After the Whole 30
Last Wednesday, my nutritional reset came to an end. I spent thirty days without eating grains of any kind, as well as eschewing dairy and soy and sugar and legumes (and alcohol and caffeine, which I rarely drink anyway) and, finally, it was over. Not five days earlier, I'd been crowing about the pizza topped with fresh mozzarella and cherry tomatoes I was going to eat when the Whole30 was over. I couldn't wait to put milk in my tea again and eat yogurt for breakfast. But then the end came and went and that first bowl of yogurt? Actually made me feel a little lousy. And it turns out I didn't really want any milk in my tea after all – in fact, I didn't want any Earl Grey at all anymore. Toast? No, thank you. Pizza? Nah. Pasta, nuh-uh. All I wanted was to keep eating the way I had been for the past month.

You could have knocked me over with a feather made of fairy dust.

First things first: the results. I lost three kilos (six and a half pounds) during the Whole30, which brings me back to my pre-pregnancy weight, which is what I'd been hoping for. (Despite the weight loss, a lot of my old clothes just don't fit the way they used to, but such is life. In exchange, I got Hugo, so I'm definitely winning.) My joint pain didn't go away, but I don't think it has much to do with my diet now. And my insomnia did indeed get better. It took a while and it's not entirely gone, but it got much better. So, on the whole, I'd have to say that the Whole30 was, for me, a success.

Now. My thoughts. I don't know how people live like this all the time. For thirty days, it was fine. It was fun! It was challenging, but an enjoyable challenge. However, it burned a big hole in my bank account. BIG, people. Meat is expensive! As are nuts and organic fruits and vegetables and, seriously, how do people do it if they eat like this all the time? This is not a rhetorical question, I'm really wondering. I'm not a penny pincher when it comes to food, either.

Second of all, while I actually really enjoyed being forced to come up with new ways to enjoy meat (I think I ate more meat in the last month than in the entire previous year before that), I couldn't imagine being indefinitely deprived of all the variety of delicious foods available on our lovely planet. The textures and flavors and sheer versatility of grains and legumes and dairy products are such a delight! Living without them forever would be so sad.

(Also, I am personally of the persuasian that we humans should be eating a lot less meat and a lot more plants to do our part as environmentalists, so while a month of the Whole30 didn't mess with my conscience, I can't imagine continuing it for that reason alone.)

Now, I had been way too reliant on my daily sugar high before I started the Whole30 and I'm really glad that I was able to last the month without craving it at all. It was a bad habit that started in pregnancy and sustained me during the months of breastfeeding but then become nothing but an indulgence I didn't need anymore. So, while I don't want to live a life without bread and beans and yogurt, I really would like to eat less sugar. And I'm amazed to say that of all the things I'm "allowed" to eat again, cake (or whatever) is nowhere on the list of things I crave.

Things it turns out I love? Sweet potato fries made with David's sage-and-rosemary rub. Almond milk. Oat-free granola. Cashew butter. Homemade beef broth.

If you're thinking about doing the Whole30, my only advice is to really commit to the whole month. Don't give up after a week. Remember those fuzzy headaches I got? They disappeared after 9 days. I got struck with the grumps around Day 18, but otherwise I felt an incredible clarity of mind that lasted until the end. I stopped having exhausted slumps in the afternoon and I felt full of energy, even on little sleep. And while just five days before the end, as I mentioned, I was exultant about the Whole30 ending, by the time it actually did end, it turned out that reset was the right word. I felt totally reprogrammed.

The challenge now is to find my way back out of the Whole30. So tonight, there shall be oyster sauce on my bok choy! And tomorrow, I plan to stew rhubarb with some sugar! This is the life.

Happy Memorial Day to you folks in the States. I can smell your barbecues and freshly cut grass all the way over here.

