red Star Quick Rise yeast that comes in a packet, thinking that I bought the right kind of yeast. Fantastic results! The loaf was so pretty I took a picture of it! The aroma, the taste, the crisp texture of the crust and the moist inside bread were superb! Thank you Jim and Mark!

    Like

  48. Cony Avatar
    Cony

    I live in France, I am Mexican and I learned to bake bread in the US. The recipe I used for years was the Amish friendship bread, somebody gave me the mixture and I had to learn how to use it, since then I am a regular baker. Even here, I have to bake my bread because I live far from good bakeries.
    It was very interesting for me to find this recipe, the ingredients and quantities are the same I have been using here for the last 4 years.
    To get the crust, I was using a big stone in the oven and brushing the loafs with a diluted, cooked maizena solution, adding steam at the beginning of the baking, etc. The results were o.k. but never like in the bakeries.
    I use bread flour, a mixture of unbleached and whole wheat flours. It is used here to make a bread named “Pain de Campagne” (country side bread). Some times I add a seed mixture or other flours.
    I use regular French lyophilized yeast and a little bit more salt than in the recipe.
    What I still do different:
    To rise, I leave the dough growing in the fridge in a closed plastic container for 1 to 2 days or even more, the lid sometimes gets open due to the carbon dioxide produced by the yeast, but I just have to close it back. Since we eat a lot of bread, I always have some dough in the fridge, ready for the second rise. Sometimes I take part of it to make pizza. I mix leftovers of the old dough with the new one. I found that the flavor improves with time. In France, the short rise baguette is never as tasty as the overnight raised one.
    The second rise is out of the fridge and I leave the loafs to grow between 2-6 hours, depending of my schedule.
    I used to knead for a few minutes, but I stopped since I found this recipe.
    So far I found that what makes the whole difference is the use of the dutch oven, even my French husband thought the bread was from the bakery!

    Like

  49. Elizabeth Nathan Avatar
    Elizabeth Nathan

    Any thoughts on whether this recipe can be adapted to a smaller dutch oven. I’ve got a 5qt Staub but not a 6 or 8 qt.

    Like

  50. geordie Avatar
    geordie

    Went by all the instructions, let it rise for 24 hrs, up to now its just a soggy runny mess impossible to fold really, however ill slog on as I have it rising for the last 2 hrs, Lord knows what it will turn out like…..I’ll let you know

    Like

Leave a reply to karen Cancel reply