David Tanis's Ambrosia

Happy New Year! I hope you all had restorative, calming breaks. Max was home for 16 blissful days and we enjoyed every single one. Even Hugo played along and stopped waking up at 5:00 am, for which we are both endlessly grateful. We may even buy him a pony in gratitude? A tiny motorcyle? His very own African elephant baby?

I know it is hopelessly unhip to admit to eating healthfully in January, but I can't help it. In the grand German tradition, we started eating piles of Christmas cookies all the way back on the first Advent and by the time New Year's rolled around, after the roasts and the jelly doughnuts and the Stollen and panettone and everything else, it would have been a freaking miracle if our pants weren't tight. Ahem. My pants. Also, I now have that sort of unpleasant sensation of being completely sugared out. Of being sated down to the tips of my toes. Best remedied by eating lightly and cleanly and by getting out and moving.

But I was invited to a lunch party yesterday and was tasked with bringing dessert. What was I going to do? I couldn't bring myself to even make a pan of brownies. (The last pan I made, David's dulce de leche brownies, was just after New Year's and while they were perfect, I couldn't bring myself to eat more than a few bites. Like I said, sugared out! To the tips of my toes!)

Instead, inspired by something I read online from Amanda Hesser about a reinvention of that old Southern dessert ambrosia, a mix of sliced oranges and shredded coconut, I turned to David Tanis's lovely book, A Platter of Figs. David Tanis updates the dish with just a few simple touches, turning it from simple and retro into something far more elegant, complex and delicious.

Segmented citrus

Instead of just using oranges, David has you use grapefruits, blood oranges, kumquats and navels (I didn't have navels, so used clementines). The grapefruits are segmented, the oranges are peeled and sliced and the kumquats are sliced, so you not only have a whole dance of different citrus flavor going on, but layers of texture too, especially once the soft pineapple and spiky coconut are tossed in. Some versions of the old ambrosia add canned crushed pineapple to the mix, but here, David has you dice up fresh pineapple, which adds an element of pure sweetness to the dish. And instead of sweetened shredded coconut, use unsweetened shredded coconut (I used a mix of flaked and shredded, just for fun). David's original recipe makes an enormous amount of ambrosia, so I scaled down the citrus a bit to the quantities below and it served 6 of us at the end of a 3-course lunch quite well.

David's ambrosia is the perfect winter dessert – seasonal and juicy, deeply satisfying and delicious, and beautiful to boot. I'm in love.

But next week is my mother's birthday and I am, of course, in charge of dessert. And while I adored the ambrosia, I'm not sure it's birthday party material. I want to find something that's celebratory and special, but still relatively light. So what can I make? A wintery pavlova? An angel food cake? A towering croquembouche filled with nothing but sweet, delicious air? Help a girl out, folks!

David Tanis's Ambrosia
Adapted from A Platter of Figs
Serves 6

2 pink grapefruits
2 blood oranges
2 clementines
8 kumquats
1/2 ripe pineapple
Sugar, if necessary
1 cup unsweetened shredded coconut

1. With a sharp knife, cut off the tops and bottoms of the grapefruits, blood oranges and clementines, then peel, making sure to remove all the white pith. Working over a bowl, section the grapefruit into wedges, cutting between the membranes. Before discarding, squeeze out the grapefruit carcasses into the bowl, they should yield quite a bit of juice. Slice the blood oranges and clementines into 1/4-inch rounds and add them to the bowl. Slice the kumquats into the thinnest rounds possible and add to the bowl. Peel and core the pineapple, then cut into small pieces and add to the bowl. With your (clean) hands, mix the fruits very gently. Taste the juice and if absolutely necessary, add a bit of sugar. Cover and set aside for up to several hours.

2. Just before serving, sprinkle the coconut over the salad. Toss gently and serve immediately.

Posted in , , ,

53 responses to “David Tanis’s Ambrosia”

  1. Katie K Avatar
    Katie K

    Marcella Hazan’s almond torte.

