Dsc_5142

I am, shall we say, a little distracted these days. I'm leaving for Germany in a little less than three days. And I'm not coming back until the first days of January. That's the longest vacation I've taken in a good bit and I'm sort of agog at the prospect of so much (badly-needed) time off. Time to see old friends, show more bits and pieces of Berlin to Ben, figure out where and when we're getting married, have my mom cook me dinner, spend time with my family, literal and figurative, and simply be in my hometown. I've missed it so much this year that Heimweh turned into a perpetual ache in my chest. I'm ready to be rid of that.

And though I'm not sure if this is entirely related to my distraction, my luck in the kitchen lately has been abysmal. Almost funnily so, though if you'd seen me yesterday, attacking an innocent pizza that had soldered itself to the baking stone in less than 25 minutes and was thus burned to an absolute crisp, rendering our casual late-afternoon lunch a blackened, unpleasant mess, you might have handed me a towel to mop my brow and commanded me to go take a walk around the block. Happy to oblige, thanks!

Not to be outdone, there was also a lackluster savory rice pie that I loved when my stepmother made, but that ended up a bland, insipid, tragic waste of Carnaroli rice when attempted in my own kitchen, and the unforgettable pickled endives that had such promise, but were a deeply unpleasant combination of sweetness, bitterness and spice that was not meant to be eaten by anyone, at least not anyone in my home.

Kitchen disasters, please be gone, would you?

But Christmas comes early this year: a holiday dinner tonight with friends, a liquid dinner of cocktails tomorrow, one meal airborne over the Atlantic and then – boom – I'm absolved of the rest of the year's meals. Strangely enough, I'm sort of pleased. I think my kitchen and I need a break. (Oh, except there's this one amazing soup I have to tell you about before I leave…).

I'm bringing my camera cable with me to Europe, since I'm going to be (finally!) documenting the annual Springerle bake-off with my friends Joan and Ann, and Ben's first encounter with a Currywurst (it might not happen, but I'll try – and in any case, after years of loyalty to the stand at Wittenbergplatz, it's time for me to branch out and try Konnopke's. Are there any Berliners out there who want to weigh in?). Then, best of all for you hungry folks, I'll be in Brussels for the last week of my holidays with my family who never fail to introduce me to some kind of stellar food. Last year, I brought back the focaccia di patate; this year, who knows? It will be delicious and I will share it: that is my solemn holiday promise to you.

Oh! And these potatoes! Well, for those of you for whom Christmas is not Christmas without mashed potatoes, and for those of you who find leftover mashed potatoes – formed into patties and fried, for example, or eaten cold from the fridge – to be your own personal nirvana, this is the recipe you must make this year. It is, in a word, insane.

After all, not only is there browned butter and fried sage (dreamy!) but there is Greek yogurt, too. Luscious, I tell you, and pleasingly different without being weird. Also, it makes mountains of mashed potatoes. Mountains! That is not an exaggeration. You will be inundated with thick, creamy, tangy, herby mashed potatoes. The good thing is they're so easy to keep eating, day after day. Croquettes, potato soup, shepherd's pie – is there anything that cannot be done with these leftovers? I have yet to find out.

Brown Butter Mashed Potatoes with Sage
Serves 6 to 8 with leftovers

3 pounds baking potatoes, scrubbed, skin on, cut into 1-inch chunks
1/2 cup (1 stick) unsalted butter
24 fresh sage leaves
1 cup whole milk
3/4 cup plain Greek yogurt
1 1/2 teaspoons sea salt
1/2 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper

1. Put the potatoes in a large pot or Dutch oven and cover with cold water by at least half an inch. Cover and bring to a boil over high heat. Lower the heat and simmer until tender, about 15 minutes.

2. While the potatoes are cooking, heat the butter over medium-high heat in a medium skillet. When it begins to foam, add the sage leaves and gently fry until crisp, 2 to 3 minutes. Remove with a slotted spoon, place on a paper towel and reserve. Continue to cook the butter until it's golden brown and nutty, watching so that it doesn't burn, an additional 1 to 2 minutes. Remove from heat and reserve.

