DSC_2197

I know what you're thinking. You're thinking, girl, of course you're posting about cabbage soup. It's January 6th, for Pete's sake, and we're all supposed to be on the New Year, New You! plan. You know, the one in which, just two weeks after Christmas, you swear to get up early each morning to sweat at the gym, eat whole-grain hot cereal for breakfast and drink nothing but green tea and think soothing thoughts about everything and everyone for at least, shall we say, two weeks before collapsing in a heap and eating an entire bag of Cape Cod potato chips for dinner in front of the television.

But no! You're wrong! That's not at all why I'm posting about cabbage soup. Sure, cabbage is good for you, all packed with vitamin C and flavonoids (or maybe it was antioxidants? Whatever it was, it's not goose fat or almond paste, thank Jeebus, because I can't look at either right now without wincing.). But take a closer look: There's ketchup in this soup, people. Ketchup. KETCH-UP. And brown sugar. And you're supposed to dollop sour cream on top. Okay? No diet soup here, no sirree, I don't think so.

It's not that I'm not into New Year's resolutions. Last year I made a bang-up list (uh, yes, drinking more green tea was on there, but so was stuff like "get a pedicure"and "buy a standmixer" (got the former, not the latter)). By February, though, it devolved into a to-do list of wedding-related errands and things like "open a German credit card" and "go to the cemetery in Kassel" and before too long, I hied that list of resolutions to the curb.

This year, I was too busy to make a list. I wanted to enjoy every blessed minute that Max was here over the holidays (two whole weeks!) and we had our very first Christmas at home (which has been one of my life goals since I was a small child – check!), replete with a candle-lit tree that the poor man lugged home the day before Christmas Eve and that is still perfuming our living room almost two weeks later. (Before you throw out your Christmas tree, have you seen this?)

Plus, I was sort of consumed with thoughts about the book, you know, and this other thing that has been occupying whatever spare part of my mind I've still got left (it's not much) (good grief, the parentheses in this post are multiplying like bacteria) (more on that, the other thing, not the parenthesiitis, in a minute)).

So there's no official list of virtuous resolutions this year. In fact, a few days ago I even canceled my gym membership (if you must know, it's because my gym stinks – well, figuratively, not literally). I was pretty sure the gods of January were going to smite me for doing such a profane thing, but miraculously I made it home in one piece. Being virtuous for a few weeks feels like a waste of time when I've got so much more in my lap right now. Instead I've decided to do things like "use up the vegetables languishing in the fridge instead of letting them calcify" or "embrace self-indulgence every once in a while, you mean old hag, you" and I've also decided I don't need a pretty list doodled on good paper to do that, either.

DSC_2211

Which leads me back to the ketchup soup. The other night, I had nothing but three moldy carrots, half a green cabbage and several lemons so dried out you could have cracked them like eggs skulking around my fridge. The carrots especially were starting to seriously irritate me. Carrot frittata? I wondered as I stared at this motley crew. Lemon sandwiches? Cabbage spaghetti? No, no and no.

Instead I vaguely remembered reading something about a cabbage soup, but who knows when, my mind is a sieve these days. A few clicks later and there was Bess Feigenbaum's Cabbage Soup staring back at me from the computer screen. As I scrolled through the ingredient list, I felt more and more triumphant. I had everything I needed, everything except for the raisins which I didn't want in my soup anyway, no way, no how. How perfect was this?

Also, as I might have already mentioned, there was ketchup in this soup. KETCHUP. In the soup. People. When I saw that, I scrambled to the kitchen so fast that dust clouds kicked up under my feet.

To start, you make a simple tomato sauce base, really – sautéeing onions and garlic in olive oil, adding sliced carrots and canned tomatoes and tomato paste. But then you throw in a bay leaf and ketchup and brown sugar (and not a small amount either, though I confess to halving the sugar, because I just couldn't bring myself to use the full amount, not with a whole half-cup of ketchup in the soup to boot) and when this has cooked for about twenty minutes you render it coarsely mashed or puréed, depending on your taste, and then you add an enormous amount of sliced cabbage and water and what seems like far too much lemon juice, but do not skimp, please, because the lemon juice is crucial.

This whole messy concoction, cabbage strips sticking every which way, then gets cooked until it's good and silky. Two hours at least. I had a bowl after an hour and I don't advise you do the same. You want the cabbage to go limp and soft, really soft. Practically melting. And you want all those crazy flavors to meld into something a little less nuts (don't worry, the ketchup does blend into the background). (Also, it feeds a blessed multitude, so invite your whole block over for dinner or else be prepared to eat this for days.)

