P1100817

(Oh dear. This is awkward. I think I'm going to write this entire post in parentheses. You know, to mitigate the awkwardness. If it's in parentheses, then it's still sort of just a thought in my head and not an entirely un-take-back-able statement. Right? I don't know. Lord help me.)

(So here's what happened. Last week, Russ Parsons published this article in the Los Angeles Times about waffles. Goodness knows we are a wafflefriendly household. And since there is no other waffle more talked about than Marion Cunningham's yeast-raised waffle (am I wrong?), I was quite excited to try my hand at this legendary recipe.)

(You make a batter with active dry yeast and let it ferment overnight in the fridge. But I didn't get started until early Sunday morning – on Saturday, we were too busy looking at apartments out in faraway neighborhoods and getting into arguments about where we should live and how much we should pay and, oh, the joys of New York City living, they really are such a pleasure – so I let the batter ferment on my kitchen counter top for an hour or two instead. It doubled in size and smelled deliciously yeasty and had all these appealing bubbles and a gorgeous foamy top. Very promising, indeed – as was that one place out in Forest Hills, the one I can't stop thinking about and, holy hell, does that mean we should take it, help me, readers, help me.)

(I heated up the waffle iron and we debated the merits of Bak-Kleene versus melted butter, but it turned out that neither was really that necessary. My non-stick waffle iron performed like a champ, spitting out waffles with nary a sticking corner in sight. It was impressive. Less impressive, however, were (gulp, double gulp) the waffles.)

(Did I actually just say that out loud?)

(…)

(For starters, the waffles, while crisp and browned on the bottom, were flabby and a pallid, yellowish hue on top. Also, their insides were a little too batter-y. And lastly, they were buttery to the point of greasiness.)

(We ate the first round in silence, chewing carefully. Ben tentatively ventured that they might not be the best waffles we'd ever made. With the second round, I tried flipping the waffles in the iron in the hopes that the pale, yellow side might get a little toastier. Hardly. With the third and fourth batch, I overfilled the iron, which resulted in the delicate lacy waffle you see in the photograph. The underside, however, still looked totally under-baked. The taste was better now, though, and Ben made the good point that the warm syrup-doused waffles tasted like French toast – it must have been the yeast, I think. I still found them far too buttery for my taste. Unpleasantly heavy, they sat in my stomach while I pondered the impossible.)

(Could it be that I didn't like the world's most beloved waffle? Would anyone still take me seriously after this? What on earth would become of me?)

(It's not really clear. We spent the rest of the day calculating rent budgets and train passes, imagining life in a spacious 2-bedroom apartment with leafy tree-tops instead of air shafts for a view, and weekends spent strolling down the West Side Highway. Which made me think – if there's room in this city for all the different folks we saw out yesterday, there must also be room for li'l ol' yeasted-waffle-disliking me. Right? Oh, pretty please!)

Yeast-Raised Waffles
Makes 16 waffles

1 package active dry yeast
2 cups milk
1/2 cup (1 stick) butter, melted
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon sugar
2 cups flour
2 eggs
1/4 teaspoon baking soda

1. Place one-half cup warm water in a large mixing bowl (the batter will double in volume) and sprinkle in the yeast. When dissolved, stir in the milk, butter, salt, sugar, flour and eggs and beat until smooth and blended. Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and refrigerate overnight.

2. Just before cooking the waffles, beat in the baking soda. The batter will deflate and become about as thin as soft yogurt. Cook the waffles according to the manufacturer's instructions for your waffle maker. Serve with maple syrup.

Posted in ,

46 responses to “Marion Cunningham’s Yeast-Raised Waffles”

  1. Mary Avatar

    (Our waffle iron got a lot of use when we first bought it and then it gathered dust for a couple of years. Now it’s in storage along with the Kitchen Aid mixer and all of the pastry implements -what was I thinking? – tried a lot of different recipes. I think I prefer the Joy of Cooking recipe that Parsons references over the Fannie Farmer/Marion Cunningham one. I guess I’m in good company.)