    Like

  2. Katie K Avatar
    Katie K

    Marcella Hazan’s almond torte.

    Like

  3. bea Avatar
    bea

    This looks fantastic.
    For your mom…. anything with lemon in it!

    Like

  4. fabric Avatar

    oh this looks lovely! as for your mama how about claudia roden’s orange and almond cake? or may i suggest nigel slater’s chocolate almond. it’s got ground almonds and its very grown up, a bit dark with espresso that you can serve in the tiniest slivers. http://comeconella.blogspot.co.uk/2010/12/birthday-cake-for-o.html

    Like

  5. Erin in PA Avatar
    Erin in PA

    May I suggest a lemon olive oil cake? I find those just right for winter celebrations. I too am sugared and chocolate-d out by this point of the year, and that ambrosia looks just lovely and bright! It would be lovely alongside an olive oil cake. I think the recipe I use is from Bon Appetit or Gourmet, but I am not positive.

    Like

  6. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    Glad you had a great Christmas break. What about floating islands? Maybe too fiddly to bring with but they are light, luscious and decadent… Let us know what you do whatever you choose. It will be perfect I’m sure and happy new year to you and yours!

    Like

  7. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    I always loved coffee angel food cake with slivered almonds sprinkled on the icing.

    Like

  8. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    David has an update on the fruit salad in his new book — One Good Dish. He uses persimmons and oranges sprinkled with sugar and pistachios…

    Like

  9. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    I love Karen Demasco’s lemon steamed puddings. Very light, almost soufflé like cake, with a layer of lemon curd that forms on top. Beautiful, easy to make, luscious and refreshing.

    Like

  10. Zoomie Avatar

    Nigella Lawson has an online recipe for a cake made with whole clementines and almond flour that is not too sweet but really delish. If youGoogle “clementine cake” and look for her name, you will find it. Don’t reduce the sugar in the recipe. It is perfect as written, although you will doubt. 🙂

    Like

  11. dervla Avatar

    I’d definitely still go citrus again though, what about a lemon or grapefruit mousse? I also loved the suggestion above for that lemon steamed pudding. I myself was thinking of this satsuma and pomegranate cake this month: http://www.tarteletteblog.com/2013/12/recipe-gluten-free-satsuma-pomegranate.html

    Like

  12. Elissa Avatar

    My favorite light dessert lately is granita (e.g. http://hartsinthekitchen.com/blog/2013/7/2/a-tale-of-two-desserts, but not sure that the presentation is birthday appropriate. Maybe served with cookies? Or have you ever made individual pudding cakes? I have a cookbook with a great recipe for key lime pudding cakes that is light and refreshing but still delicious–can share if you’re interested.

    Like

  13. Julie Avatar
    Julie

    It might sound a bit “health nutty” but I love making chocolate mousse with silken tofu instead of heavy cream. It’s a pinch to make, can be prepped ahead of time, looks great (especially with some whipped cream and orange zest)… And no one ever suspects its soy base. Recipes abound online!

    Like

  14. Amy Avatar

    I love Smitten Kitchen’s Yogurt Panna Cotta http://smittenkitchen.com/blog/2013/04/yogurt-panna-cotta-with-walnuts-and-honey/. Light, and you could put any fruit on top- some jam, or citrus segments. I used vanilla yogurt when I made it, so I cut way back on the added sugar.

    Like

  15. Amy Avatar

    Oh, and for Julie’s comment, about the tofu mousse- I’ve made a recipe from Heidi at 101cookbooks. It was heavenly.

    Like

  16. Rivka Avatar

    I made this for a birthday recently – such a hit: http://www.nigella.com/recipes/view/gooey-chocolate-stack-161

    Like

  17. Tamsin Avatar
    Tamsin

    Not very fashionable but I had crepes suzette (with a scoop of vanilla ice cream) for my birthday dessert over a month ago and I’m still thinking about them now. I bet they would be lovely with a mix of citrus.

    Like

  18. Kim A Avatar
    Kim A

    Ina Garten (the Barefoot Contessa) has a “heavenly” Angel Food Cake that is flavored with lemon zest. Absolutely scrumptious!