A dollop of something cool and creamy on top is sort of crucial when you serve the soup. Otherwise it could err a little on the sweet-and-strange side. You could go for sour cream or plain yogurt, if you were feeling virtuous (or if that's all you had in the house, ahem). But don't skip this bit either. You want that final hit of bracing acidity and smoothing lactic power, brightening the coldest and darkest of winter days.

My father arrived this morning for a two-week visit and I served this to him for lunch, along with a slice of dark bread. (He always eats a slice of buttered dark bread when he gets off the airplane in Berlin and then, with a deep sigh, tells me how good it tastes.) (Also, he is a cabbage man, if you know what I mean. Never met a cabbage he didn't like.) He said it tasted like the stuffed cabbage his mother used to make, which is exactly the point, according to Zoe Feigenbaum (Bess was Zoe's grandmother and Bess's stuffed cabbage was the inspiration for the soup.)

But wait! We're not done yet! There's still that thing I have to tell you about, the thing I mentioned just above. I have been wracking my mind for days (weeks! months!), trying to figure out a good way to tell you all, my darling readers, my friends who I've never met, and I keep on coming up empty. It's just too big, I guess, too good.

So. You know how I said I was hiding from you because I was so wrapped up in the book and all the craziness that goes along with the final weeks of revisions and writing? Well. Um. I might not have been telling you the whole, entire truth. Technically.

You see, that other something I mentioned above, well, it's not just a little thing, though, actually, it is pretty little. With wee legs and arms and delicious cheeks to nibble on soon and a thumpy, steady heartbeat and the cutest little profile I ever did see, already turning 2012 into the best year of my life, hands down, without a doubt, book or no book.

What I'm trying to say is, that thing occupying whatever space I've got left in my mind and taking up all the space in my belly is our baby. Our baby! A boy, our son, due in June. This June! Our baby! Our son!

DSC_2172

Bess Feigenbaum's Cabbage Soup
Original recipe here
Serves 8

2 tablespoons olive oil
2 tablespoons chopped garlic
1 cup chopped onion
1 cup peeled and sliced carrots
1 28-ounce can plum tomatoes
1 cup tomato paste
1/2 cup tomato ketchup
1/4 cup dark brown sugar
1 bay leaf
1/2 cup lemon juice
3 pounds green cabbage, approximately half of one large head (tough outer leaves, core and ribs removed), sliced into 1/4-inch-wide strips
1/2 cup golden raisins (optional)
Fresh ground black pepper
Sour cream or plain yogurt

1. In a large pot over medium-low heat, heat olive oil and add garlic. Cook, stirring, until garlic is tender but not browned, about 2 minutes. Add onion and sauté until translucent. Add 3 cups water, carrots, tomatoes and purée, tomato paste, ketchup, brown sugar and bay leaf. Simmer for 10 minutes, then crush the tomatoes with a fork or wooden spoon. Continue to simmer until carrots are tender, about 10 minutes. Discard bay leaf. 

 2. Using an immersion blender, process mixture until it is coarse, not puréed. Add lemon juice, cabbage strips and 3 additional cups water. Place over medium-high heat and cook at a lively simmer until cabbage is meltingly soft, about 2 hours. Add water to thin to desired consistency. Ten minutes before serving, stir in raisins and a few twists of black pepper. Garnish each serving with a dollop of sour cream or yogurt.

Posted in , ,

173 responses to “Bess Feigenbaum’s Cabbage Soup”

  1. Renae Avatar
    Renae

    Congratulations!! Your adventure has already begun 🙂
    I clipped this soup recipe from NYT and have made it several times – love it! The combination of flavors is so unexpected and delicious.

    Like

  2. Hannah Grace Avatar
    Hannah Grace

    Congratulations Luisa!
    Like quite a few of the above I’ve been a silent reader of your blogs for a long long time, they never fail to make me (and my tummy!) smile! Im struggling through a uni dissertation at the moment and i thought I’d have one quick visit here before starting for the afternoon, and now I’m going to start work with a big grin on my face as a result!
    So happy for you both, take care and thank you:) x

    Like

  3. multikulinaria Avatar

    How wonderful and exciting. I love the image. Congratulations! I wish I could have had that joy too…

    Like

  4. Victoria Avatar

    Luisa, that’s the best news ever.
    Congratulations!
    I am thrilled that you are living happily ever after!
    Happy New Year. There’s no doubt that 2012 will be the best one yet.
    xoxo

    Like

  5. Jess@My Pickles and Jams Avatar

    Congratulations too! Funny cabbages aseem to be a theme. I’ve been laying down some sauerkraut this week.