Posted in

34 responses to “After The Whole30”

  1. Giulia Doyle Avatar

    Glad you made it! I felt similar when I gave up sugar for lent – even though that was a minor reprogramming it helped get me out of the craving habit. But it’s so easy to start adding sugar again when it’s not needed 😉

    Like

  2. christine Avatar
    christine

    A good testimonial! It’s tough, especially for those who don’t really like meat to start with. I am so glad you got through the whole month, and congrats on losing the excess weight! I’ll admit, I haven’t completely gotten rid of grains. But I’m close. I’ll have rice at an Indian restaurant, or in the occasional sushi, and I make a loaf of long-fermented sourdough once or twice a month and splurge with toast and jam. Oh, and definitely corn tortillas/chips with Mexican food. But mostly, it’s veggies, eggs, meat, and fruit, in that order. Overall, I just eat less and I’m less hungry. Breakfast gets skipped some days without a problem, and I just eat 2-3 times a day, no need to snack. Everything is cooked with butter or olive oil, coffee gets heavy cream, and I’m not afraid of the fatty bits of meat. The grisly ends and bones make broth, and soups can stretch even the ugliest root veggies and saddest greens. We spend more money on good-quality meat, eggs, and dairy, but we aren’t buying all of the processed boxes that have infinite shelf-lives. I also buy veggies in season, so it about evens out for our bill. I’m lucky to live in a farming community, so even though a lot of what I buy isn’t organic, I know it’s not sprayed.
    For joint pain- do you take fish oil? That and the chiropractor have helped immensely, but eating low-sugar has done wonders too. It took awhile (3-4 months) to really kick in.

    Like

  3. Beth Druce Avatar

    Really interesting reading… I too think plants and grains are such an important and integral part of our diets, and that we’d do a whole lot better on less sugar. I think if that’s what you took from Whole30 then that’s great. And can’t wait to try the sweet pot fries. X

    Like

  4. Katie Avatar
    Katie

    I agree with you that eating a lot of meat is not exactly good for us. I worked with a nutritionist at the famous Cooper Clinic in Dallas TX and they believe you should limit yourself to 3 oz meat per day. They like the athletes diet of high carbs (whole grains) since they are energy boosters. They cut calories by leaving off sugars and eat limited amounts of low fat meat or beans, but eat a lot of vegetables and fruits. It’s a great diet but you have to exercise on this diet to lose weight!

    Like

  5. Τέτη Κωνσταντινίδου (Teti Konstantinidou) Avatar
    Τέτη Κωνσταντινίδου (Teti Konstantinidou)

    Michelle from The Sweet Beet (www.thesweetbeet.com) suggests training ourselves to detect the sweet taste in foods that we hadn’t thought about before. She also gives tips on flavoring eg. yoghurt with vanilla or cinnamon instead of adding sugar or honey.

    Like

  6. looa Avatar

    I basically eat like this already {minus the lack of bread} and need to force myself to eat meat and sugar. I lack the essential proteins in meats, eggs, and the calcium in dairy so I’d actually like to try a reverse whole30 eating plan and see the results. I tend to get tired a lot now and notice that I keep weight in my lower body. I under eat and as I don’t drink enough water; it’s not even water weight. I have no idea exactly how my body processes food anymore.

    Like

  7. Conny Avatar

    Thanks for this thorough summary, it’s very helpful!
    A while ago, I’ve been looking into the Paleo diet, which seems very close to the whole30 concept. The reason I hesitated to try it is one you mention as well: Eating that much meat somehow doesn’t seem right to me. Aside from the cost, you’d really have to find a trusted source for organic, grass fed meat – otherwise I’d fear that it does more harm than good.
    Anyway, I’m really tempted to give it a try now, after reading along on your journey. Who doesn’t need a reset for some sort of convenient eating habit? 🙂
    Today’s dinner was whole30-ish, let’s see how tomorrow goes. Thanks again for sharing and inspiring others.

    Like

  8. Anna Avatar
    Anna

    I did it too, with similar results and reservations. We are continuing to eat more or less this way at home, without restrictions in restaurants. I still feel ambivalent about eating so much meat, but I feel physically a lot better. Also, we noticed the cost started to go down as we got clearer about what we would eat. And we eat a LOT of chicken…

    Like

  9. STH Avatar
    STH

    I asked a dietician about low-carb diets and she told me that it’s best to eat a wider variety of foods–the nutrients in grains and dairy are important to staying healthy. And I worry about the environmental consequences of eating so much meat, too. My partner is a diabetic, so we’re both on a diabetic diet and I’ve found that to be very doable and balanced; we have small portions of lean protein, lots of veg, and some whole grains, while limiting sweets. It gives me the flexibility to buy what’s in season (or on sale) and therefore watch the budget while allowing us to eat most of the things we like.

