How to Make Crostata

Hello from the rolling Montefeltro hills! The verdict so far is that things are blissfully as they always are here: lazy, sunny, delicious, mosquito-filled.

We have not done much since getting here. Which is sort of the whole point, of course. There have been a few dinners with friends, an excursion to the beach or two, and there has been beer with lunch and dinner almost every day so far (we are nothing if not livin'-on-the-edgers).

Also, there has been a lot of crostata. Crostata is the very first thing I ever learned to bake. For a long while, it was the only thing I ever baked. It is, to explain, a jam-filled tart of sorts, except the dough is sort of cakey as well as crusty. It is eaten for breakfast and for dessert. It can be filled with any jam you like, though we are partial to sour ones like plum or sour cherry. A grade-schooler can master it and it requires nothing besides a countertop and a baking pan. I make one every couple of days since that's about how long they last.

In the grand tradition of Italian desserts, crostata is a little dry and almost aggressively simple. I would urge you to resist attempts to fancy it up.

I suppose it will be the first thing I teach Hugo how to bake one day. He is showing more and more interest in what I get up to in the kitchen these days. I plop him on the counter next to me and he watches as I knead pizza dough or helps measure oats when it's time for oatmeal. For now, though, he's content just eating crostata. And I'm happy to still be the one tasked with making it.

How to Make Crostata

A few notes on the recipe:

1. I've given you both metric and US measurements, but I haven't tested it with the US ones yet.

2. If you have access to Italian "00" flour, you can use that instead of all-purpose. If you don't, no sweat.

3. The baking powder here in Italy is conveniently flavored with vanilla. If you happen to have access to Pane Degli Angeli baking powder, you need half a packet. If not, use 3/4 teaspoon (8 grams) of regular baking powder and then add either a spoonful of vanilla sugar or of vanilla paste/extract.

4. The eggs here are smaller than in the US, so I've noted "medium" eggs. If you can't find those, you can use large but you may need to use a bit more flour as you go.

5. The butter must be very soft to be able to be quickly incorporated by hand into the dough. Let it sit out overnight before making the crostata.

6. My favorite jams in crostata are sour ones. Sour cherry, plum and apricot are all great choices. But you should feel free to choose whatever jam you like. You can even divide the crostata in half and fill it two different jams for variety. As for other fillings, there is such a thing as Nutella crostata, just FYI.

Crostata
Makes one 9-inch tart

200 grams / 1.5 cups plus 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour
Pinch of salt
50 grams / scant 1/4 cup sugar
8 grams / 3/4 teaspoon baking powder
Grated peel of 1/2 organic lemon
1/2 teaspoon of vanilla paste or extract if not using Pane Degli Angeli baking powder
2 medium eggs, room temperature
50 grams / 3.5 tablespoons unsalted butter, very soft
About 1/2 jar sour cherry or plum jam

1. Heat the oven to 180 C / 350 F. Dump the flour onto your work space and make a well in the middle. Sprinkle the salt, sugar and baking powder into the well, making sure to sift out any lumps in the latter. Add the grated lemon peel and vanilla flavoring, if using. 

2. Crack the two eggs into the well and, using your finger, stir them gently to break up and start incorporating into the dry ingredients. Then add the very soft butter and continue to stir until a rough dough starts to come together. Knead gently until it is smooth and uniform. Try not to overwork or add too much additional flour, but don't overthink things either; this is not pie crust.

3. Pull off a quarter of the dough and set aside. Pat the remaining dough evenly into a 9-inch pan and make sure to push the edges of the dough about 1/2 an inch up the sides of the pan to create a crust.

4. Spoon the jam into the crust and spread out evenly. Pinch off small pieces of the remaining ball of dough and roll them out into strips of varying length that you lay on top of the jam to create a lattice top.

5. Put the pan in the oven and bake for 20-25 minutes, until the tart is browned and the jam is bubbling. Let cool on a rack for an hour before turning out of the pan. Keeps for several days at room temperature.