    Like

  6. Charlotte Avatar

    Oh Luisa! The best news! Congratulations! (and boys are the BEST – not that I’m biased or anything as our boy approaches 6 (gack)). You can see I’m also a fan of parenthesis. Thanks for this cabbage soup – I have cabbage and carrots and lemons lurking in my veg drawer – it must be fate. Keep well.

    Like

  7. Sara Avatar
    Sara

    Yay! Congratulations!

    Like

  8. Adina Paun Avatar
    Adina Paun

    Dear Louisa,
    All the best to you and yours for this year, and may you enjoy the wonderful journey that lies in front of you- although I am sure you will make the most of it.
    I have wanted to thank you for a long time for the wonderful gift that you gave me- great recipes and courage in the kitchen!- so allow me to give something from my own experience: as a lactation consultant, I always advise pregnant women to speak to someone about breast feeding before the birth- knowing little things makes everything so much easier.
    All the best and congratulations again,
    Adina

    Like

  9. Janet Avatar
    Janet

    Awwwwww! Congratulations! Wishing you all the best!

    Like

  10. Stephanie Avatar

    Congratlations and Happy New Year! Thank you for a beautiful post. i just may try this soup, ketchup and all.

    Like

  11. Terri Avatar
    Terri

    Cried when you told us you were getting married, crying that you are pregnant!!! And you don’t know me from a hole in the ground!! Congrats, my friend. As the mother of a 6 and 4 year old, I know what you are in for. The best and hardest time of your life. So happy for you and Max. Congratulations.

    Like

  12. cory @ eat and {relish} Avatar

    that is such amazing news for a new year! even better than green tea or a stand mixer 🙂 congratulations.
    thanks for outlining this soup so well – without the encouragement, i never would have thought to try it. happy 2012!

    Like

  13. Emily Avatar

    Holy smokes!!!!! Congratulations Luisa!!! That is such happy news! You make me grin.

    Like

  14. Molly Avatar

    oh, LUISA!!!! you dog, you!!!
    oh, i am beyond thrilled. BEYOND THRILLED!!!! just, smitten, giddy, happy for you and max, beyond measure.
    my own wee one is calling after a bedtime story, but just one more time, HOOT!!!! And happy 2012!!

    Like

  15. Phoo-d Avatar

    What incredible news! Congratulations to both of you! Our first is now 10 months old and we have loved the entire experience. You are in for a joy-filled ride!

    Like

  16. Rhonda Avatar

    Your post made me laugh, I totally sympathized with your dilemma to make something out of practically nothing. The soup sounds wonderful, then I had to smile at your news, many congratulations!

    Like

  17. twoblueshoes Avatar

    Ha ha! BRILLIANT! Wonderful news. It is the hardest and best thing ever, ever. Love.

    Like

  18. Bec Avatar

    Congratulations! This time last year I, too, was expecting a little one. And he is here in all is beautiful glory. It’s a wonderful thing! Its an exhausting, exhilarating, confusing & joyous thing too. Very joyous!! Enjoy every second (what am I saying, of course you will!).

    Like

  19. Jocelyn Z Avatar
    Jocelyn Z

    I come to your site all the time, but I’ve never commented before – but how can I hold back now? I’M DUE IN JUNE, TOO!
    (And I’ve just recently gotten my appetite back. Holy wow, those first three months of being queasy and not knowing my own taste-buds sucked).

    Like

  20. Taylor Avatar
    Taylor

    Congratulations! What a wonderful thing to look forward to in 2012. 🙂 And thanks for another wonderful recipe!

    Like

  21. Julia of Randomly Yours, Julia Avatar

    If you hadn’t put the part about your baby last, none of us would have read about cabbage soup, ketchup or no ketchup.
    Congratulations! What a year this will be!

    Like

  22. David Avatar
    David

    What is up with the gyms here? I don’t like gyms all that much to begin with – but sheesh, considering the sky-high membership prices (and the focus on hygiene), you would think they would be a lot cleaner than they are.

    Like

  23. Kate Avatar
    Kate

    What beautiful news! Congratulations!

    Like

  24. Anna Avatar
    Anna

    A book and a baby! 2012 is HUGE for you!!! All the best/ Auguroni/ Herzlichen Glueckwunsch –

    Like

  25. kristin Avatar

    Luisa–Congratulations!!! That is so exciting! I look forward to reading more about your pregnancy and soon after reading about your son!
    On another note, I celebrated a German Christmas too! I was with my sister-in-law’s family who is German and our tree was complete with lit candles and all. Also lots and lots of German food.
    Sounds like all is well with you. Here’s to 2012 continuing its greatness!
    -Kristin

    Like

  26. sylvie Avatar

    Congratulations! What an exciting year 2012 is going to be for you. Oh, and I like the dea of that soup, too.