    Like

  10. Molly Avatar

    Luisa,
    Thanks so much for sharing your experience, here. It seems a bold thing, somehow, in this hare-brained world of strong sentiments and food factions. It is wonderful to hear a thoughtful, mindful, honest (!!!) take on how we navigate this weird, wonderful modern food landscape.
    Cheers,
    Molly

    Like

  11. ellie Avatar
    ellie

    Hi Luisa,
    I’m curious if you were exercising while on the Whole30 plan? I did a no-carb diet for 3 months (don’t recommend that!) but found exercising to be incredibly taxing on my body. Wondering if you had a similar experience?
    I’ve also become a convert to sweet potatoes but cannot believe the price difference between them and their yellow colored friends.. woah! All the ones I’ve found in Berlin so far are from the US, though.
    Congratulations on your Whole30 success!
    Ellie

    Like

  12. Katie Avatar

    I’m glad you mentioned the expense thing, Luisa. When I first went down that list of foods to forego for 30 days, one of the first thoughts that came to mind was: damn, this is not a diet for anyone on a tight budget. It’d be hard for me to give up legumes for a month just because they’re so inexpensive and filling!
    Anyway, thanks for being so forthcoming about your experiences with Whole30, and I’m glad that it’s prompted some positive changes in your life!

    Like

  13. Luisa Avatar

    No, and that’s actually what I think is mostly behind the insomnia (and weight issue) – and it’s one of the reasons I’m so desperately looking for a babysitter! I need to start moving again. But I’m actually surprised to hear that you found it taxing, because I felt really strong and energized once those first 9 days were over and if I’d been able to work out, I have the feeling I would have powered through really well. But you know, I think these things are hugely different from person to person. We all react so differently to different foods – one person’s poison is another person’s fuel. You know?

    Like

  14. Jill Avatar
    Jill

    After giving birth last summer I have been suffering from insomnia too. I’ve been wondering if some dietary changes might help. I cannot handle a diet so heavy in meat though. I’m glad this was successful for you!

    Like

  15. Luisa Avatar

    A couple readers on a few posts back said that they too suffered from insomnia in their babies’ first year. I think it’s probably a mix of hormones and habit and wakeful mama-nerves?

    Like

  16. Oana from dishchronicles Avatar

    In reply to the how do you so it financially thing, it’s literally a choice to pay for food over some other things. We choose to drive a Ford instead of an Audi (much to my husband’s disappointment, I think he’s campaigning for one this year :)), eat smaller portions of the more expensive things. Buy less expensive organic cuts of meat like necks and backs and cheeks which are all super awesome and nutritious. Some months it’s literally: Is it the Dress or the Asparagus 🙂 Sometimes I sacrifice the dress and sometimes the asparagus has to go. All to say it is not an easy task…

    Like

  17. Kristine in Santa Barbara Avatar
    Kristine in Santa Barbara

    Luisa: thanks so much for posting your follow up. I’d never heard of the Whole30 until you posted about it. (I read a lot of food and culture blogs, don’t know how I missed it!). I started it two weeks later and found it pretty easy to follow. But the few meals that we had out had me really concerned with the quality and type of oils, additives, and the sugar that was sneaking into everything, even at the “farm to table” places. So my husband joined me a few days ago for a formal Whole30 and we plan to mostly eat in and pack food for travel.
    Even before I started I was concerned about the sustainability of paleo/primal type eating. Not just environmental sustainability, but lifestyle and cost sustainability. It’s a lot of shopping, a lot of cooking and a lot of dishes. And then there is the social and community impact of eating alternatively. Who wants to be left out of pizza night or birthday cake or wedding champagne? My understanding from a lot of reading I did is that the Whole30 was truly intended and designed to be a re-set and not long-term. The self experimentation part is figuring out what feels OK to add back in. Does you feel good after you eat it? Or, if it doesn’t feel good, was it worth it? 🙂 That was my take away, at least.
    I’m sure you’ll find your way. Oyster sauce and stewed rhubarb sound like a great and delicious start! (But Sister, throw away that Better than Bouillon. Seriously. The sugar and corn syrup in it are the least egregious ingredients. In spite of claims that it has no msg, it contains ingredients that are all msg based or derived. It’s dreck. Tasty dreck. It should be called Tastes Too Good to Be Bouillon.)
    I feel great after my initial two weeks and am looking forward to seeing what develops over the next 30 days. Thanks once again for inspiring me in the kitchen and elsewhere.