Posted in ,

35 responses to “How to Make Crostata”

  1. Sylee Avatar

    And S was just asking for a cooking lesson this morning, and a friend gave us a jar of perfect homemade apricot jam. Thank you! As always, it’s a joy to live your golden Italian days vicariously. x

    Like

  2. Elizabeth Avatar

    Growing up, my Italian neighbour used to make this in sheet pans and if we were lucky, she would bring us some, one with lemon curd filling, one with plum jam. Years later I asked for the recipe and she gave me the “add enough flour to make a dough” sort of instruction. I have made it often over the years. The plum version was my favourite. She added a little cocoa powder to the plum – the ultimate filling!

    Like

  3. dervla Avatar

    mmm! Gonna make this with raspberry jam soon. Enjoy your time under those gorgeous skies.

    Like

  4. DIvya Avatar

    This looks so good!

    Like

  5. Dani Avatar

    The plum jam filling sounds delicious and I don’t know how I could ever pass up a Nutella version?!! My weakness…

    Like

  6. Elizabeth Mars Avatar

    Because we’re not great jam eaters in our house I’m always left with jars and jars of jam that need to be used up. This looks like just the thing.

    Like

  7. Kelleyn Avatar
    Kelleyn

    Yum! Now you are talking. Can’t wait to taste this recipe. Tried the focaccia the other day, amazing flavor! A little crunchy. Kids thought it was too hard to chew. Will try to make it again. Would live to find a recipe for potato focaccia that you mentioned in your book. BTW, loved your book. Will write more to you soon on it, but I am typing this on my phone. Enjoy Italy!!!

    Like

  8. Dani Avatar
    Dani

    I never knew it was so easy to make crostata. Also, so refreshing to read a dough recipe that’s supposed to be made by hand. It seems every recipe I read in the last few years asks for a food processor (which I never use–I use a pie cutter instead).

    Like

  9. Christine Avatar
    Christine

    How large are your jam jars? I have a bit of blackberry jam from the farmer’s market left, but I think it’s quite possibly too small. I guess the only thing to do is to buy more jam.

    Like

  10. Gerlinde Avatar

    Cool, I will make this using my homemade sour cherry jam. Have a wonderful relaxing vacation.

    Like

  11. Luisa Avatar

    I know, drives me nuts! 😉

    Like

  12. Luisa Avatar

    I knew someone would find that too vague 😉 I’m guesstimating you need about a cup to a cup and a half of jam. It should be a good fat layer, but not too thick. Use my photos for guidance? Good luck!

    Like

  13. Catherine Avatar

    “Aggressively simple”–I love it. Looks absolutely delicious.

    Like

  14. Jean Bellinghausen Avatar
    Jean Bellinghausen

    You had me at ” …eaten for breakfast and for dessert.” Looking forward to trying this. Thank you!

    Like

  15. Kelleyn Avatar
    Kelleyn

    Thank you! Can’t wait to try this version of focaccia.

    Like

  16. Becka Avatar
    Becka

    Luisa, I made this just last night and it was delicious! The US measurements worked perfectly and it was a lovely easy dough to put together. I sampled many crostatas when vacationing and studying abroad in Italy, so it was great to recreate at home.
    Hope you’re enjoying your vacation!

    Like

  17. Isabelle Avatar

    This looks absolutely delicious – will certainly give it a try. What a lovely discovery, this blog; will be back for more!

    Like

  18. Angela Brown Avatar

    This looks so great! My Italian grandmother used to make crostata when we were kids using either apricot or fig jam! I’ve never had one using Nutella, though that definitely sounds like something I should probably add to my weekend to-do list! Looks so beautiful…hope you’re having a wonderful time on your trip.

    Like

  19. Charlotte Avatar
    Charlotte

    This looks yummy and we have lots of pots of jam in our house of no-so much jam eaters.

    Like

  20. Robyn Avatar
    Robyn

    I am looking forward to trying this with gooseberry jam – Anglo-Italian crostata!

    Like

  21. Marce Avatar

    This reminds me of pastafrola, a very typical tart here in Argentina, which I always assumed was Italian, but I recently heard it´s a mix of different things. Anyway, it´s similar in terms of the dough, but filled with quince paste, called membrillo in Spanish, so I recommend that filling as well.