    Like

  2. Anne Avatar

    (Don’t be embarrassed! We all have foods and recipes like that. For me it’s butternut squash. Such a beautifully colored, wonderfully versatile winter treat…that is way too cloying and chalky for my taste.)
    (Good luck with apartments! I say go for the trees and space. Commuting can be a pain at times, but you get a lot of reading done. Plus you emerge from the toils of Manhattan into a gorgeous, treelined block. It’s truly tension-draining.)

    Like

  3. amy Avatar

    (i was just in forrest hills last night, and it is so pretty but SO FAR!) Move to Brooklyn, far better!

    Like

  4. Leah Avatar

    (Forest Hills, go go!)
    (If only because a) yay trees, b) The Ramones graduated from Forest Hills High and I actually own a FHH t-shirt for that reason, and c) my dad was born in Queens. Plus, sometimes a change of scenery and a bit of room to stretch out give you a new perspective – but you don’t lose out on New York.)

    Like

  5. Stephanie Avatar

    Good luck with the apartment search. It’s a hideous, soul-sucking process and there’s really no way around that.
    I don’t know anything about Forest Hills, but I just made the move to Queens (Sunnyside) myself and I’m really liking it. It feels vibrant and genuine in a way that a lot of the city doesn’t anymore. Plus, the food is fantastic. There are things at the produce stands that I’ve literally never heard of and I’ve been around the produce block once or twice.

    Like

  6. Sharon Avatar
    Sharon

    Can’t comment about the waffles, but Forest Hills is awesome, we just moved from there and I miss it so. You must try the blintzes and pierogies at Just Like Mothers, the Polish restaurant on QB.

    Like

  7. Anne Avatar

    I always appreciate your honesty and this post is a great example. Who cares if this is the most beloved waffle?! You tried, you tasted, you felt differently. This recipe called out to me when I read the paper but now I think I’ll put it at the bottom of my pile. Thanks;)

    Like

  8. Phoebe Avatar
    Phoebe

    I made those waffles this weekend too and I liked them okay. Maybe I have a high butter tolerance. Mine didn’t brown as nicely and evenly as I would’ve liked, but I chalked it up to inexperience with using my waffle iron (once a year, max), and not getting the settings right. Still, they weren’t the Best!Waffles!Ever! or anything, so I’ll probably continue to try other recipes.

    Like

  9. Aime Avatar
    Aime

    I spent a blissful year living in Kew Gardens. I would go for it… there is a cute independent movie theater on Lefferts.

    Like

  10. radish Avatar

    (Oh dear, Forest Hills! The boyfriend and I are both on a FH bender – we keep sighing at all the green things and the beauty there. I love it. And I’m a Brooklyn-is-the-coolest-borough girl. Did you see the Trolley House by the way?? As for teh waffles – I have made a version of yeast-based waffles a few times a couple of years ago, when not a weekend would go by sans waffle consumption – they never quite turned out right and I chalked it up to a bad recipe – it happens… i wonder if yeast isn’t the kind of thing that works well with waffles… hmmm..)

    Like

  11. MichaelQ Avatar

    A stick of butter does sound like a bit much for 16 waffles, but I imagine a slow rising time in the fridge (as opposed to the 1-2 hours on your counter) would dramatically affect the flavor.
    Wouldn’t you have a similarly poor result if you let a brioche rise on a counter instead of in the fridge?
    (But, it’s not like you have to love something everybody else does, anyways.) Good luck with your future endeavors and thanks for the wonderful site!)
    (oh btw, I love making the Indian Spiced Chicken you posted a while back, it rocks!)

    Like

  12. Caroline Avatar

    My favorite posts are the honest ones that admit when things go wrong… or just aren’t good. And, I love how you even did parentheses within parentheses… bold. Very bold. (if you don’t mind me saying so)

    Like

  13. Lia Avatar

    Forest Hills? Ever since I heard you didn’t love your time in Brooklyn, I thought you’d stay in Manhattan forever. But now that I hear you’re venturing to outer boroughs, I have to put my vote in for Brooklyn, since I really think you’d love living there with Ben. But you know me, I’m totally biased 🙂
    Oh and so sad to hear about the waffles! I’m still dying to try those shortbread ones that Molly posted. Talk about a lot of butter — I think there’s two sticks in that recipe!

