Photo-1
(Before the photo police come a-calling, let me just put a disclaimer right up here at the front: I took this photo with my phone on Sunday evening, just before dinner, and I know it's sort of hideous, but I had absolutely no intention of blogging about it and so didn't think to pull out my real camera and anyway, even if I had, it is a proven fact of life that shooting meat is, shall we say, challenging and leave it at that.)

There! Now let's get down to brass tacks.

THIS CHICKEN. It may have the worst name in recipe-naming history (I'm renaming it Slow-Roasted Chicken), but that doesn't even matter, not one little bit, because OMG THIS CHICKEN. (Yes, I know with the all-caps, but this chicken deserves them plus several exclamation marks and a lot of underlining and four-letter words, too.)

The recipe comes from the current issue of Bon Appetit and even if you think that a new recipe for roast chicken is snoozeworthy, you need to know about this. Like, REALLY. (People, I have feelings about this chicken and they are not equivocal!)

Instead of roasting your bird at high heat or slathered with butter or barded with bacon, here you put together a little herb-spice rub (fennel, hot pepper, marjoram, thyme and salt), add some olive oil and then rub the bird all over with that mixture, sort of as if you were giving it a relaxing salt scrub. You stuff the bird with a whole head of garlic cut in half, a lemon cut into quarters and more marjoram and thyme. Then you put the bird on top of some thyme sprigs on a baking sheet, surround it with potatoes (I added carrots and parsnips) and put it in a low oven, 300° F, for two to three hours.

When the chicken is done (I put my oven just a little higher – at 160° C instead of 150° C – so it was done a little after two hours – but I had to take the vegetables out earlier, so definitely pay attention to what's going on in your oven around the 90-minute mark if you're going with the original temperature), it is meltingly tender and the joints have practically dissolved. The skin is irresistibly crisp, but you have none of the crazy chicken-fat smoking out of the oven that crispy skin usually requires. The roasted vegetables have shrunk and sweetened and are infused with herby, savory chicken fat. It's pretty much the greatest Sunday dinner ever.

But I'm not even done yet!

Because, believe it or not, this roast chicken, as delicious and perfect as it is freshly roasted, goes straight into the stratosphere as leftovers. I mean, cold roast chicken of any kind is tough to beat – it's just one of those home-run foods that everyone loves (right? RIGHT?) – but this cold roast chicken is unparalleled. A day or two of sitting in the fridge and it's pretty much the best thing ever.

Bonus proof-that-this-chicken-is-the-chicken-to-end-all-chickens story: This evening, while I was pulling the remaining meat off the carcass to repurpose as Indonesian chicken salad, Hugo literally grabbed the entire breast that I had just lifted off the bones out of my hands (I'd already put some shredded meat on his plate!) and proceeded to devour it, with his hands, like a very cute and yet slightly terrifying and hungry little caveman.

Slow-Roasted Herbed Chicken
Serves 4

1 teaspoon ground fennel
1 teaspoon crushed red pepper flakes
2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh marjoram; plus 4 sprigs, divided (I used dried and skipped the sprigs)
2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh thyme; plus 4 sprigs, divided
1 tablespoon kosher salt, plus more
½ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper, plus more
6 tablespoons olive oil, divided
1 3½–4 pound chicken
1 lemon, quartered
1 head of garlic, halved crosswise
2 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes, scrubbed, halved, or quartered if large

1. Preheat oven to 300°F (150 C°). Mix the fennel, red pepper, chopped or dried marjoram, chopped thyme, 1 tablespoon salt, ½ teaspoon pepper, and 3 tablespoons oil in a small bowl. Rub chicken inside and out with spice mixture. Stuff chicken with lemon, garlic, 2 marjoram sprigs, and 2 thyme sprigs. Tie legs together with kitchen twine.

2. Toss potatoes with remaining oil on a rimmed baking sheet; season with salt and pepper. Push potatoes to edges of baking sheet and scatter remaining 2 marjoram and 2 thyme sprigs in center; place chicken on herbs. Roast, turning potatoes and basting chicken every hour, until skin is browned, meat is extremely tender, and potatoes are golden brown and very soft, 2-3 hours. Let chicken rest at least 10 minutes before carving.

Posted in , ,

54 responses to “Bon Appetit’s Slow-Roasted Chicken”

  1. Stephanie Avatar

    OK — you got me! I started reading this, thinking I really don’t need another chicken recipe, but all your enthusiasm has totally convinced me. The next whole chicken that enters my house becomes a slow-roasted herb chicken.