    Like

  22. Kristine in Santa Barbara Avatar
    Kristine in Santa Barbara

    I love jam cakes and tarts. Whenever I’ve looked up crostata recipe though, most have no leavening and the dough is more like pie dough, whether it’s a free form rustic one or the one with a lattice top. I prefer the Italian desserts that are less like pastry, more cakey, and I like them a little dry. So when i saw this post, I knew this was the one. I made it grain free by replacing the flour with 1.5 cups almond flour, 1/2 cup tapioca flour and 1/4 cup coconut flour. Followed the rest of the ingredients to a tee. Baked it for 30 minutes. Just delicious, we love it. Dough isn’t very sweet so contrasts well the jam (blueberry and cherry). Love the lemon zest and vanilla. Thank you for a new family classic!

    Like

  23. kelleyn rothaermel Avatar
    kelleyn rothaermel

    Mine looked nothing like this! I had to make two dough recipes because mine barely spread across the pan. Wish I could have watched your grandmother make this! Can’ wait to taste it in the morning. This one kicked my butt!

    Like

  24. Irina Avatar

    My Russian-Jewish grandmother used to make a very similar cake – she would have been surprised to see an Italian recipe that was so much like hers! Her recipe used less eggs and more butter (melted, not softened), and also included a few tablespoons of sour cream. She typically used grated apples as a filling, but sometimes she used jam or cocoa powder mixed with sugar. I continue to make this cake now that she is gone and it is such a great way to keep her memory and the taste of her home alive. The last time I made my grandma’s “crostata” was a couple weeks ago and I used homemade blackberry jam as the filling. I find that our version of crostata is best on the second or third day if stored in a lidded container – it becomes a little softer and the filling soaks through the dough a bit.

    Like

  25. Lynda Engle Avatar
    Lynda Engle

    I made this tonight and it was delicious!

    Like

  26. Renate Avatar
    Renate

    Made this …. and it is delicious !! The recipe is a bit like Muerberteig I use for my Pflaumenkuchen.
    Thank you.

    Like

  27. Luisa Avatar

    Ooh! Is your Mürbeteig relatively low in butter? I’m on the hunt for a good Mürbeteig for my next book…

    Like

  28. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    Hi Luisa,
    I made your crostata and it was loved by all–(one person took the recipe home). I used about 8 oz of jam–bought a 12 oz jar not knowing how much. Using cherry jam, it tasted like cherry pie and (for me) a little sweet for breakfast. I understand why you use sour cherry jam. I am going to try the suggestion of Irina using grated apple next.
    Thank you for such a good and easy recipe.
    Mary

    Like

  29. Olga Shenkerman Avatar

    Hi Luisa! I just wrote you an email, hope you get to read it! Thank you!

    Like

  30. ncnovice Avatar
    ncnovice

    I substituted 1/2 cup ground pistachios for flour in the dough and used apricot jam – so very delicious! Going to try it next with sour cherry jam, and maybe a bit of almond flour. Love how fancy this appears though it’s actually quite easy to make. Luxurious breakfast!

    Like

  31. anna Avatar
    anna

    The 3/4 tsp of baking powder is actually 4 grams not 8!

    Like

  32. Nancy Avatar
    Nancy

    I made my first Crostata last weekend at a workshop during the day-long 8th annual Mad for Marmalade, Crazy for Citrus sponsored by Toronto’s Fort York and the Culinary Historians of Canada. I am not a baker but I brought it home uncooked, froze it and will serve it tomorrow for the bridge ladies. I am madly excited that I may become a baker at the age of 76! Your recipe and details confirm I am on the right track.

    Like

  33. gf fnjkdf Avatar
    gf fnjkdf

    yoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyyyoyoyyoyoyoyyoyoyo

    Like

  34. Birdy Avatar
    Birdy

    Delicious! I’ve just had a slice. Hmmmm…..
    I had a glas of strawberry jam that I had to use up, I added lemon juice to the jam because we like a tart tart 😉
    It was quickly done but I only had troubles with the lattice, 1/3 of the dough didn’t seem to be enough so I had to stretch it. I rolled out the dough and cut the stripes.
    In the end all turned out well 🙂 Next time I want to try with plum puree.
    Thank you very much for sharing.

    Like

Leave a comment