    Like

  14. Cindy Avatar

    I haven’t tried this recipe but it looks similar to the recipe in Cook’s Illustrated that we love. The procedure there is different. And I mucked with it to make it easier for us. You might give it a try. To us they are the best waffles. My boys prefer them to chocolate waffles. http://wherewasthatrecipe.blogspot.com/2007/04/yeasted-waffles.html

    Like

  15. Kim Walker Avatar

    I love the playgrounds, trees, etc, in Forest Hills, the neighborhood-ness of it, and I find it pretty Manhattan-accessible, but the dining options leave something to be desired. There are places to eat, even decent ones, but only one or two that I’m over-the-top in love with.
    No greenmarket (unless you have a car), but there’s a CSA.
    Actually, I’m finding myself rambling, then editing. If you would like to know what I think about food shopping and dining in Forest Hills, let me know. I think I’m a little overeager to share my opinion.
    What kind of waffle iron do you use? I threw my cheap one out and now I only get waffles when we go out.

    Like

  16. Mercedes Avatar

    Ok, being the waffle-fiend I am, I have always wanted to make these, but I never have. Dare I admit I am kind of glad they weren’t so impressive, so that I can go on making my very-delicious-ready in minutes-waffles without the guilt? I’m almost relieved.
    Eeek, I get squeemish at talk of boroughs too (don’t get me wrong, I love Brooklyn, it’s just…). But really, Forest Hills is very nice, and there is that whole space thing. No matter what, hope you find something you both like!

    Like

  17. molly Avatar

    (woo brooklyn!)
    (and OY with the apartment-looking and rent-calculating. I have been there, although never quite managed to find that spacious two bedroom with a view.)
    (was this the waffle recipe in The Breakfast Book? I’m pretty sure our ‘house’ waffles when I was growing up came out of her The Breakfast Book, but I don’t remember any yeast nonsense, so I might be wrong. But Marion usually is so reliable. hmmm.)

    Like

  18. Lydia Avatar

    How disappointing that the beautiful waffle in your photo didn’t really appeal to you. Ah, well, it happens.
    (As for FH, I’d say go for the trees. After growing up in NYC, and then spending 25 years in Boston’s South End, I’ve gone for the trees in northwest Rhode Island — and I highly recommend it. Our daughter lives in Jackson Heights, in one of those buildings with an interior garden shared by all of the abutting buildings. Before that she lived in Williamsburg, which was cool, but there’s nothing better than a few trees and flowers at the end of a long work day.)

    Like

  19. ann Avatar

    Dude, I don’t like waffles, so you’re still my friend. For some reason, they seem like, heh, tarts to me. They smell so wonderful and then the flavor just doesn’t live up to the promise, like a pretty, vapid girl. Anyway, we’re not here to talk about waffles, we’re here to talk about real estate…
    If you’re a little bored with Manhattan I can honestly say, moving out to the “burbs” is a great thing. Plus, you can always move back to the island, it’s not a permanent exile 😉

    Like

  20. bittermelon Avatar
    bittermelon

    I really like this recipe for the original Belgian waffles in Saveur, and it’s much simpler:
    http://www.saveur.com/food/classic-recipes/belgian-waffles-51875.html