    Like

  2. Dani Avatar
    Dani

    I actually like your photo. It looks like the chicken is so relaxed, with one of the legs slightly to the side–it captures the falling off the bone quality you described…

    Like

  3. Naomi Avatar
    Naomi

    I also made this Sunday night, slightly higher temp, for just over two hours, and while it was good, I wasn’t blown away. It was nice and moist, even then next night for leftovers, but I don’t think it holds a candle to the Zuni cafe roast chicken (small bird, very high temp, burn-inducing flipping of said bird twice during cooking). But this one is much less labor intensive.

    Like

  4. Katrin Avatar
    Katrin

    Yeah!

    Like

  5. Jennifer B Avatar
    Jennifer B

    Okay, you have me drooling!

    Like

  6. Christina Avatar

    Ok, after that ringing endorsement, there is no way I could not make this! We love roast chicken, it really is the perfect meal. I’m cracking up, my toddler eats chicken the same way as Hugo, shoving it in as though he’s frustrated his mouth isn’t bigger so he could get more in. Because, you know, we starve him.

    Like

  7. Christy Avatar

    That sounds amazing and relatively easy. I have had a chicken in my freezer for a few months now and I told my husband yesterday that it was getting cooked next week and that I needed to find a recipe for it. Thank you for making my search a very short one.

    Like

  8. Julie Avatar

    I bet the house smelled fabulous as it cooked. Thank you, I will try this method as it sounds like a great way to ensure the chicken isn’t undercooked too. That’s where I always mess up roasting birds.

    Like

  9. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    I saw that in BA and skipped right over it because of the name. I’m glad you saved it from the oubliettes!

    Like

  10. Sirena Avatar
    Sirena

    Actually relieved after I read this – I just did Thomas keller’s high-heat chicken and although it was fantastic (ridiculous – crisp skin, moist tender meat perfectly cooked throughout!) – the smoke billowing from the oven was terrible. I don’t know if I can go through that again not to mention having to clean my whole oven 🙂 Will definitely try this!

    Like

  11. Bethbochnak@gmail.com Avatar
    Bethbochnak@gmail.com

    I thought the flavor was great but after 2.5 hours it was dried out, altho it looked lovely. I used a 3.5 lb free range chicken. I would use the herbs again, lacking marjoram I used sage, and not 100% convinced a whole head of garlic was necessary.

    Like

  12. Thehungarybuddha Avatar

    Yum. Sold. This weekend.
    And your picture looks fabulous 🙂

    Like

  13. Gerlinde Avatar

    The next time I roast a chicken I will try this recipe. The last time my nephew, a budding chef, took the backbone out and baked the chicken at high heat. The chicken was good but the oven was a mess and the smoke terrible. I tend to just grab a rotisserie chicken to avoid a messy oven.

    Like

  14. Hannah Avatar
    Hannah

    We loved this one too. I made it because I read the recipe and happened to have everything right in the kitchen – but we were all surprised by how much we really loved it. (I think your photo is great – the chicken is sort of dancing a jig. It loved being roasted so slowly.)

    Like

  15. Baked Potato Oven Avatar

    I love this chicken.its really well roasted and dam i wish i can eat all mate..lol

    Like

  16. olga Avatar

    Perfect pictures are overrated 🙂 You’re a busy mom. It is what it is. We’ve clipped that recipe to our fridge and I can’t wait to make it – it sounded terrific in the magazine and I’m so glad you liked it too!

    Like

  17. Luisa Avatar

    Thank you for that, sweetheart!! xo

    Like

  18. dervla Avatar

    yum just when i was in the mood for roasted chicken this weekend, too!

    Like

  19. Tom @ Mastering the Flame Avatar

    Roasted chicken is really good, but you are right, the leftovers might just be better. There is so much you can do with all that leftover chicken. I love to make chicken potpies and chicken salad with my leftovers.

    Like

  20. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    Hi Luisa, thanks for this recipe. I’ll try it when I next roast a chicken (probably in the next few days!). My curiosity is piqued re cooking times.
    I hope I don’t sound rude and I understand you probably do so because most of your readership is US based but could you please consider adding more European measurements when you list the recipes you’ve tried?! I know, it’s more about my laziness and it’s not like I haven’t got the Internet or haven’t looked up what 2 pounds of potatoes is in kgs. or what a stick of butter is before but it would make life as a European fan of yours so much easier!
    Thank you so much and hope I haven’t offended you. x

    Like

  21. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    Crop the bottom and top of the chicken photo and it looks much better — cropping covers a multitude of siins.