    Like

  27. Katerina Avatar
    Katerina

    Brava Luisa!!! I’m due in July with my second – I have been a silent reader for years but I’m commenting for the first time. You cannot imagine the love you will feel, I am so so pleased for you and Max. Best wishes for 2012.

    Like

  28. Ariana {And Here We Are...} Avatar

    Such wonderful news! Congratulations, and just enjoy this time of preparing, nurturing and waiting.

    Like

  29. art and lemons Avatar

    Luisa, How wonderful and congrats to you both! Wishing I had some cabbage to go with my wimpy carrots and ketchup…

    Like

  30. Kristine in Santa Barbara Avatar
    Kristine in Santa Barbara

    Congrats! My own Luisa is now 21 and her sister Gabi 17. Motherhood was and is still my best gig to date. I guessed the news would be coming from your last post….you said your clothes didn’t fit and you were wild-eyed. That didn’t sound entirely deadline related. You will love being a mother.
    I made the soup this afternoon. I was intrigued by a soup that might be reminiscent of stuffed cabbage without the all-day commitment. Wonderful! I made a half batch and used my little pressure cooker, so it only took 15 minutes instead of two hours to get the melting cabbage. I did cut the sugar in half, knowing that was too sweet for me, but followed the rest of the recipe (no raisins for me either). Used whole milk greek yogurt as a topping. It’s borcht-y and cabbage roll-y. Yum!

    Like

  31. Annie Avatar
    Annie

    Congratulations! Such wonderful news. I have a little boy of my own kicking around in my belly, due to arrive in May. And, based on my limited and totally subjective experience of having an almost-two-year-old, I’ve got to say you’re in for a marvelous adventure.

    Like

  32. Adrienne Avatar

    Hooray! I had a bit of a hunch when you disappeared for a bit, and I’m just thrilled for you. Many, many congratulations 🙂

    Like

  33. Melinda Avatar

    Congratulations! Made this soup tonight and my Belarusian husband said, “Tastes like home.” High praise! Thanks for sharing.

    Like

  34. Debby Avatar
    Debby

    Congratulations!

    Like

  35. kickpleat Avatar

    Congratulations Luisa!!!! Woweee! As for the cabbage + ketchup soup, I’m in. Happiness abounds 🙂

    Like

  36. Honeybee Avatar
    Honeybee

    Congratulations!!! I’m so happy for you!! What an exciting year this is going to be! All the best.

    Like

  37. emiglia Avatar

    Ahh!! Baby! Congratulations, Luisa!

    Like

  38. Tamsin Avatar

    Congratulations! What wonderful news!

    Like

  39. Selkie Avatar
    Selkie

    My son is traveling in India with his love, who have just told me I am to be a first time Grandma in July! Such happiness, for you, for them, for the babies! A sure sign of optimism, hope, and love! All best ……

    Like

  40. TheKitchenWitch Avatar

    I was going to gag if you actually added raisins to the soup. I like weird, but raisins in soup is even too weird for me!
    But what am I blabbing on about? Congrats, Luisa! I’m thrilled for you.

    Like

  41. Valerie Avatar
    Valerie

    Oh Luisa, such wonderful news! I already had a feelding when I read your last post… Huge congratulations to you and Max from a very happy and besotted mama of an 11-months old boy.
    Hugs from Brussels, Valerie

    Like

  42. emily Avatar

    Congratulations! What wonderful news, and I agree that that little boy will make 2012 a wondrous year for sure.

    Like

  43. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Congratulations! Such wonderful news!

    Like

  44. Robin Avatar

    That photo brought some happy tears to my eyes! Congratulations and hope you are feeling good!

    Like

  45. laura k Avatar

    Congratulations! What wonderful news…and what a lucky, lucky boy.

    Like

  46. Sonja Avatar
    Sonja

    Herzlichen Glückwunsch, Luisa!
    Alles Gute für euch drei (what a reason to delurk!)

    Like

  47. Evy Avatar
    Evy

    Congratulations, Wednesday Chef! I have been reading you for well over a year–you are my favorite food blog by far.

    Like

  48. Anne K Avatar
    Anne K

    Congratulations! What an exciting year 2012 will be!

    Like

  49. Darina Avatar

    Congratulations on your fantastic news. All the best.

    Like

  50. terry johnson Avatar
    terry johnson

    I am another fan who has never commented but the adorable baby bump has my fingers typing! Congratulations and how Lovely for you and your husband!

    Like

Leave a reply to Veronica Cancel reply