Roasted chicken with lemon and oregano

Every so often a little recipe comes along that is just a sheer stroke of brilliance. I love recipes like that. I live for recipes like that. The most recent one to make me do a double-take of glee is this one, from Bon Appetit's December 2012 issue (and shot by my friend, Brian Ferry!)

Okay, so you know how most chicken recipes make you first brown the chicken and then remove it from the pan to do a bunch of other stuff, then you have to put the chicken back in and yadda yadda yadda, it's done? I don't know why they bug me so much, but these kinds of recipes do.

Actually, maybe I do know why:

1. I am lazy (but you already knew this).

2. Mess, mess, messy. I dislike spattering cooking fat. 

And 3. Okay, fine, in addition to being lazy, I am also impatient and never brown the chicken long enough, so it's always a little flabby instead of perfectly crisp and wonderful.

This recipe, the darling thing, is all about making sure that the skin never veers anywhere even close to flabby. What you do is put the chicken, skin-side down, in a pan with a little bit of oil and then let it cook for a good long while without touching it, over medium heat, so that the fat renders out, slowly crispening and crispening the chicken skin (yes, I did just make that word up).

Pan-roasting chicken legs

As it cooks, you can periodically get rid of the cooking fat, if too much of it renders out, but that actually never happened to my chicken. Once the chicken is halfway done, you throw in a whole bunch of lemon slices and stick the whole pan in a hot oven, where the lemons soften and the chicken roasts until the skin is perfectly crisp and of a deeply lacquered loveliness.

How lovely? SO LOVELY:

Roasted chicken legs

Then, all that's left to do is to remove that lovely chicken to a plate and scrape a bunch of different things (garlic, minced onion or shallot and oregano – the recipe calls for fresh, but I used dried and it was fine) into the pan that you cook on the stove top for a little while. In goes wine and broth, or just broth, if you'd prefer (which is what I did) and then you reduce this to a nice, saucy consistency and pour it over your lovely chicken and eat right away because oh my goodness it smells so good you simply cannot wait another second no sirree bob.

Lemon oregano sauce

The lemons mellow and sweeten in the cooking process, and the soft lemons and velvety sauce contrast beautifully with the shatteringly crisp chicken skin. This was seriously delectable chicken, people. I'll never brown a piece of chicken any other way again.

(Note: The original recipe calls for deboned chicken thighs but I made it with bone-in chicken legs, cut through at the joint, and just added a few minutes onto all the cooking times.)

Roasted Chicken Legs with Lemon and Oregano
Adapted from Bon Appetit
Serves 3 to 4

1 lemon
4
large or 8 small skin-on, bone-in chicken legs, cut in two
Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper

1 tablespoon
olive oil

3
sprigs oregano

1
small onion, minced

1 small
garlic clove, minced

1/8
teaspoon crushed red pepper flakes

1/4
cup dry white wine (such as Sauvignon Blanc)
, optional
1/2 to 3/4
cup low-sodium chicken broth (larger amount if not using wine)

1. Heat oven to 425°. Very thinly slice half of lemon; discard any seeds. Cut remaining lemon half into 2 wedges. Season chicken thighs with salt and pepper.

2. Coat a large room-temperature skillet with the oil. Add chicken, skin side down. Place skillet over medium heat and cook, letting skin render and brown, until chicken is cooked halfway through, about 10 minutes. If there is a lot of fat in the pan, pour off the excess fat to maintain a thin coating in pan.

3. Scatter half of lemon slices over and between chicken. Transfer skillet to oven, leaving chicken skin side down. Roast until chicken is cooked through, skin is crisp, and lemon slices on bottom of skillet are caramelized, about 15 minutes.

4. Transfer chicken pieces, skin side up, and some of the lemon slices from bottom of skillet to a warm platter. (Leave a few softened lemon slices in the skillet.) Return skillet to medium heat. Add oregano sprigs, shallot, garlic, and red pepper flakes; cook, stirring frequently, until fragrant, about 1 minute.

5. Remove skillet from heat. If using, add wine; cook over medium heat until reduced by half, 1-2 minutes. Add broth; cook until reduced and thickened, 5 to 6 minutes. Squeeze 1 lemon wedge over and season sauce with salt, pepper, and juice from remaining lemon wedge, if desired. Return chicken to skillet, skin side up, to rewarm. Serve topped with caramelized lemon slices.

Posted in , ,

31 responses to “Bon Appetit’s Roasted Chicken Legs with Lemon and Oregano”

  1. Wendy Avatar
    Wendy

    Are there really people in this world who put one-half of a garlic clove into dishes? I mean, really? Color me dubious. That aside, this sounds tasty and looks easy. Thank you.

    Like

  2. Charlotte Avatar

    How did I miss this recipe? It looks divine and the answer to my dinner question this week – how to cook the chicken thighs that are waiting for dinner inspiration. Thanks!

    Like

  3. Luisa Avatar

    Recipe edited. Better now? 😉

    Like

  4. Mary Avatar
    Mary

    I know I’m showing my ignorance here, but my honey doesn’t like dark meat. Will this work (or how would I modify it) for chicken breasts?
    Personally I’m salivating at the recipe as is!

    Like

  5. Luisa Avatar

    My honey doesn’t either – so I just made it for myself! 🙂 The problem with white meat is that it dries out so easily. I’m not sure that you’ll get particularly juicy breast meat with the method here, even if you cut down on the cooking time. But it’s worth trying, I guess? I’d just lop a few minutes off each of the steps and definitely use bone-in chicken breasts. I think. Good luck!

    Like

  6. Leslie k Avatar
    Leslie k

    umm, wondering if I could use preserved lemons in this recipe?