    Like

  22. Luisa Avatar

    You didn’t offend me – I appreciate the feedback. I know there are others that feel the same way, but the truth is that it is a lot of work to do for every recipe and I often simply don’t have the time. And I actually like cooking with US measurements, it’s very comfortable for me because that’s what I’m used to. But I appreciate that on recipes more complicated than this one (where there are only two measurements that “need” to be translated – the weight of the chicken and of the potatoes), a translation would be nice.

    Like

  23. Luisa Avatar

    Ha, I did crop it – but apparently not enough! 🙂

    Like

  24. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    Thank you for replying. I appreciate it and glad to see I didn’t offend you! Happy Thursday! x

    Like

  25. Mary from Texas Avatar
    Mary from Texas

    Hi Luisa,
    How I love a slow roasted chicken! Thanks for sharing this recipe. The addition of fennel seeds is a nice touch. Also – I wanted to share – that last Thanksgiving, I slow roasted our Turkey rubbed with herbs to make it look like a rotisserie chicken. Oh my! It was the best turkey we ever had…falling off the bone, tender, juicy, and delicious. My family and guests still talk about it! I plan to do it like that every year.
    PS – love the previous picture of Hugo eating his salmon and buttered peas. Reminds me of my son when he was that age. He’s 15 now, and still loves salmon and peas!
    Love, Mary

    Like

  26. Gemma Avatar

    I sort of skimmed this in the magazine and thought I should read it properly but now I know I should try it – I haven’t roasted a chicken in a while and this is calling…

    Like

  27. alyssa Avatar
    alyssa

    Is your stove electric or induction? Our new house doesn’t have a gas line so we’re trying to decide what to get. Would love you to hear whether you like or dislike what you have! Thanks!

    Like

  28. Luisa Avatar

    That sounds fabulous! How big was your turkey and how low was your oven and how long did it take? I want to try it!

    Like

  29. Luisa Avatar

    It’s electric… it’s taken some time to get used to and it’ll never be like gas (sigh). I’ve heard induction is amazing! If you can choose, I’d do that over electric.

    Like

  30. Mary Avatar

    This has me drooling. I’ll have to try it.
    Have you ever tried Jamie Oliver’s roast chicken in milk? It’s my favorite roasted chicken recipe, but I’ve only recently returned to the land of the omnivore (I was vegetarian for a long time), so maybe I’m not the best judge on that…

    Like

  31. Tucker Avatar
    Tucker

    How big a chicken do you suggest, for this length of cooking time?

    Like

  32. Molly Avatar

    i SAW that recipe.
    i pulled the page.
    i read your post.
    twice.
    that was yesterday.
    today, ibought chickens.
    plural. two.
    because if leftovers are that good, surely one chicken would only lead to regret?
    thank you for confirming my suspicions.
    off to mindlessly roast a sublime set of chickens…

    Like

  33. MB Avatar

    I agree. Great photos are nice, but overrated 🙂 Your fabulous writing convinced me to try this chicken tonight! I have to say, I like Molly’s idea to buy two chickens. It would be nice to live off the leftovers during the week. If there are any leftovers.

    Like

  34. canddc@comcast.net Avatar
    canddc@comcast.net

    HI! Love your blog. Can’t wait to try the bird recipe. While on your page I wandered over to the Indonesian Chicken Salad recipe and am making it for guests tonight, any thought on the servings? Have you made it before? Maybe 4? thanks! Keep up the awesome blog!

    Like

  35. looa Avatar

    True, photographing food amazingly is the worst! I’ve made something fantastic, it looks and tastes great so I want to share a picture; but the flash is off and gloomy shadows abound. I’m quite hopeless no matter the make or model of the camera. Having said that, nothing beats a stellar recipe so I’ll definitely be following this one to make my own real-life juicy chicken.