    Like

  19. Alicia Avatar
    Alicia

    Pavlova with pomegranate arils and cream. So good.

    Like

  20. Luisa Avatar

    YES, THIS. Sounds incredible!

    Like

  21. Luisa Avatar

    Have been meaning to try those for ages and ages. This might be the time!

    Like

  22. Luisa Avatar

    Ooh, this is definitely a must-try recipe for me one day, but it’s too complicated for my mom’s birthday, I have to transport it from my house to hers… But one day! Thanks for reminding me.

    Like

  23. Charlotte Avatar
    Charlotte

    Or with passionfruit and yogurt? Although I love a lovely lemon mousse or icebox pie.

    Like

  24. Shauna Avatar

    Ahem…I would like to recommend a recipe for Vanilla Cloud Cake in a certain cookbook that I may or may not have written. (I find it goes over big with the non-traditional birthday cake crowd.) xxoo

    Like

  25. Bobbie Avatar
    Bobbie

    My husband made me my favorite – gingerbread – for my birthday recently. Lemon glaze gilded the lily, and of course we had to have schlag. Not the lightest thing, but so tasty, and there’s something about it that makes me think it’s healthy!

    Like

  26. Elizabeth Avatar

    Pavlova is always good particularly with the festive addition of pomegranates. Nicholas Day posted ALice’s Medrich’s labneh pie a while back and it is one of those amazing not too sweet deserts. http://food52.com/blog/6216-alice-medrich-s-labneh-lebni-labni-tart

    Like

  27. Ashley Avatar
    Ashley

    Rose and raspberry St Honore !

    Like

  28. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    Hi Luisa,
    Good to see you back here…and Happy New Year! Hope 2014 brings you a year filled with good health, happiness…and delicious food! 🙂
    For a light dessert, I think you can’t miss with the Brown Derby’s Chiffon Cake. A nice light cake with a hint of the nostalgia of the Clark Gable era of the glamorous, golden age of Beverly Hills.
    As legend tells it…
    “The story about Harry Baker and his famous Chiffon Cake is the kind of stuff on which legends are built and numerous references can be found in food reference books. According to the legend, the Chiffon Cake was invented in 1927 by Harry Baker, a California insurance salesman turned caterer.”
    Furthermore…
    “Harry Baker sold his Chiffon Cake to places like the Brown Derby which had a simple menu in its earliest years. The first dessert to be sold at the Derby was Harry Baker’s cake which was made by Mr. Baker and sold to the restaurant and to other Hollywood notables for their parties. The Brown Derby cookbook published in 1949 provides a brief explanation for the cake.”
    And where does Clark Gable come in? Well, the Brown Derby was his favorite restaurant. (It’s also home to the “Cob Salad”.)
    Here’s a recipe (thanks to Nick Maglieri) for his take on Harry Baker’s Chiffon Cake: (PS – Nick uses, lemon, but I think any citrus would work. As a matter of fact, I think the original Brown Derby Chiffon Cake was made with orange.)
    Delicate Lemon Chiffon Cake (adapted from “Perfect Cakes” by Nick Maglieri)
    2 ¼ c. cake flour (spoon flour into dry-measure cup and level off)
    1 ½ c. granulated sugar
    1 T. baking powder
    ½ c. vegetable oil, such as corn or canola
    4 large egg yolks
    1/3 c. fresh lemon juice plus cold water to make ¾ cup
    2 tsp. lemon extract
    1 c. egg whites (from 7-8 large eggs) – at room temperature
    Pinch of salt
    – One 10-inch tube pan with removable bottom, ungreased; or two 9-in. round cake pans with waxed paper in the bottoms
    – Wine bottle on which to hang the cake to cool
    1. Set the rack in the middle of the oven and preheat to 350 degrees.
    2. Sift the cake flour into the bowl of a heavy-duty mixer (or use hand mixer). Add all but ¼ cup of the sugar and the baking powder and stir well to mix.
    3. In a medium bowl, stir together the oil, egg yolks, water, and extract. Stir the liquid ingredients into the dry ingredients, then beat on medium speed for about a minute, or until smooth.
    4. In a clean, dry mixing bowl, whip the egg whites and salt with the whisk attachment on medium speed until very white and opaque and beginning to hold a shape. Increase the speed to medium-high, and whisk in the remaining ¼ c. sugar in a stream. Continue to whip the egg whites until they hold a firm peak.
    5. With a large rubber spatula, fold the yolk mixture into the egg whites, making sure to scrape the bowl thoroughly. Pour the batter into the prepared pan(s).
    6. Bake for about 55-60 minutes (tube pan) or 30-35 minutes (rounds), or until the cake is deep gold and firm; a toothpick inserted halfway between the side of the pan and the center should come out clean. Invert the central tube of the tube pan onto the neck of the bottle and allow to cool completely upside down; cool round cakes upside down, as well.
    7. To remove the cooled cake from the pan, run a long thin knife around the sides of the pan; remove the pan sides and run the knife around the tube and under the cake. Invert the cake onto a platter, easing it off the central tube with your fingers.
    Serving: Use a sharp serrated knife to cut the cake. Cake may be glazed, or served with whipped cream and/or fruit.
    Storage: Wrap in plastic or keep under a cake dome at room temperature. Or, wrap well and freeze.
    Hope this helps with your list of ideas for your Mom’s birthday celebration. Early Happy Birthday to her! My Mom just turned 89 at the beginning of January!
    Love,
    Mary