3. In a small saucepan, heat the milk over medium-high heat just until hot, careful that the milk does not boil. Remove from heat and reserve in a warm place.

4. Drain the potatoes and place them into a large bowl. Using a masher, mash the potatoes to the desired consistency. Stir in the hot milk, yogurt, salt and pepper and browned butter, making sure to get all the dark butter solids. (Recipe can be prepared to this point a day in advance; refrigerate the potatoes tightly sealed and keep the sage in a tightly sealed container at room temperature.)

5. Garnish with the fried sage and serve. (If you have refrigerated the potatoes, gently reheat the mashed potatoes before serving, thinning if needed with additional milk. Garnish and serve.)

Posted in , , , ,

30 responses to “Amy Scattergood’s Brown Butter Mashed Potatoes with Fried Sage”

  1. Drew Avatar

    Humming “Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht” and wishing you and Ben an early Merry Christmas – whether it’s Christmas Eve or Christmas morning. Nothing beats a northern European Christmas.
    Here’s hoping Christmas brings you springerle, currywurst and last but not least: braised cabbage. (It’s not really Christmas without it.)

    Like

  2. BF Avatar

    enjoy your travels! can’t wait to see some photos.

    Like

  3. Phoo-D Avatar

    Enjoy the needed break! Hopefully you’ll come back rested with your cooking mojo firmly restored!
    Phoo-D

    Like

  4. maggie Avatar

    I, too, felt the brown butter and sage urge this week, but wasn’t sure whether to fry the sage first, and remove it, or throw in halfway through and hope the timing worked out for the butter browning. I bet your way is better.
    Happy holidays! Enjoy your break!

    Like

  5. Leah Avatar
    Leah

    if you go to Konnopke’s, call me! that’s right under our Ubahn station – ah the ambience; the pigeons. Other people swear by Curry 36 on Mehringdamm and there is always a huge crowd of people there. Bis gleich!

    Like

  6. jenny Avatar
    jenny

    excuse me, but did someone say fried sage? I can be all too easily manipulated with fried sage.
    thanks for another wonderful year of recipes and wit. safe travels to you, and merry christmas!

    Like

  7. Adrienne Avatar

    Oh, have such a great time!! And maybe be patient with Ben on the currywurst – it sounds… like an acquired taste. Happy holidays 🙂

    Like

  8. Dana McCauley Avatar

    Yum – brown butter has such a nice deep round flavour.
    Happy Holidays to you!

    Like

  9. kickpleat Avatar

    tis the season for brown butter! in mashed potatoes? sounds delicious. and your trip? envious. i love berlin and loved the fries at witty’s!! i also had the best falafel plate at a little mediterranean restaurant in fredrickshain just down the street from a cute cupcake shop. sigh. have a great trip!

    Like

  10. Lisa Avatar

    Luisa, you read my mind! I was just looking for a Christmas-worthy potato recipe. This looks so good.
    Happy and safe travels!
    Lisa

    Like

  11. Biz Avatar

    Oh my that looks good! I’ve had fried rosemary, but not fried sage – this will go on my list of things to make!
    Happy Monday!

    Like

  12. Susannah Avatar

    These potatoes look delicious but I must say that the Currywurst is what I’m really interested in now! Looks like it would make a good Christmas Eve lunch.

    Like

  13. Magnolia Avatar
    Magnolia

    Hi Luisa,
    Love your blog. I’ve been making (or assisting in making) springerles here in the US my whole life. My molds were brought over by my great (great?) grandmother. Looking forward to seeing your photos of these lovely cookies…

    Like

  14. Lia Avatar

    Luisa,
    Have a great trip! I can’t wait till I can go to Berlin some day and get all your food recs. Maybe next year!