    Like

  36. Molly Avatar

    Me again. So, with all due respect to those above who tried this and didn’t love it, WHAT HAPPENED?!
    Ahem.
    We roasted two, tonight, exactly as you outlined (but with dried herbs instead of fresh, as nothing but nothing is growing right now) and OH. MY. GOODNESS.
    Unbelievably tender. Flavorful beyond measure. Absolutely, gobsmackingly good. Hands-down, the best roast chicken, ever. Though admittedly, we’ve not yet had the leftovers. I am so sold. So, so beyond sold. I’m about to get embarassingly ALL CAPpy on you. So just: yes. YES!!!
    And thanks.
    xoxo,
    Molly

    Like

  37. Luisa Avatar

    Hi! Sorry I’m just answering now. I made half a recipe and my husband and I ate it all up, so I think 4 sounds right for the full recipe! Hope you liked it…

    Like

  38. Luisa Avatar

    HA! YES! 🙂

    Like

  39. Nuts about food Avatar

    I wish you had a picture of Hugo the caveman devouring the leftover of what sounds like a delicious roast chicken ;o)

    Like

  40. Rosilla Avatar
    Rosilla

    Sensationell. Stößt das Zunihähnchen vom Thron. Vielen Dank dafür!!!

    Like

  41. Luisa Avatar

    Oh, me too! 🙂

    Like

  42. Luisa Avatar

    Nicht zu danken! Ich finds auch grossartig. 🙂

    Like

  43. Kristine in Santa Barbara Avatar
    Kristine in Santa Barbara

    Well, I needed another roast chicken recipe so thank you for sharing this. I made the Zuni roasted chicken and it was fabulous but I will never do that again. Smoking. Dirty Oven. Tiny bird. Did I mention the smoking? Made this recipe last night (Sunday!) and it was a hit. Had a 5 pound bird and it took 2.5 hours at 325. Smelled amazing. Breast was juicy, dark meat was amazing. Husband, who doesn’t usually eat skin, just loved the flavors and gobbled it up. The herb mixtures is a good one. Don’t skip the fennel. Thanks for a great Sunday dinner with leftovers. Chicken salad for lunch today!

    Like

  44. Kristine in Santa Barbara Avatar
    Kristine in Santa Barbara

    I made this chicken again today, on a weekday. In the oven by 4:30, we ate at 7:30. This way of roasting is so, so good. Another 5 pound bird, this time I went with 300 degrees. Was done in less than 3 hours. No basting, no turning. Just pop it in and take it out. I didn’t even tie the legs. So flavorful, so moist. SO easy. I usually roast chicken once or twice a year, and now I’ve made this two weeks in a row. Thanks again for sharing!

    Like

  45. Amy P Avatar
    Amy P

    I have a similar recipe, but different spices and an onion in the cavity instead. The low-and-slow method is fantastic! I’ll have to give this flavour combination a go – I think I’d like the garlic head in there! And I too skipped over the ‘faux-tisserie’ chicken in BA…

    Like

  46. Ellen Avatar
    Ellen

    I really believed I had happened upon the perfect roast chicken LAST month with the high-temperature Bon Apetit Provencal roast chicken. I was done searching, having tried Thomas Keller’s and Barbara Kafka’s and the Zuni Cafe’s. But this, I must admit, is even better. After trying and loving the original (in spite of the terrible name), I have settled on this as more a method, though, and I use much of the flavoring from the Provencal recipe, mixing chopped garlic, dried herbes de Provencal, salt and olive oil and spreading this on the chicken, since it’s a little faster. I agree that cooking 2.5 hrs just makes the bird a little TOO mushy. It’s best at 2:15 or under. Just perfect–I love this–thank you for sharing the recipe.

    Like

  47. Amy P Avatar
    Amy P

    Sadly, there were no leftovers so I can’t attest to how those taste – but the chicken was great the first and only time around! I will do the vegetables separately next time though. And the chicken skin was quite salty – I loved it, but I could see it being too much for some people. Good thing I will make this again, since I bought the fennel just for this recipe after you convinced me it was worth it! After grinding the fennel I was worried about the final flavour – the spice rub was intensely licorice-y, but it was great once finished.

    Like

  48. Robin Avatar

    The incredibly rare “popular with all four of us” recipe–thank you so much for pointing it out! I’ve been enjoying Bon Appetit but never would have decided to make this for some reason.

    Like

  49. Laura Jo Avatar
    Laura Jo

    Geesh! I’m ready to run off to the store right this moment and grab me a chicken just to make this recipe! I LOVE your writing; this is the ultimate food porn. I’m not even hungry, yet, you make me want to try this recipe. NOW. I will post a followup message to this if I do). Dangit girl…. LOL

    Like

Leave a comment