    Like

  21. Luisa Avatar

    Mary – I’m not the biggest cake-y waffle fan, but I have to say that the buckwheat ones that we made (linked in the post) were just lovely, too. Worth pulling your waffle iron out of storage!
    Anne – yes, yes, you’re right! I’m currently caught in what can only be called the biggest bout of indecision EVER.
    Amy – Isn’t it pretty, though? Oh, sigh…And yes, SO far away. But Brooklyn? Really? Ben’s a fan and I’m not. Oh dear.
    Leah – that is a good point. And cool t-shirt!
    Stephanie – I’ve heard a lot of good things about Sunnyside. I find Jackson Heights appealing in the same way, all that interesting food to discover!
    Sharon – it’s good to know that FH engenders homesickness, too!
    Anne – Thank YOU!
    Phoebe – I’m not alone! Thank you! 🙂
    Aime – That independent movie theater definitely is a big mark in the PRO’S list…
    Radish – haven’t seen the Trolley House yet. So funny that you guys also like Forest Hills. Interesting that your yeasted waffle experience wasn’t stellar either. Maybe it’s just a taste thing!
    MichaelQ – you are the voice of reason, for sure, and I think you’re probably right. So glad you like the site! And that Indian chicken! It is good, isn’t it?
    Caroline – Thank you! (And I don’t mind at all, no way). 🙂
    Lia – those shortbread waffles sound KILLER. I don’t think I could handle them, they’re far too much waffle for this woman. As for Brooklyn, I think Ben’s on board, but I’m still (ugh) waffling. I couldn’t help it! Sorry! 🙂
    Cindy – I’ll keep that one in mind for next time, maybe!
    Kim – oh please please please, do share some more about Forest Hills food, CSA, markets (even if you need a car), etc. I’d love to know a food-interested person’s perspective. Thank you! I use a Krups waffle maker that my stepmother gave me a few years ago. I’m not sure if it’s a regular waffle iron or a Belgian one, though.
    Mercedes – I know exactly what you mean, on both counts!
    Molly – oh, I know you know. So, wouldn’t you say that that 2-bedroom with a leafy view is something we just need to jump on? Oh man, I am just so torn. I can’t remember now if this recipe is in the Breakfast Book, but I imagine that it is…
    Lydia – that’s good advice – I’m totally over the cool factor (I think), but I still can’t seem to get on board with living in what seems so undeniably a suburb. I need a few more sleepless nights to stew over it, I guess.
    Ann – another voice of reason! I read your comment about 4 times and nodded, relieved, each time. Yes! It doesn’t have to be forever! Sigh…
    Bittermelon – yow, that’s a lot of butter! But it sure does sound good, and what a pedigree…

    Like

  22. Melissa Avatar

    You are too funny! I love hearing the rants just as much as the raves. It shows you have a discriminating palate! 🙂 p.s. Not having set foot in NYC since I was eight I obviously can’t help with the apartment quandry, but I know you’ll make the right decision. Just go with your gut.

    Like

  23. Patrice Avatar
    Patrice

    I’ve been making that waffle recipe for a couple of years now with amazing results. It’s our family’s favorite breakfast. The ingredient list is exactly the same, but mine says to add the eggs in the morning along with the baking soda. Maybe that makes the difference in the texture? These come out so good!! Not sure it would account for the yellow-ish hue you described. Mine are golden brown on both sides – I use an old waffle iron that’s been around forever. Don’t give up – these waffles are worth the time and effort!!

    Like

  24. Vanessa Avatar
    Vanessa

    Your blog is lovely, your writing being entertaining and the food delicious. I only have one objection, which was a comment you made on your May 22nd post, saying that most English sandwiches are a terrifying prospect!
    As an English person, I completely disagree with that. We have some wonderful sandwiches, partly because we have such delicious cheeses –
    Two types of farmhouse Lancanshire cheeses, one which is creamy (mild, matured by hand for 2-3 months) and crumbly (slightly acidic, bright white and matured for only 6 weeks.)
    Farmhouse cheddar – a nutty strong cheese, matured for 16 months
    And so many more – Double Gloucester, delicious white or blue Wensleydale, Chesire, Caerphilly, Red Leicester (my home town’s cheese!) and many others, too many to name.
    How can our sandwiches be bad when they tend to have such wonderful cheeses in them?
    An example, is the “ploughman’s lunch” – a thick slice of cheese, usually cheddar, sometimes Stilton, and some kind of tangy or spicy pickle, like Branstons Pickle or Piccalilli in a crusty buttered bap. A salad on the side and other common additions like half an apple, pickled vegetables or pate.
    Or a Ploughman’s steak sandwich – seared fillet and onions, fruity chutney and cheddar.
    Welsh Rarebit – a cheese white sauce including splash of beer and spoon of mustard, spread onto hot toast and briefly grilled. There is the “Buck Rarebit”, with has the addition of a poached egg, Yorkshire Rarebit with bacon, Irish Rarebit with onions, vinegar, herbs and gerkins.
    Theres many more examples. Although it has that reputation abroad, English food really isn’t bad. A peek at one of Jane Grigson’s books demonstrates this nicely.