    Like

  7. Stephanie Avatar

    This looks so good! I just encountered the whole flabby chicken issue with a new recipe I made on Saturday night. Even after initially browning the skin, it simmered in this sauce and managed to be overcooked and oddly soft, with skin like a boiled onion. (I must have a special talent, I know.) The leftovers are sitting in the fridge, looking at me reproachfully.
    Your recipe looks much more foolproof. After all, if you’re going to cook chicken with the skin on, it better be crisp and tasty! I will be trying this soon . . .

    Like

  8. Emily Avatar

    I have been making this recipe constantly for a few months – absolutely a new favorite. I have the butcher debone the chicken thighs and they are SO good.

    Like

  9. ellie Avatar
    ellie

    Hi Luisa,
    This looks delicious and I will also attempt it with white meat (not a fan of the darker meat either!)
    I believe you are still on the Whole30 program and I thought I would recommend trying Big Stuff BBQ at Markthalle 9 in Kreuzberg. It is certainly not the best BBQ but is very good for Berlin. Also.. tons of meat! You can get a platter and perhaps ask to swap the potatoes for more sauerkraut. It may feel like a naughty treat that is still playing by the rules! Although, if you want to break the rules, I strongly recommend the cake stand in Markthalle 9 for a slice of the Lemon Cloudcake (Wolketorten Zitrone). It blew my mind!
    Best of luck,
    Ellie

    Like

  10. Sylee Avatar

    Oh Ellie, the Cloudcake is a thing of wonder!
    Meanwhile, Luisa, oh boy, that chicken.

    Like

  11. Julia @ Julia Bailey Wine Avatar

    This looks so delicious! I so think that bone in is the way forward – so much better flavour!
    And very pretty plates too 🙂

    Like

  12. Veronica Avatar
    Veronica

    Oh Luisa I do so love your blog, and your recipes! – The way you present them (in all senses of the word). So glad too, for y’all, about Max’s new job.
    My daughter spent a week in Germany on exchange, and came home with Spatzle (having problems with the umlaut). I’d really like to do it justice – have you any ideas?
    Kind regards from CalmKiwi in Amsterdam,
    Veronica

    Like

  13. Caroline Comerford Avatar

    Holy, moly. This might be the best chicken I’ve ever made. And so quick!

    Like

  14. Amanda Avatar

    How did you know!? I’ve just gotten the hang of cooking chicken pieces at all without drying them out–but can only ever do them plain. Because I, too, am lazy. Can hardly wait for market day to get my hands on some thighs. No, wait, that sounded weird… Anyway, thanks!

    Like

  15. Luisa Avatar

    Don’t see why not – try them out!

    Like

  16. Luisa Avatar

    Have heard good things about Big Stuff!

    Like

  17. anna@annamayeveryday Avatar

    I am not keen on browning things either, I end up smelling like a frying pan. This looks delicious, will give it a go.

    Like

  18. Kylee Avatar
    Kylee

    I made this last night and it was completely delicious, and really easy. I’m very pregnant with twins and thought I had lost my cooking mojo, but thanks to this recipe I have it back! My husband added it to the must have again list 🙂 Thank you!

    Like

  19. mhs Avatar
    mhs

    @veronica
    Just melt some butter in a nonstick pan and fry the spätzle over until a little crisp. Nice sidedish with meat, sauce and veggies.
    You may layer them in a buttered overproof dish with grated cheese, such as emmentaler, mountain cheese, comté et al. and put them in a preheated oven until the cheese has melted. I personally add some grated vegetables such as zucchini as I find pure Kässpätzle too rich.

    Like

  20. Kate Avatar
    Kate

    Thank you, thank you, thank you!! Just made this for mother’s day dinner and it was a huge hit. My 15 month old gobbled it up, too! This will definitely enter into heavy rotation in this house. Love it!

    Like

  21. Laurie Avatar

    I love this recipie, and I swear I’ve been making it every other week since that issue of bon Appetit came out. I’ve made it with bone in, skin on split chicken breasts, and thought it was just as good!

    Like

  22. Luisa Avatar

    Spätzle seem complicated, but are actually pretty easy – it’s just about working quickly. Do you need a recipe or are you wondering about the method?

    Like

  23. Roxy Avatar

    After reading this recipe, and looking at the mouth-watering pictures, it’s easy to understand why the last one shows an absence of left-overs. This one I will have to try ASAP.

    Like

  24. Theodore Avatar

    Thank you for the great looking recipe. I also believe that cooking the the bone in adds greatly to the flavor. I will have to print it off and try it this weekend.

    Like

  25. Eileen @ Phoenix Helix Avatar

    I love skillet to oven recipes. I cook steak and pork chops this way now, too. Comes out delicious (and fast) every time.

    Like

  26. shrazzi Avatar

    I had the same thought. If cooking with preserved lemons, would you need to stick them in half-way through, since they don’t need to be caramelized?

    Like

  27. shrazzi Avatar

    No, I was totally wrong. Preserved lemons taste incredible caramelized! This was the best chicken we’ve had in a long time.

    Like

  28. Gerry Avatar
    Gerry

    Just wondering if this recipe can be made a day ahead and reheated the next day without losing any of its goodness?
    Thank you.

    Like

  29. Luisa Avatar

    You’d lose the crisp skin, which is sort of the whole point of the recipe… If you don’t mind that, though, the rest would be delicious!

    Like

  30. helpigottacook@gmail.com Avatar

    You could try brining the chicken breasts to put a little moisture in them.

    Like

  31. Melissa Avatar
    Melissa

    Made this tonight. Was absolutely delicious! I used chicken legs. Love the skillet to oven. My 3 yr old gobbled up two chicken legs lol. Will definitely make again! I wanted to bathe in that sauce haha

    Like

Leave a comment