    Like

  18. Luisa Avatar

    I’m so glad I inspired you! Thanks for your lovely comment. But you can pry the Better Than Bouillon out of my cold, dead hands. 🙂

    Like

  19. Dan from Platter Talk Avatar

    What an interesting post! Thanks for chronicling this experience. I’m not sure I have discipline to undertake such a challenge but it certainly gives pause to consider what we use for self-sustenance.

    Like

  20. Eileen @ Phoenix Helix Avatar

    I eat similar to the Whole 30 for health reasons. (It’s reduced my rheumatoid arthritis symptoms by 90%, and let me tell you, that transformed my life. I went from excruciating pain to mild discomfort. So, that’s a strong motivation for me to stick with it.) I’ve been doing it for a year, and how I afford it is that all the money we used to spend at restaurants and coffee shops and bakeries and on junk food general is redirected into the whole 30 foods instead. For that reason, it’s not more expensive for us. As for the ethics, we’re lucky to live in a community with a lot of ethical farmers. We have access to local, pastured, humanely raised beef, pork, chicken and eggs. I just buy the inexpensive cuts of meat, rather than the pricey ones. I also make a lot of soups and stews which stretches out the meat. People should also know that most paleo people eat a ton of vegetables. It’s not a meat-only diet. I’ll be curious to see what you choose to do going forward. A lot of people follow paleo eating 80% of the time and eat as they want with the other 20%. It’s a good option for someone who doesn’t have a health problem. As for the joint pain, nightshades are big trigger for me. I can’t imagine you’d want to give them up, but it would be an interesting experiment. One tiny bit of potatoes, tomatoes, eggplant, peppers, or pepper spices, and my joints flare. Food (and its effect on our bodies) is fascinating.

    Like

  21. M.E. Avatar
    M.E.

    It was interesting to hear your candid reflections on the Whole30. Like other posters, I am still leery! There is actually a lot of science to support intake of plant-based protein sources like beans and whole grains and very little evidence to support the healthfulness of meat. Cardiologists routinely prescribe whole-food vegan diets for high risk patients (e.g. Bill Clinton). I suspect the paleo diet works because it similarly cuts sugar and increases vegetable intake. Diet is personal and you should take cues from your body, but I’d be curious to know if you could get the same benefit with beans instead of meat. This change would curtail the compromises (monetary, environmental, ethical, health) in a way that’s supported by nutritional data. Given how little we know decisively about nutrition today, making conclusions about it in paleolithic era seems a bit unreasonable. I think this is why the paleo movement stems from the fitness community rather than the medical or scientific ones.

    Like

  22. Luisa Avatar

    Thanks, love!

    Like

  23. Luisa Avatar

    Yes, absolutely, my vegetable consumption definitely increased. I was just focused on the meat, since that was a huge change for me. Normally, I eat a pretty large amount of vegetables anyway. I’m glad you found something that helps your RA symptoms!! (And obviously, it makes total sense to me to follow a diet like this if it’s for health reasons.)

    Like

  24. Lara Avatar

    Since you wanted insight on managing this kind of diet financially, here’s my experience. We live VERY frugally on one modest income, and manage to feed our family of 3 a diet with minimal processed food, 100% organic dairy, and almost all local, pastured meat. We live in a mid-sized midwestern city, so food costs are a little lower than they would be in a metropolitan area, but the biggest thing we’ve done to make our food dollars go farther is to buy our meat in bulk through local farm CSA’s. We go in with family on a quarter cow every year, and buy a half pig for ourselves. These animals are raised humanely, on grass, by people we know and trust. Not only are we supporting the type of agriculture we believe in, we’re also keeping our food dollars local. There’s the initial investment to buy a chest freezer, as well as the (in my opinion, enjoyable) challenge of figuring out what to do with all the odd cuts, but we pay less per pound for organic, local, pastured meat than we would at the supermarket.
    As far as health concerns, pastured meat has a completely different fat profile than meat from animals that have been fed industrially. It’s high in Omega-3’s, beta carotene, alpha-linoleic acid, and all sorts of other goodies. Of course, we also make sure to get our veggies.
    We also eat a LOT of eggs… the most versatile, economical animal protien out there!

    Like

  25. Luisa Avatar

    Lucky you – it sounds like you have a fantastic set-up with regards to sourcing meat!

    Like

  26. Jill Avatar
    Jill

    I think that’s probably true. I just wish it would end soon!