    Like

  25. Ian Avatar
    Ian

    Woo Queens! My girlfriend and I are two more who moved to Sunnyside (about a year and a half ago), and we really love it. Of course, we’re not really city people to begin with, but I think even hardened urbanites benefit from neighborhood gardens and balconies for tomato-growing.
    I don’t know a whole lot about the Forest Hills CSA, but it’s supplied by the same farm as ours in Sunnyside. (Stephanie, are you a member by any chance?) Golden Earthworm Organic Farm is out on the north fork of Long Island, and has been supplying us with really great produce so far this year (usually about five or six bunches/heads/pints/whatever a week).
    Also, you “forgot” to mention Russ Parson’s citation of this blog in the waffle article. Congrats! 🙂

    Like

  26. Victoria Carr Avatar

    I am totally puzzled. I absolutely LOVE these waffles, and I have never made them for weekend guests in the country who have failed to swoon and faint while eating them with local maple syrup. I do know, however, that the recipe I use, which is directly from Ms. Cunningham’s Breakfast Book, calls for the milk to be warmed and the batter to be left out overnight on the counter and not in the refrigerator, which could make a big difference. Luisa, I would give this recipe another try making those two changes.

    Like

  27. Lisa (Homesick Texan) Avatar

    Forest Hills is so un-NYC (in a good way). A friend lives out there (she owns a place and she and her husband love it) and she mentioned for a whole week she left her car window rolled half-way down (while the car was parked on the street, no less) and not one thing was stolen. Sounds like a lovely neighborhood, plus you get to read on the train! (I’m not being snarky–that is the one thing I miss about a commute, having all that built-in reading time added to my day.) Good luck with your decision–Melissa and Ann are so right, just go with your gut and nothing’s permanent.

    Like

  28. Mary Avatar

    What a relief – I have great respect for Marion Cunningham and have cooked from her books for years. A few years ago, I made those waffles for the first (and last) time. My results were like yours: greasy, heavy, flabby and crisp at the same time. I decided that that recipe just wasn’t meant to be for me and pushed on.

    Like

  29. Patrice Avatar
    Patrice

    An addendum to my previous post…I mentioned that my version of Marion’s recipe calls for adding the eggs in the morning with the baking soda, it also says to leave the yeast mixture out at room temp overnight (not in the fridge). Another person (Victoria, I think) mentioned this as well. Perhaps you got a bogus copy of Marion’s recipe. You have to make these again because they totally rock! We’ll be looking for your future post “raised waffles redux”.

    Like

  30. Julie Avatar

    (Could the problem be your waffle iron rather than the waffle recipe?)
    (I quote from Cooks llustrated: “No matter how foolproof the recipe, all waffles will be rubbery and flaccid if cooked in the wrong waffle iron.”)
    (Lots of the small, newer, cheaper waffle makers (which would be what I have) don’t let you adjust the heat so they’re not hot enough or too hot, and/or they don’t heat evenly. All the problems you describe could be attributed to that. Just a possibility.)
    (I dream of trading my cheapo (and rarely used) waffle iron in on a restored model from the 1940s or 1950s from a place like this which sells waffle irons from an era when they were solidly built: http://www.toastercentral.com/waffles.htm )
    (One of these days I’m going to throw caution and fiscal responsibility to the wind and just go ahead and do it.)
    (I once spent a week in Forest Hills. I loved it.)
    (Is it my imagination, or does the use of parentheses encourage everyone to leave longer comments?)