    Like

  15. Honeybee Avatar

    I’m completely intrigued with the use of greek yoghurt. Thank you for the recipe. Is that right that the potatoes are not peeled after cooking? How does the skin behave when mashed?
    Fröhliche Weihnachten und ein gutes neues Jahr! Enjoy your break!

    Like

  16. ovenhaven Avatar

    Oh that does look very heavenly. Sorry to hear about all the kitchen mishaps. Berlin must be calling out to you to come sooner! 😛 Have fun going back to your hometown! 🙂

    Like

  17. Liza Avatar
    Liza

    Definitely Konnopke’s Imbiss, a Currywurst with a Pommes rot/weiss, nothing better than that… To top it just take a few steps down the Kastanienallee and take some pics at the old fashioned Photobooth just in front of the Prater Biergarten there (4 Poses, €2), great bw pics and lots of fun!

    Like

  18. ann Avatar

    Froeliche Weinachten Luisa! Happy travels and best wishes for a happy, healthy New Year to you and yours. Bring us back some currywurst! 😉

    Like

  19. zeta Avatar
    zeta

    I don’t really like Konnopke, I think they are way overhyped and their claim to currywurst-fame is ridiculous – after all, the original currywurst is definitely a West-Berlin-thing. I would go to Curry 36 on Mehringdamm/Gneisenaustraße, Kudamm 103 is great as well (and they have homemade potatoe-salad) and there are quite a few very good stands on Schlosstraße in Steglitz.
    Travel save and have a great time!

    Like

  20. Sara Avatar

    Before Thanksgiving, I was looking for mashed potato recipes. I wish I had seen this one then. Maybe I’ll get started looking for next year.

    Like

  21. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    I have always found Konnopke’s to be disgusting, but that’s just me. Part of the ambience there I think comes from its location, rather than its quality.

    Like

  22. Molly Avatar

    Merry Christmas, my sweet friend! I hope your travels are happy ones – and very, very relaxing. xo

    Like

  23. Leah Avatar

    Well.
    I was all set to come here and echo those lovely sentiments of Molly’s but then all this brown. butter. mashed. potatoes. fried. sage. business got into my head and I’m so sorry, what was I supposed to say?
    Enjoy your much needed holiday vacation, lovely girl. And come back well-rested, with delicious tales to tell. xo

    Like

  24. juliette Avatar

    oh Brussels! I am sure the Berliner Curry Wurst will be wonderful, but there as soft place in my heart (and belly) for Belgium! Last time I was home, Brussels was one long eating fest. The frites on Place Jourdan, the chocolates on Place du Sablon (Marcolini de rigueur), fish and oysters at Scheltema, cusine bourgeoise Aux Armes de Bruxelles, and an unforgettable celery root sandwich au Suisse in front of the old Stock Market building. Enjoy!

    Like

  25. EB Avatar

    Have a wonderful trip!!!

    Like

  26. L*Joy Avatar

    merry family filled christmas and happy holidays.
    I am awaiting pictures to be sure, but (it is not about me) this is your vacation. enjoy it!

    Like

  27. parsnips aplenty Avatar

    I think it’s rather impossible to fail by putting brown butter in anything. I’m sad I never thought of putting it in mashed potatoes before! I’m happier, though, that you have done it. Now I will, and others will, and the world will be a better place.
    Can’t wait to hear about the Springerle bake-off!

    Like

  28. Zarah Maria Avatar

    Happy Holidays Luisa, end enjoy your time off! You’ll be so close 🙂

    Like

  29. yumyummaybud Avatar
    yumyummaybud

    Oh Berlin in summer! Thanks for the memories – now I need to get my hands on the Elderberry syrup…Enjoy the currywurst. I agree Kppe’s is overrated. Have you been to M. Vuong’s in Prenzlauerberg? Heaven in a bowl.

    Like

  30. sponge cake bob Avatar

    you got me with the acid from the yogurt and the nuttiness of the butter.

    Like

Leave a comment