    Like

  27. Luisa Avatar

    Oh, I hear you, sister. I’ve started taking 400 mg of magnesium before bedtime; I read that that helps. And so far, it hasn’t hurt! Hang in there.

    Like

  28. Rachel Avatar

    Wow, worlds collide: I’ve been reading your blog for years (first comment, though, which is ridiculous) and I started experimenting with the Paleo idea about a year ago. Pretty shocked to revisit here and see you’ve been experimenting, too!
    For me, the health benefits justify living without grains/sugar/processed food for the majority of the time. Some cost-effective options for meat on Paleo include offal, “little greasy fish” (as Michael Pollan calls them) such as sardines, etc. and eggs. Beef and pork are splurges for me, and as for the unsustainable aspect… one of the above comments made me chuckle: “you’d really have to find a trusted source for organic, grass fed meat – otherwise I’d fear that it does more harm than good.” Oh, NO! Finding and supporting local farmers raising animals humanely is so arduous, let’s give up the idea completely. wink
    Just some thoughts!

    Like

  29. Alex Avatar

    I recently started a diet called LCHF (low carb high fat)where you cut out all grains, sugar and legumes, however it works on the premis that fat is good for you. I have been on it for 2 monhts – in the beginning I was skeptical, but now I can’t imagine going back to my normal ‘balanced’ wholegrain diet. As it is low carb high fat NOT low carb high protein…you are not increasing your protein consumption, but upping your veggies and dairy! You should look into it if you are feeling better after your one month Wole30 challenge!

    Like

  30. Ariana {And Here We Are...} Avatar

    Hi Luisa, I thought I’d just stop by and add my 2¢ about affording a modified diet… My family has been eating a paleo-type diet for nearly 3 years, and I have been working on ways to make it affordable. We live in the UK, where food is kind of expensive (we were in Germany when we started, and it was so much easier there!) I try to avoid shopping at the supermarket as much as possible, and have a few ways that shop “outside the box.” I wrote a whole post about it here: http://and-here-we-are.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/how-we-buy-our-food-without-going-to.html
    I love that you did the whole 30, and that it was a good experience for you.
    I hope this is helpful!

    Like

  31. Amanda Avatar
    Amanda

    So glad you made it through! I had a pretty similar experience with the Whole 30 and am now doing a modified version of Paleo. Mostly modified to reduce the amount of meat we’re eating and substitute that with bushels of vegetables. We manage to do this because of two main things: Costco and farm stands. Both of those are much easier to do here in Central California than in Germany! From Costco we get all our protein. They don’t have a huge selection of organic meat, so we rotate through the same 4 cuts pretty regularly (special cuts come from Whole Foods, which adds up quickly). Almost all our produce comes from local growers, mostly organic and all very inexpensive, but I realize we’re pretty spoiled living where we do.
    I still cheat (all the time) but try to stay close to the path at home. Since adopting this eating style I’ve managed to rid myself of daily headaches and that afternoon slump. But, every body works differently and you just have to figure out what works best for you!

    Like

  32. lexan Avatar
    lexan

    homemade beef broth post? please???? cold winters in vermont will be here sooner than i know it!

    Like

  33. Camilla @ Something Is Done Avatar

    Thanks for saying it, Kristine! It’s A LOT OF COOKING! Especially when you have a newborn on your hands, how do people find time to cook all that food? I did a Whole30 and I was HUNGRY. ALL. THE. TIME. And I couldn’t just grab a granola bar or a sandwich to ease me through the day. I had to literally cook some chicken or something. I felt like I was overly relying on nuts, bananas and avocados to get me through…which I don’t think is healthy either! I wouldn’t mind paying more for food but to me my time is worth more than money.

    Like

  34. Adri Avatar
    Adri

    I’m glad I found this post. I’ve done a Whole30 and finished about a month ago. It was a fantastic experience. Lost weight, felt great and made my peace with food (after years of struggle, with about 3284932 diets on my record). The problem is I love food and cooking. All foods. Not just “Whole30-compliant”. But I also want to keep feeling great as I was during the experiment and don’t want to come back to my old food relationship issues. Until now I haven’t been able to find a middle ground between the two things and this has been quite hard to manage. It’s all about balance, so they say, but I don’t seem to be able to ever find mine! (sigh) Thanks for sharing your experience.

    Like

Leave a comment