    Like

  31. Luisa Avatar

    Melissa – my gut is currently KILLING me. With the indecision. And the nerves. Stupid gut.
    Patrice and Victoria – okay, I’ll try these again sometime with your amendments. Maybe that will do the trick!
    Vanessa – I agree with you that English cheeses are absolutely delectable. And I’ve had some seriously amazing meals at gastropubs in London. Modern English food is delicious! I think my affection for Nigel Slater is a good indication of my feelings on the matter. In my comment, I was referring to the mayonnaise-laden, squishy bread sandwiches cut into triangles.
    Ian – thank you! 🙂 And tomato-growing, be still my beating heart. We’re looking at another place with a balcony out there and the thought of My Very Own Plants has me weak in the knees.
    Lisa – you’re absolutely right – the nothing’s permanent thing is a good thing to remember. And train reading! I do miss that, too.
    Mary – AHA! I am so relieved – you have no idea!
    Julie – (I think you might be right about the parentheses.) 🙂 As for my waffle iron, it’s a heavy-duty Krups one and is quite the champ – every other waffle we’ve made with it has been perfect, so I’m not entirely sure that that’s the problem…

    Like

  32. Vanessa Avatar
    Vanessa

    I’m glad to see that you’re a Nigel Slater fan, I adore his newspaper articles, books and cooking programme. Not only is he a good cook, I think, but an exquisite food writer.

    Like

  33. Susan from Food Blogga Avatar

    Upon seeing your scrumptious photo, I just assumed you were going to rave about this recipe. Sorry it wasn’t everything you had expected, but the pic sure is appetizing.

    Like

  34. Randi Avatar

    If you can find it( Williams sonoma carries it). Carbon’s malt waffle flour is the BEST. I’ve introduced it to a few people and they absolutely love it. Try it and let me know what you think.
    I used to live in Forest Hills but I was a baby so I have no recollection of it.

    Like

  35. Bakerina Avatar

    Coming so late to the party on this, but I figured you could use the distraction from the Mouse Problem. My own yeast-raised waffle of choice is Mollie Katzen’s recipe from Sunlight Cafe. I don’t have it to hand right now, but I’m pretty sure she calls for much less yeast; because I used instant yeast, I scale it back somewhat. I don’t know that I’ve ever used more than a teaspoon of yeast — maybe 1 1/2 tsp., max. Mollie also calls for 6 tbsp. butter. I usually cut this in half, brown it (as for beurre noisette)and then add it to the batter. You do have to crank the waffle iron to the maximum setting, and it never gets quite as crisp as it does with the full complement of butter, but it’s close enough for rock & roll. Lately we’ve been accompanying our waffles with the “Zim Eats Waffles” episode from our Invader Zim dvd’s. It’s the only way to eat waffles, I’ll tell you.
    Incidentally, on the apartment search, there’s a part of me that wants to urge you to move to Astoria, so we can be neighbors. Then I think of all the poor youngsters at my local coffee bar who talk of looking for, oh, eight or nine months before finding the right apartment in Astoria, and I think that maybe I should not encourage you to make yourself even more exhausted. Even though it would be boss if we were neighbors. 🙂

    Like

  36. Luisa Avatar

    Randi – thanks for the tip, malted waffles sound totally irresistible!
    Jen – I think Astoria would be lovely! But it’s true that the stuff available right now isn’t blowing me away. I’m still looking though! Queens is groovy, man, and all that good food….

    Like

  37. Ellen Avatar
    Ellen

    Wow – a waffle recipe can generate alot of comments, along with house hunting in NYC, of course. And I have a couple comments about the waffles – I made them for a large party with several borrowed waffle irons and found that they cook better on irons that make thin waffles not the thicker Belgian waffles. It looks from your photo that you have a Belgain waffle iron and that might account for the textural problem. And the recipe I’ve used calls for adding the eggs and baking soda in the morning not the night before. Just my 2 cents.

    Like

  38. TRACY Avatar
    TRACY

    Just a note: I’ve seen several warnings that this recipe does NOT perform well in a Belgian -style waffle iron. From the picture you posted (looks A+ on that side!), I’m thinking you used a Belgian…

    Like

  39. Brooke Avatar
    Brooke

    I know it’s really late to chime in on this on this topic, but oh well. Here goes! I’ve tried this recipe as adapted my Mitchell Davis (from the Fanny Farmer book). We eat waffles just about every weekend, and my waffle maker turns out consistently great waffles every time. When I first read the yeast-raised recipe, I had to try it. I used the slightly warm milk and left it on my counter overnight (with, uh, the eggs mistakenly added the 1st time), and got the exact same results as you! Since I love waffles & M.D. (and the thought of having my batter prepped & ready to go in the morning), I’ve tried them again a few times since, tweaking things here & there, with the same results. I’m also not nuts about the flavour, which is quite strong. My current favourite waffle recipe is a smoked cheddar & green onion waffle with some asparagus (or broccoli), a poached egg, and homemade salsa on top. Beats the pants off Fanny Farmer!

