Soup_13

A week in Berlin with my mother ensured that I got my requisite amount of fresh vegetables after being stuck, for the previous week, in a smoke-filled, sunless convention center where Wuerstchen and chocolate bars were the standard fare. But after returning from Berlin this past weekend, I've found that I'm still craving vegetables, especially ones that are transformed into silky, warm versions of themselves. Ah, fall. I'm so glad to see you.

While I was gone, quite a few appealing recipes were published – Garlic sausages with braised lentils! Monkfish-mussel-chorizo stew! Salted caramel mousses! – but for some reason I found myself gravitating towards this simple soup that Celia Barbour touted as her go-to winter fare. I left out the dill because I am not a fan of that feathery, frondy business: it always reminds of a traumatizing moment at the dinner table when I was a child and my father was going through an obsessive Hungarian phase, learning the language and the cuisine, and he made a veal stew that was flecked through and through with those fussy bits of dill and although, when I took a piece in my mouth, my throat just closed up and would not let that veal piece pass, my father insisted that I eat at least four pieces (like he made me do with Brussels sprouts, which I have to come to love, but the same just will not happen with dill, don't even try to convince me of it) and so I had to obey, with tears in my eyes, and yuck, by God, now that I am the master of my own domain, I will not eat the stuff, no way, no how, no sir.

But otherwise, I hacked and chopped and diced away at my pile of fall vegetables (though I have by no means mastered Knife Skills 101 and could care less, really, about the cubed uniformity of root vegetables in soups) and then cooked them into a shockingly bright mixture that miraculously didn't ruin a single article of clothing (I actually debated cooking with no top on, but decided against it… I do have roommates, after all). I put only half of the orange peel and orange juice in the soup, which was the right thing, for my palate at least – the soup is sweet enough with all those beets and tomatoes and butter. In fact, I think lemon juice might have been a better brightener.

Ben and I ate this for dinner (mine topped with plain yogurt, his unadorned) with toasted brown bread and found it a pleasing meal. It's wholesome and nourishing and that color certainly goes a long way towards the whole eating-with-your-eyes business. It won't go in my hall of fame of soups because it lacked something (beans? potatoes? parsley? I don't know) that would immortalize it. And that name, to be honest, sort of gets my goat. But it hit the spot last night, and that is, sometimes, enough.

Beautiful Soup
Yields 6 servings

6 tablespoons butter or 3 tablespoons butter and 3 tablespoons olive oil
3 medium onions, chopped into ½-inch pieces
4 cloves garlic, minced
2 small beets, peeled and cut into ½-inch dice
4 to 5 medium carrots, cut into ½- inch dice
4 stalks celery, cut into ½-inch pieces
½ medium celery root, peeled and cut into ½-inch dice
¾ cup chopped dill
2 quarts beef or chicken stock
1 28-ounce can diced tomatoes with their juice
Finely grated zest and juice of 1 orange
Salt and freshly ground black pepper
Sour cream, for garnish
Dark whole wheat sour bread or other hearty bread, for serving

1. Place flameproof casserole or other deep, wide pan over low heat and add butter or butter-oil mixture. When butter has melted, add onion and garlic; sauté until soft but not browned.

2. Increase heat to medium-high and add beets, carrots, celery, celery root and half the dill. Sauté, adjusting heat as needed, until vegetables have released their liquid, dried and start to turn golden but not brown, about 20 minutes.

3. Add stock and tomatoes with their juice, and bring to a boil. Reduce heat and cook until vegetables are soft, about 45 minutes. Add orange zest and juice, and remaining dill. Season with salt and pepper to taste. To serve, ladle into bowls and top each with a dollop of sour cream. Serve with hunks of bread.

Posted in ,

10 responses to “Celia Barbour’s Beautiful Soup”

  1. ann Avatar

    how awful!
    i’m the exact opposite from you luisa, dill is possibly my favorite herb after sage… i adore the springy taste it brings into the kitchen in the dead of winter, but trauma’s trauma man!
    this reminds me of an article published awhile ago about what chefs will NOT allow in their kitchens. dill was one for one guy, and i cheered when another said bell peppers, how i loaaathe them!
    this soup gets tagged for a cold winter’s night, to be sure.
    welcome back!!