    Like

  29. Mommy G Avatar
    Mommy G

    It’s a great idea.. and it’s easy to relate to being sugared out:)
    http://maybetodayistheday1.blogspot.com/

    Like

  30. katy Avatar

    I recently made a chocolate pavlova with honeyed whipped cream, pomegranate arils and clementines and it was a huge hit–both for Thanksgiving and for Christmas Eve.

    Like

  31. Maria Avatar
    Maria

    Hi,
    Long-time reader; first-time commenter :-). Saw this today and thought of you and your cake dilemma, although I think you can’t go wrong with any of the suggestions here! Happy birthday to your mom!
    http://scally.typepad.com/cest_moi_qui_lai_fait/2014/01/la-tarte-aux-clémentines-alex-croquet.html

    Like

  32. Patty Avatar

    http://www.saveur.com/article/recipes/thomas-kellers-coconut-cake
    This is a link to a cake I must try: Thomas Keller’s coconut cake. Forget resolutions, this looks wonderful.

    Like

  33. Suzy Avatar

    Even though pavlova IS sugar I find if you heap enough fruit and lightly folded cream on it, it feels fresh and light. Or I have been making Matcha green tea cake with chocolate chips in it. Even though it’s green – all 3 girls love it. Super squishy, super light, barely sweet – could not support icing I think and also you need an angel cake aluminium pan – which I don’t have so have been making a 2 egg quantity in my one tiny aluminium loaf pan – which disappears as soon as it’s cool enough to eat.

    Like

  34. nicole Avatar

    I like a nice angel food cake with a hit of citrus — like grapefruit zest, or clementine — and maybe a sprinkling of poppyseeds, served with whipped cream and fruit. Or a plain angel food with lemon curd or maybe ambrosia piled on top of slices instead? Best of both 🙂 Happy new year!

    Like

  35. S Avatar

    Happy New Year. How about a Persian baklava cake – it transports really well and has no phyllo to fiddle with. The dried rose petals make it look festive. My recipe is in Persian, but I found one very close to the one I have: http://familyspice.com/recipes/recipe/?recipe_id=396
    It is lovely with tea or a Metodo Classico.

    Like

  36. Lynn D. Avatar
    Lynn D.

    My mother used to make a hot fruit compote with dried, fresh and canned fruits. There are lots of recipes out there. I think hers had curry powder in it, but I can’t find a recipe online for that. Nice with perhaps a simple pound cake or maybe some cheese.