    Like

  40. Julie F Avatar
    Julie F

    This is a great recipe. We made them every Christmas eve for breakfast Christmas morning. They do need to rise overnight. Crisp on the outside, tender inside, more delectable than any baking soda/powder waffle I’ve ever had.

    Like

  41. SharonO Avatar
    SharonO

    I have made these waffles for 20 year, the first time for breakfast birthday party for 4 year olds. Huge, huge success. I’ve made them precisely as the recipe states, on the counter overnight, eggs & baking soda in the morning and I’ve mixed up the batter and cooked them right then and there. Without fail they are perfect every single time. Light, crispy and delicious and the house smells cozy and warm. I have a regular Black and Decker waffle iron, not a Belgian. Maybe they aren’t everyone’s taste but they sure are ours! We gobbled them up with peppered maple bacon after wiping away the tears the joy for Obama’s inauguartion.

    Like

  42. lieben Avatar

    Interessante Informationen.

    Like

  43. seajohncook Avatar

    we’ve made these several times with mixed results. Sometimes like light and crispy clouds other times soggy blops. Continue to make them and discover where i go amiss. When they are good they are most excellent and not they are not.
    good luck.
    j

    Like

  44. kempthead Avatar
    kempthead

    I’m sorry to see this venerable waffle recipe dissed so prominently on the basis of a single attempt that took major liberties with the procedure. Fannie Farmer’s Boston Cooking School Cookbook was published 113 years ago, and there’s a reason this recipe has survived and flourished. I have made it dozens, if not hundreds, of times, and like Ian, have never failed to get raves from family and guests. I have never found a baking powder recipe for waffles that can approach its rich, crisp, buttery goodness.
    In fact, I just cooked about 50 of them — a quadruple batch — for a “waffle frolic” my son and I put on every year for friends in Halifax, Nova Scotia.
    This recipe is intended to rise for 8-12 hours, not 1-2. This is major difference, and could account for your unhappy results.
    Like Patrice and Melissa, I also wonder if your waffle iron could be the culprit. Until a few years ago, I never thought a modern waffle iron could match the results of the old fashioned nickle plated model in my mother’s kitchen. Recently, however, I discovered a Cuisinart model WAF-R . It adjusts easily for preferred brownness, it cues the cook when it’s hot enough for batter, cues again when the waffle is done, rarely sticks, and delivers consistent waffles time after time. Most important, it produces waffles with many small, deep pockets for syrup, rather than the few large shallow indentations of so many modern waffle makers.
    Still another possibility is that we have very different taste in waffles. I do like crisp buttery waffles, while cakey ones leave me bored and dissatisfied.
    This is a lovely blog, but I entreat readers not to accept this one misfire as the final word on a recipe that has given hundreds of thousands of cooks, and their families and guests, untold pleasure.

    Like

  45. Dan Maranci Avatar

    Agreed with the post just above – you really have to let the batter rise without refrigeration overnight, and should add the egg and baking soda in the morning. I do also cut the butter to half a stick, and brown it for more flavor (or sometimes subsitute 1/4 cup canola oil). I also substitute malted barley syrup for the sugar, it adds color and flavor, though the yeast flavor is what shines through. This waffle should comes out like a light, crispy brioche in waffle form.

    Like

  46. Luisa Avatar

    Tracy – indeed, I think you’re right! I’ve heard many times since making these that the Belgian waffle iron is a no-go with this recipe.
    Kempthead – You flatter me: I hardly think my post would be the final word on this famous recipe! The waffle iron seems to have been the main culprit here – sadly I now no longer own one so it will be a while before I can make any kind of waffle again. When the next time comes, I’ll make sure to make this batter the night before.

    Like

Leave a comment