    Like

  2. deb Avatar

    I was going to make this too! Perhaps I’ll try those garlic sausages instead. I found last week’s Times far more inspiring than this one. I’ve also been eyeing that savory pumpkin tart but fear it might be… dull?
    I’m with Ann on the dill – love it, but I get some odd kick out of remembering what odd ingredients certain big-name food types can’t stand. Reichl (honey!), Danny Meyer (hazelnuts!) and for Emeril it’s dill. Just don’t start “bam!”-ing on us, Luisa. 😉

    Like

  3. Lia Avatar

    I’m going to have to try this, though I know what you mean about certain soups lacking that certain something. My husband and I had the same problem with this Butternut Squash Soup we made on Sunday from Food & Wine: http://www.foodandwine.com/recipes/butternut-squash-soup
    Even with beans and two slices of smoky bacon, it was still missing something. I think it needed some dill (just kidding).
    It still hit the spot, but I’m not sure I’ll be making it again either.

    Like

  4. yulinka Avatar

    This sounds a lot like borsch, minus the cabbage and potatoes. Maybe that’s what it’s missing. Otherwise, yum.

    Like

  5. lindy Avatar

    I’m with Yulinka on what’s missing. Potatoes and cabbage, all the way.
    Funny about dill-I love it myself, but have long noticed that almost as many people loathe it as loathe cilantro. You are definitely not alone on this.
    This won’t work for you, since it is largely the texture you dislike, but I did learn something, fairly recently, about dill and soup. I’ve always put dill in my chicken broth, following the example of my Jewish grandmother, who also advocated a parsnip, for sweetness. I read somewhere, though (maybe Joan Nathan?) that if you add dill at the beginning to the pot, it can be a bit bitter. Turns out-I’ve tried it-it is much nicer to add dill snippits right before serving the soup.

    Like

  6. Luisa Avatar

    Ann – Isn’t it funny how different people’s palates are? Sometimes I feel silly about my strong dislikes (cilantro and dill), but then I figure I am pretty open to everything else, which brings me farther than a lot of eaters 😉
    Deb – um, never fear. The day I emulate Emeril is the day that pigs fly. I agree with you on the NYT this week, but that Melissa Clark article does have me salivating. I’ll make the citrouillat for sure…
    Lia – that’s disappointing, but I suppose that not every recipe can be great – that’s why finding really tasty ones makes you feel so triumphant, no? I clicked on the link: personally, I find pureed butternut squash soups better than chunky soups with butternut squash in them. Have you tried any pureed ones lately?
    Yulinka – quite possibly! Barbour did mention in the article that this was no borscht, but I’m thinking maybe it should have been…
    Lindy – my father, apparently, concurs with this last-minute dill snippage business. He also still thinks that veal stew was great. The horror! I have often found comrades in cilantro-hating, but so few in dill-hating… It’s a lonely world out there 😉

    Like

  7. Anne Avatar

    I didn’t realize the name was actually “Beautiful Soup.” I thought you were editorializing! I have to agree, the name is a smidge annoying.
    You think you’re alone in hating dill…guess what I’m not a huge fan of? Sage. There. I said it.

    Like

  8. Lia Avatar

    The soup was interesting because you actually do puree part of it (the butternut squash, leeks and onions) before adding in the kale, carrots and pepper. From now I think I will stick to simpler butternut squash recipes where it’s the main ingredient. This one had a bit too much going on and still wasn’t full of much flavor.
    And I do have a cast iron pan (I bought it specifically for tarte tatin) but I have to admit I haven’t tried using it for much else. The whole cleaning part kind of confuses me. What else do you recommend using it with?

    Like

  9. Luisa Avatar

    Anne – I would NEVER have come up with that name. Please! 🙂 As for sage, I could see why someone could find it overpowering. How about in small doses and browned butter sauces? I won’t try to convert you, though, I promise.
    Lia – I’ve used my cast-iron skillet for many things: toasted panini, eggs, bacon, cornbread, steaks, and pork chops, to name a few. It’s weird at first to wash it without soap, but you get used to it, especially as you get more practice in just cleaning it with hot water and a clean sponge and then wiping it clean.

    Like

  10. Tiny Banquet Committee Avatar

    Very interesting to see everyone’s comments – I am not a dill fan either. I appreciate the flavor but something about those little feathery bits always feels gritty to me, and I hate the way they seem to get stuck to my hands and everything else while chopping.
    I made that monkfish-mussel-chorizo stew from the LA Times; a pic of it is at http://www.flickr.com/photos/tinybanquet/274542828/
    If you try it I recommend leaving the monkfish in whole fillets. I am not used to cooking such small pieces of fish and I overcooked it; I think it’s much easier to cook a standard portion. I also think it might be more attractive to have a whole piece of it in each bowl surrounded by the other ingredients.

    Like

Leave a reply to ann Cancel reply