    Like

  37. Heather Avatar
    Heather

    Before I got to the end of the paragraph I was ready to shout pavlova (as if you can hear it when I talk to you through my computer screen). Pomegranate sounds wonderful; I was thinking with cherries and pistachios.
    But now I am thinking the fruit compote served with cheese sounds delicious.

    Like

  38. Maegan Avatar
    Maegan

    I love making tapioca pudding from scratch, preferably with egg yolks. Then whip the leftover whites with a bit of honey and fold them into the cooled tapioca. Buy some kind pretty, fancy dance shortbread type cookies and serve pudding in pretty glasses/bowls with a cookie and a nip of cinnamon sugar on top.

    Like

  39. Anna Avatar

    Yum! Pavlova with pomegranate sounds (and would look!) beautiful. At bills cafe in Sydney they serve pavlova with yogurt cream (a mix of Greek yogurt and whipped cream) and it is so light and refreshing.

    Like

  40. Katy Bee Avatar
    Katy Bee

    Pavlova!!!!!
    There are few things in life more comforting and perfect that a slice of well-made, crispy, marshmallowey pavlova. Pomegranate would be nice, or passionfruit maybe.

    Like

  41. Luisa Avatar

    Do you have a favorite, fool-proof recipe for a well-made pavlova?

    Like

  42. Joanne Craven Avatar

    This looks juicylicious! Very fresh. On a really hot day maybe add a scoop of Italian lemon flavored sorbet?

    Like

  43. Kat Avatar
    Kat

    Deb Perelman did a post about a pavlova she made for her parents a few years ago. She used meringue recipe adapted from Joy of Baking and Shuna Lydon who gives step by step instructions with photos. Her mixed berry and raspberry sauce came from Ina Garten. http://smittenkitchen.com/blog/2007/04/a-ballet-of-sorts/

    Like

  44. Rebekah Avatar
    Rebekah

    This really is a summer dish, but I love the Summer Berry Pudding in The New Best Recipe. It’s light and delicious and beautiful. I’m sure you could make it with frozen berries since the berries are cooked. I dream about this dish all year ’round.
    Also had a tapioca once that was made with coconut milk and infused with lemongrass–delicious!

    Like

  45. Denise | Chez Danisse Avatar

    This looks fresh and delicious and perfect for tonight. Thank you!

    Like

  46. Leslie Avatar

    Happy birthday to your mom. Do you mind sharing where you found the large flaked coconut in Berlin? I find the standard German coconut flakes too small and hard and miss the softer, larger shreds in the US… combining tiny and large flakes seems like a good compromise.
    Regarding your mom’s birthday, didn’t you write once about how cooking what you felt like eating at home ended up being perfect for dinner parties as well, if if the food was not explicitly “festive”? I don’t see anything wrong with bringing ambrosia… I suspect some of the other birthday guests may be feeling sugared out, too, and will appreciate it. Also, you have the advantage that European guests won’t necessarily associate it with church potlucks, picnics and mini-marshmallows the way Americans might.
    If you feel like you must do something a bit more structured, you could serve it alongside mini-pavlovas or a small angel-food cake.
    Or sometimes I make a layered ambrosia of orange and date slices, infusing a little of the orange juice with cinnamon, anise, cardamom etc. for a light sauce. Layering the slices dresses it up a little; in fact, I invented the dish for a tiramisu cook-off. It was much welcome as a respite from the other, super-rich entries!

    Like

  47. Jennie Avatar

    I have such fond memories of the ambrosia my grandmother would serve at Christmas parties. In typical 50s style, it also featured mayonnaise, and mini marshmallows. Hideous, but fondly remembered all the same, right down to the stale left over marshmallows that I would sneak from her pantry for months afterward.

    Like

  48. Luisa Avatar

    Bio Company! And you’re right that the ambrosia would probably be fine – but I’d love to try something new 😉

    Like

  49. Leslie_kuo Avatar

    Thanks for the info, Luisa… I will check the nearest Bio Company.

    Like

Leave a comment